TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk

Michael Carrick

Join the Man Utd fan discussion on TalkingPoints around all the latest Michael Carrick news, opinions, polls and updates.

1,260 comments

Now the dust has settled, what was the biggest reason why Michael Carrick failed at Man United?

A

abiolakuye76d ago

In my own point of view. Carrick failed becos He refuses to continue what he started when he came in as interim coach. Again the board didnt help matters during requitment. He refuses to speak out like Ruben. He was a puppet of the board just to keep is job.

J

jjflash4226d ago

He spent nearly £170 mill,get in the real world.Thats a lot of money.and you're so wrong in comparing michael+Ruben.Ruben knew he was out of his depth,saw maresca bottle out@ chls and he did the same.he bottled it,cried to the media to get paid off.Carrick is much classier,he kept his mouth shut and did his best.Didnt work but is still loved.

E

eoin7d ago

He wasnt ready for the size of the job. Think its really as simple as that. Not enough characters!

K

kilham.max7d ago

Board let him down by not strengthening the defensive department. However, I feel Carrick lacked in the tactical department – there seemed to be no set style of play.

Open full discussion →

Youri Tielemans has urged Man Utd NOT to sack Michael Carrick - What do you make of his comments?

D

davecarey2821d ago

He needs to improve his own form as do 99% of the others except Lammens. But good he came out to back him, not sure now if Carrick is going to last it is all uphill.

S

ssahibdeen821d ago

I was thinking that Lammens should have done better with the first goal. Didn’t make himself big the way De Gea would have.

D

darlisox22d ago

He is right the boys are very lazy

D

dancoombs20d ago

They have got to realise their own places at the club are on the line, it’s not just Carrick. If they even care

G

geldroper22d ago

He has to be forched to use our youth. If he is not using Amass instead of loser Dalot and Lacey he should be fired

S

stephenjholmes122d ago

I have been saying that for months, and someone said that it would be bad for the team to play them. What could be worse than losing every game? That is all we are doing. Play academy players. Not all at once, but we need to do something. Give Amass or Heaven time at lb. Give Lacey the second half. Do nothing, expect nothing.

Open full discussion →

Honest opinion... will Michael Carrick survive the 2026/27 season at United?

We want Michael Carrick to SUCCEED at Man Utd - but the season has started badly...

B

billycrabtree235d ago

Its not the manager this time its them above him. They have got the wrong players CARRICK WILL get it good again and get the players buzzing.

D

deansexton4635d ago

i think Carrick Is great but the players are lazy ATM but he will bring them in line no doubt

S

stuartongley1537d ago

I personally agree with Lisandro on what he said, and that he should be backed for calling out Wilcox for players not purchased as in Hall, then Angelo Stiller instead of Youri Tielemans. Wilcox and Glazers Out, not Michael

Open full discussion →

Any united fan who wants rashford back in the team is part of the problem

B

barryroberts7265d ago

I didn't want him back at the club full stop and i personally think he will leave on a free because of his wages, he's just going to keep playing for the money.

Open full discussion →

What is your ADVICE to Michael Carrick after a poor start to the 2026/27 season?

A

apgcfrg23d ago

Do you mean postion🤣

D

deansexton4655d ago

stop playing players out of possession

P

plattysared562d ago

Get tough or get out, no place in this game for Mr Nice guy, stop being everyones mates & put them in their place!!!!

Open full discussion →

What are Michael Carrick's three biggest priorities this summer to prepare for 2026/27?🤔

The Manchester United head coach has so much work to do...

R

roycheong18130d ago

Need to add one or two academies to senior squared to strengthen the squard.

T

thehayneses139d ago

Mount is an International midfielder and gets around the opposition well. Start the season with him alongside Mainoo with confidence.

D

dancoombs136d ago

I do think he will get a prominent chance in preseason to show what he can do

G

geldroper143d ago

why is nobody thinking about Colyber. When he played in Man U he was pretty good

Open full discussion →

Aim for next season has got be trying to win fa Cup or carbo Cup to start and be competitive in champions league as well with few good signings I think that more than acceptable don't think we be challenging for league just as remember it sprit not a race that what I be happy with

J

jwhitbread62182d ago

Yes, top four and a cup! Would love a run in Europe too

T

taylorjoe41183d ago

Yeah agree with that buddy, a good run in the cups we won’t win the CL or the PL next season but have a good run in both. Maybe the season after we can have a real go at the PL.

