
Now the dust has settled, what was the biggest reason why Michael Carrick failed at Man United?
abiolakuye76d ago
In my own point of view. Carrick failed becos He refuses to continue what he started when he came in as interim coach. Again the board didnt help matters during requitment. He refuses to speak out like Ruben. He was a puppet of the board just to keep is job.
jjflash4225d ago
He spent nearly £170 mill,get in the real world.Thats a lot of money.and you're so wrong in comparing michael+Ruben.Ruben knew he was out of his depth,saw maresca bottle out@ chls and he did the same.he bottled it,cried to the media to get paid off.Carrick is much classier,he kept his mouth shut and did his best.Didnt work but is still loved.
eoin1w ago
He wasnt ready for the size of the job. Think its really as simple as that. Not enough characters!
kilham.max1w ago
Board let him down by not strengthening the defensive department. However, I feel Carrick lacked in the tactical department – there seemed to be no set style of play.
adnan.riaz1w ago
One word: Ineos.
stephenjholmes11w ago
Sorry but Ineos have brought in a team of people to run the club. They clearly have got it wrong, but I am sure Wilcox & Berada will be gone as soon as SJR finds a replacement. Perfection isn't done overnight. Ask James Dyson how many failed attempts he had before putting his Vacum cleaner to market!
aryansurajc1w ago
I don’t think I should be saying this, but yes, his management was really questionable, and United were not able to pick the best 11. I think there needs to be some sort of balance in terms of chemistry. He was not able to boost the morale of the players and it seemed like he had no control over what was going on in th games.
stephenjholmes11w ago
You have every right to make that statement. Michael let us down, he let his players down, and he let the club down. I can only think that he doesn't have the intelligence for life as a manager, no other explanation can justify his decisions this season!
adnan.riaz1w ago
He was part of the blame, but it was not all because of him. There were so many things going wrong at the same time.
dakir.thanveer1w ago
Was never convinced Carrick was good enough (yet) to manage Manchester United full time. That said, United's problems run deeper than the manager. There is only so much Carrick can do with players like Dalot
stephenjholmes11w ago
The fact that he decided to continue with Dalot at left back says everything. He NEVER even gave Amass a chance! It is no coincidence that we are losing JJ Gabriel on his watch! If he continued we would be seeing lots more academy tallent running for the exit! United live and breath youth players, and Michael went against our ethos. No sympathy at all!
adnan.riaz1w ago
Dalot and Shaw still being at Man Utd sum up the sorry state they we are in. It’s just tragic now.
jordan.harris1w ago
I think he was always destined to fail. Any success or bright moments are in spite of the owners, not because of them
adnan.riaz1w ago
Equally, he couldn’t turn down the job because it is, well, Man Utd. Damned if you do, damned if you don’t.
vatsal1w ago
People wil say tactics or the window, but a key tenet that disconnected me quickly was his reluctance to use the youth. From the guy who have Tyler Fletcher his debut to whatever he (didn't) do this this season, it was baffling. Lacey Amass begged for more chances, and academy is flying. Nothing.
adnan.riaz1w ago
Surprised Dalot wasn’t mentioned here… 👀

stephenjholmes11w ago
That is Michael's biggest failing. United have trusted the youth throughout our history. You don't get the next superstar if you never give them a chance. Why are we buying up all the youth tallent if they won't get a chance to shine? I can't fault JJ's advisors for telling him to leave. Hopefully things will change under Poch! We live in hope!
peter.lynch1w ago
Really failed to address the key areas that needed strengthening… I also think this is an ageing team with a lot of dead wood. A fresh start is what the club needs and that starts with a new manager unfortunately for Carrick
stephenjholmes11w ago
We have an ageing team, but the people in charge of recruitment have decided the most stupid transfer strategy I have ever witnessed. Next season THE WHOLE DEFENCE is going to be changed in 1 go. Nothing can go wrong there🤔🤔. Clueless. Expect a relegation scrap if this continues!
stephenjholmes11w ago
We have an ageing team, but the idiots in charge of recruitment have decided the most stupid transfer strategy I have ever witnessed. Next season THE WHOLE DEFENCE is going to be changed in 1 go. Nothing can go wrong there🤔🤔. Clueless idiots. Expect a relegation scrap if this continues!
caleb.sage1w ago
Squad and man-management + tactics. United obviously have a team good enough not to be in the relegation zone. To be there has to fall on what the manager was doing with these players in training, on the pitch, in his set-up, mid-game etc.
adnan.riaz1w ago
His tactics were lacking this season, as well as the run of Steve Holland fading, too. Some of Carrick’s calls this season were terrible.