J

jonny183d ago

All about building towards it, who knows maybe we strengthen enough this summer and it is enough to get us in a title race… this season with a better midfield and Amorim gone earlier we would be in a title race

J

jonny184d ago

I agree; Top 4, at least UCL quarter finals and a cup trophy 🏆 would be a good season

Open full discussion →

What is your INSTANT REACTION as Man United confirm Carrick appointment 🔥

Deserved? Or are you concerned?

G

geldroper140d ago

With this not buying players they are setting Carrick up for failure. It is embarrising that aclub this big are so viscious

G

grantfeast172d ago

I'd like to see Carrick smile and nod appreciatively occasionally whilst on the side lines during the matches. Yes, do the moody thing too like every other manager but show passion with energy. Utd fans are a special breed and back our teams and players and managers well beyond others. Utd are the best club in the world

D

dantowen81951172d ago

100%, I’ve really come over to the idea that a Man United manager needs to be a statesman who - first and foremost - understands the pressure of the club

D

dantowen81951182d ago

One thing he has over Iraola and co - Carrick has proven he can win games at OT! That should not be underestimated, especially as so many talented coaches have struggled amid higher expectations at a bigger club

Open full discussion →

Brilliant Carrick performance against Forest. I'm very content with the fact he'll be in charge next season.

A

adnan.riaz184d ago

All for Carrick. It's just a given now.

S

seanfisher185d ago

I love the fact that he's not afraid to open games up and just go for it! Exciting football back at Old Trafford

A

adnan.riaz184d ago

My Gaffer. 🫡

Open full discussion →

Michael Carrick should be given the job , So he has the opportunity to compete with the elite Managers by having the team there and there abouts challenging for titles

A

adnan.riaz191d ago

Where do you think he would finish in the Premier League table next season amid all of the fixtures that we will have to play?

L

lyyncs187d ago

In the top 3 in the premiership challenging City and Arsenal

Open full discussion →

Michael Carrick and Sir Jim Ratcliffe are set for 'formal talks' over the Man Utd job / What is your reaction?

A

asulaiterchs186d ago

It's a well done sir God bless 🙏🙏🙏🙏

B

barbecue223187d ago

He deserves it,let give him the job.

S

seanfisher186d ago

Exactly! He couldn’t have done much more

O

opudoh187d ago

luiz is more experience more than csrrick

G

geldroper184d ago

and not availbe and too expensive and would want to bring another stile with another 500 million on so so players. No thank you

Open full discussion →

Imagine Carrick is the first English manager to win the Prem…

S

seanfisher186d ago

If Arteta can do it… so can super Michael Carrick!

C

chillout192d ago

A

adnan.riaz194d ago

Give him a knighthood ASAP.

Open full discussion →

Still think he’s the man for the job, but I do not want to be watching that stuff again. That was awful.

A

adnan.riaz194d ago

A point is a point. Fergie did the same at times.

Open full discussion →

MC deserved a permanent job 💪💪💪

A

adnan.riaz194d ago

It would be stupid to not even try it at this point.

C

callumfoy197d ago

Agreed. Think he has to be given the full-time role now.

Open full discussion →

Don't you just love the fact that ex United players yes you Gary Neville want to put your views across, never mind stick to commentating on Sky.

A

adnan.riaz194d ago

Gary Neville, man. Like a broken record that man.

Open full discussion →

Stats say he's the first English football manager to win 8 or more of his first nine home premier league games, that speaks volumes.

A

adnan.riaz194d ago

Gaffer energy.

D

dancoombs201d ago

Impressive stat

Open full discussion →

He deserves a full season. The team wants to perform for him. Fans love him. Given our position when he took over he's performing a miracle 3rd is nowhere where we want to be.... We were 15th last season and we gave him a go #weareunited

A

adnan.riaz194d ago

No doubt about it. Even if it's on a two-year or summat. This has been a really good audition period for him.

C

callum_boyle201d ago

I was hesitant about this at first but I agree now. He commands the respect of the players and has made the side more tactically astute

Open full discussion →

Fully support Michael to be next manager, he has been doing well since arrival , Neville was a failed coach , he & Keane are simply ENVY to Michael

A

adnan.riaz194d ago

His hotel is stationed rent-free in Roy Keane's head.

F

freddie204d ago

I just think they know the risks of giving it to someone who doesn't have the experience...

S

stephenjholmes1193d ago

Ask Barcelona what happened when they appointed an un proven novice. They seemed to do ok out of it. And the coach in question is doing OK at the other side of Manchester.

V

vatsal204d ago

Of course. Especially because experienced maestros like Van Gaal and Mourinho rewrote record books at Utd.

Open full discussion →

Michael Carrick is a good leader and he is a coach of the year

A

adnan.riaz194d ago

F

freddie205d ago

Coach of the year is a bit far

Open full discussion →

Carrick says Top 5 isn't enough. Honestly, based on his run, do you think we are a genuine Title Contender for next season?

A

abduali0921864316161d ago

Nice

M

mombasashipchandlersltd184d ago

i just have a feeling Carrick will do it next season let us give him two defenders Marcos Senesi & Hall, Three Middle fielders Tonali , Ederson, Balela, Then get Bowen and Lewandowski (free) am telling you will win this League

J

jonny184d ago

That is a very ambitious summer! Lewandowski for free feels too good to refuse!

C

contehmohamedmuzain185d ago

Sure

Open full discussion →

Still think areola is perfect for utd at end of season.Carrick has done well but he's not areola.Hes innovative,forward thinking,his players flog themselves for him,he improves players so much.I wish the club would change their thinking,he's ideal for a lengthy period.I think he's too much class to be into Chelsea,who 1 bad spell,they chuck their gaffer.

D

damian.p.turner202d ago

Why change to another manager he's a mid table manager in my opinion, managing a team where all the big names are sold off so doesn't have to worry about conflict or players demand, has no real experience of Cl yet people want him. For me he's a step backwards. I know you'll say well Carrick hasn't any Cl experience either. But he does have team that's impo

V

vatsal209d ago

I feel Iraola lacks a plan B (Remind you of any Portuguese manager?). He's so press-focused that it's hard to see how his style translates to a team that will have the ball 60% of the time.

Open full discussion →

good coach at the moment

E

ebenezeromotosho63d ago

He had the team spirit broken when he accepted Rashford back into the team. The. Successsof MU relys hevealy on out out. Wings. Rooney, rolaaldo, gigges,... Once that wing play fail to cross ball... Or soore... Also his team work stylee of passing discipline collapsed this season due to the new arrivals...

A

adnan.riaz192d ago

He's cooked so far. He really has.

Open full discussion →

Chelsea have fired Liam Rosenior - he has been an epic failure compared to Michael Carrick! Where has it gone right at United, and wrong at Chelsea?

Man Utd were level on points with Chelsea when Ruben Amorim was sacked!

S

steveex2005211d ago

Chelsea have been on the slide since they sacked Tuchel, a coach I would love to see at United.

V

vatsal209d ago

Tuchel would have been such an interesting one. I'm convinced he would have crashed and burned by the end but definitely would have won a major trophy in the process

H

henryngoro14212d ago

should have given him time

S

seanfisher213d ago

I think it comes down to respect too… this United squad has a lot of respect for Carrick.. something Rosenior never had at Chelsea

Open full discussion →

All the comments making out Carrick and Holland are miracle workers 🤣 we have been genuinely poor since the first 2 games, just been lucky with moments and the end result. After the Leeds game I fear trouble ahead but either way we should be getting a better manager and players if we want to compete for trophies. Amorim had won.. What's Carrick won?

R

rbrown0806206d ago

Correct. Not been convincing at all. We rarely dominate a game against any opposition. Lucky to beat a Brentford Team, who left their shooting boots at home. We coyld easiky have conceded 4 or 5.

W

winva2002208d ago

U do not understand football. What u expect ? Manager , witch never lose ?

R

richmatt22206d ago

What are you on about? 🤣

G

geldroper213d ago

where have you been for the last 8 games. yes they need better players but nobody bu you are saying that they are miracle workersbut that doesn't makke them bad coaches. We do not need coaches who want to spend unreal money. we neeed players who bleed Man U just as we fans what you are surely not

R

richmatt22213d ago

OMG what has happened to this fan base. Carrick and Holland hardly have the players working their socks off do they. Where have you been for some of the last eight games becs9as good as City and Arsenal were, Leeds and West Ham were shocking by the players in terms of effort and application. 2 nil down and a man sent off before trying!

Open full discussion →

Is Michael Carrick the right man? United have only won one of the last four games...