shamanth.jayaram1w ago
I think the players never really trusted him enough. Yeah, he did brilliantly last season, but it felt like some players thought they were bigger than him, which put him in an impossible position. Not being backed in the summer is also another big reason - United didn’t just need more players but they had to get rid of quite a few too
adnan.riaz1w ago
Like always, Keane said they would throw Ole under the bus and every Man Utd manager after him. The same repeat pattern from these so-called United players.
markmarston1w ago
Spot on. He was like the fun supply teacher last year that never made the players do the real work. Now the exams are here and they are failing because of poor preparation
seanfisher1w ago
Took the wrong approach in pre-season in my opinion. Eased off in training and the players started the season hugely lacking fitness and sharpness. That can’t run in the Premier League. At the same time, the board let him down over the summer and the players know it. Martinez spoke out about it, Bruno called for better recruitment. More was needed
stephenjholmes11w ago
Bang on fella! It started failing before a ball was kicked. The coaches never prepared the players at any level. We have too many people who aren't qualified to be coaching world class athletes. It feels like we are shopping at poundland for our coaches! Many ex-players with no top level experience are being used also. Save your mates for the pub!
will.butcher1w ago
He struggled to motivate his players, hence the poor starts at the start of a match or after HT. but i feel for carrick, it’s surely impossible to motivate a dressing room that he, through no fault of his own, had lost. The reason he had lost the dressing room was because the board had to sack him, it was only a matter of time
stephenjholmes11w ago
Any player should have enough motivation just by putting on the United shirt. If they need motivating they should never be at our amazing club. We are United. We are one of the top 4 clubs in world football. Part of the recruitment process should be about the players motivation for joining. If money is the answer, show them the exit Look at Poch. Desire!
dale.odonnell1w ago
Insufficient backing in the summer. Big let down, but it doesn’t excuse our league position which is why the incompetent owners and board ran out of patience.
stephenjholmes11w ago
The job of MC was to make the most of the tools at his disposal. He failed miserably. I do wonder who was calling the shots? How anyone with access to all the stats & match replays couldn't see the issues is beyond me. The refusal to even try different options (Amass & Lacey) is cowardly. Unfortunately he is solely responsible for his failure.
markmarston1w ago
I’d say he didn’t have a clear philosophy on how to play thru the lines and break down teams. It was high pressing and transitional vibes last season. Easy to work out and it all falls down when the players can’t be bothered to run
dale.odonnell1w ago
We did have plenty of philosophy in the past (Van Gaal), but the structure of the club was all wrong at the time. The problem was always top-to-bottom with the Glazers, esp after Fergie retired.
kyle.dimond1w ago
I’m so tempted to say that it has to be down to his experience but I’m really not sure even someone who has been in big, very demanding clubs could deal with this.
stephenjholmes11w ago
We can only wait in hope. Wilcox and Berada should have been sacked already, and SJR must be searching for their replacement. I could be wrong, but the failings of so many coaches has to seen as an issue at a higher level. I believe the WHOLE culture is rotten, and is being driven by ex-players. They have made United a meal-ticket for unqualified mates.
dale.odonnell1w ago
Had experience before and it didn’t work. It always goes back to the owners.
gls4united1w ago
Does anyone know why notifications directing talking points to United in Focus does not work
sunalike901w ago
BIGGEST MISTAKE IS SACKING OF MICHEAL CARRICK. EHY NOT GIVE HIM THAT OPPORTUNITY AND INSTALL HIM AS THE PERMANENT MANAGER, THEY DIDNT GIVE HIM ALL HE NEEDED TO REVIVE MAN UTD. TEAM SPIRIT IS BROKEN 💔😔.
jonathan.gorrie1w ago
The fact he was given the job in the first place? I'm sure United fans can point to more specifc reasonining within that but let's face it, he was never good enough to succeed in an actual full season. He was great for the very specific almost bespoke-like conditions of last season
stephenjholmes11w ago
Sorry but he was good enough last season. Yes in hindsight we can all say he was the wrong option, but I thought we would challenge this season. Failings were: poor preseason preparation (lack of fitness). Playing failing players. Terrible in game management. MC let himself down by not being brave. The academy players need to be used. Lacey, our best player
jonathan.gorrie1w ago
@jonathan.gorrie Think he seems like a decent bloke so its not about tearing him apart as a manager but there are levels to the game! Its ruthless
deansexton461w ago
cause they just couldn't be bothered, players got him sacked plain and simple
thetruthpersonified1w ago
Not right, but maybe cos they were poorly led, unfit and demotivated.
jjflash4221w ago
In game management was poor,starting games poorly,couldn't motivate the players,way too late to react in games,just no creative patterns.
dancoombs1w ago
Two reasons stand out- take your pick, 1) poor conditioning for the players. That’s on the coaching staff 2) major squad gaps unaddressed in summer. Striker and left-back were obvious concerns that went ignored