W

winva2002208d ago

United fans are one of the best, and in same time one of the worst. Football today, and before, for the elite manager is psihologic. Anceloti say i one moment "what to say to Ibrahimovic, how to play football ?No, it is elite plyer, and my job is to make him motivated in every game." If u have player group witch belive in u, u are already done great.

W

winva2002208d ago

and yes, Carick is the right man. I am sure, if Carick stay, we will fight for title next season. I see that 100%

D

daniel.owen214d ago

I do place a lot of importance on a manager who understands the pressure of playing for United, a la Zidane at Real. Amorim always seemed to underestimate that

E

ebaalobi4215d ago

With what he has done so far i believe with the backing of INEOS and the entire Manchester United board, he is the right man for the job. Thanks.

V

vatsal214d ago

Which players in the summer transfer window do you think will truly prove that Ineos back Carrick?

Open full discussion →

We need anderson he his a must

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Solsker is a pundit won fuckall as a manager got sacked useless

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Ole was also good but I think he did not get enough time and he loses simple matches We scored record goals there was positivety

V

vatsal227d ago

Absolutely agreed! Ole gets treated harshly when he did way better than "geniuses" like Ruben Amorim. Do you ever wonder how United would be doing now if he was appointed again instead of Carrick?

Open full discussion →

Carrick give the good sprit and togetherness that is help them to win and read the game

S

seanfisher229d ago

Would you give Carrick the job in the summer? 👀

A

ayelealemu1136228d ago

I would I think he knows the club and the players left and ryt

Open full discussion →

Michael Carrick please try to work very hard for United . To regain their value back to the team

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

To let the players do what they do

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

What position would Man Utd be in the league if Ole Gunnar Solskjaer was appointed instead of Michael Carrick?

How do you think it would have gone with Ole?

D

daniel.owen221d ago

Genuinely have no idea haha I feel like it wouldn't be much different from what we are seeing right now

A

adnan.riaz228d ago

Really hard to say. I would like to say fourth, but I'm leaning towards fifth... 😐

D

dancoombs229d ago

I think we would be around six points worse off. I like Ole but there was a lot history/hangover there. Carrick was more of a clean slate - and I don’t think anybody could have done better than he has

Open full discussion →

Carrick has my support,he deserves the opportunity

D

dale.odonnell233d ago

How long of a contract would you give, if the decision was yours?

P

paulskaufman231d ago

6 years

Open full discussion →

Michael carrick definitely for manger he has done a great job

E

ebukangene22234d ago

I agree with you

D

dancoombs234d ago

Carrick is definitely the lead choice at this stage, it’s also a struggle to find a compelling alternative who is available

Open full discussion →

Bringing back the familiar moments

D

dale.odonnell233d ago

Long may it last. Your favourite moment so far?

Open full discussion →

Kobie and Casemiro midfield.

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

YOU are Michael Carrick - Pitch why you should be permanent Man Utd manager to Ineos

Give us your two-line pitch...

C

colliewarrior219d ago

Ineos don’t know what they are doing and the two losses show that Carrick is clearly not the best available so no doubt he’ll get the job

S

shyllonmohamed132220d ago

Is the man

Z

zeke.wolf42226d ago

7W 2D 1L, beating both City and Arsenal well. The club needs to build around a functioning and stable leadership, which it hasn't had for most of a decade.

Open full discussion →

What is Michael Carrick's best decision at Man Utd so far?

O

olohunsanyashamsudeen232d ago

Good afternoon . I'm Olohunsanya Shamsudeen Akorede . From Federal Republic of Nigeria . Am a Manchester United fans . Since over a decade

V

vatsal227d ago

Belated welcome to a thriving Man Utd fan community mate! Make yourself heard!

C

chalmersa409234d ago

yes you are right i agree.things with carrick are so much better.with ruben everyone was struggling.

C

chalmersa409235d ago

i think playing the formation that suits are players.we are playing so much better than under ruben amorim.

V

vatsal1591996234d ago

I'm convinced he wanted to be seen as a tactical genius more than he wanted to win games. Neither happened at the end

A

adnan.riaz235d ago

It's crazy how such a simple thing has changed Man Utd altogether. 😭

Open full discussion →

Solidify our Defense and our midfield! Management should support him in this direction.

S

seanfisher243d ago

Who would be your top target for the summer?

Open full discussion →