TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk

Next Man Utd manager

Join the fan discussion on TalkingPoints about who should be the next Man Utd manager.

783 comments

Big up MC HES PURE MU DNA

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

After watching Germany at the World Cup I am GLAD United did not go for Nagelsmann

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

kindly mr luiz

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

we as manchester united fans needs you luiz

S

seanfisher186d ago

Enrique? 👀👀

Open full discussion →

Iraola top of the list but Carrick is Man U to the core so I'd give him a chance. Apart from anything else the Players like and respect him.

J

jonny208d ago

I think Iraola thrives as the underdog, not sure he’d cope under the brightest lights

Open full discussion →

I read today that Ratcliff is unsure. He has made so many BAD decisions , if he doesn't feel Carrick is the right man, it must be the correct choice. I can't get over how clueless Ratcliff is, how did he ever get rich? He has been a disaster since he has come in. Carrick gets a 2 year contract, if he's brilliant, then extend it to 5 if he's crap, he goes.

B

brook010206d ago

Agree with you and jonathan.maze - it’s like a game of opposites! I can’t see any reason not to give him a go, he’s made such a difference

J

jonny208d ago

This is spot on. Appointing anybody else this summer unless it’s Luis Enrique is a needless risk. Chances are nobody will match the success Carrick has had, setting up a new manager to fail unless we give Carrick a proper chance.

Open full discussion →

Top of the B-list, for me. Plays good football and is ‘Prem proven’

D

dale.odonnell212d ago

Begs the question: who is on your A-list of candidates for the job?

Open full discussion →

Unai Emery

J

jf7dw878s8212d ago

what's he done with Villa? How is he an improvement?

D

dale.odonnell212d ago

Deserves to be on the list, but personally, I wouldn't go as far as to interview him for the job. Villa is his level.

J

jonny214d ago

Interesting! I don't know if he's too much in the Amorim/Frank bracket - he struggled at Arsenal.

Open full discussion →

Michael Carrick deserve United job than anyone as it's. Let the club give him 2years contract and see.

D

dancoombs215d ago

Two years, maybe three, does seem like a reasonable expectation. We have learned our lesson since we gave six to David Moyes

D

davecarey28213d ago

A very good point why do we give managers long contracts 2 to 3 years max

Open full discussion →

Managerial appointment

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Where does Andoni Iraola rank for you among Michael Carrick alternatives?

Would you want Iraola at Old Trafford, now he is ready for a new challenge?

W

warinj47201d ago

No where give me Michael Carrick any day

R

robsenga208d ago

Not anywhere near Carrick!! Please, for the sake of the club and fans, let’s fix our eyes on Carrick. the man saved us the heartache from Amorim! Am sure even Bruno and colleagues share the same feeling.

J

jf7dw878s8212d ago

He doesn't

Open full discussion →

Are you happy Manchester United opted not to appoint Roberto De Zerbi?

Roberto De Zerbi was no stranger to Manchester United links.

D

damian.p.turner217d ago

Carrick is the man for the job..... Look how it's transformed, the Leeds result was a shock. It's football it happens. However UCL football you have to give him a season to prove it wasn't a fluke. I would hate to see another manager come in and set us back.. We go forward #weareunited

D

dancoombs215d ago

This is a great point, do the players want to start all over again with a new manager? I suspect not

G

geldroper217d ago

next year gone from Tottenham for sure or yearlater.

V

vatsal229d ago

"Happy" is understating it. Would have been a disaster waiting to happen

Open full discussion →

If not Michael Carrick... WHO ELSE?

Can you name a good available alternative to Michael Carrick you actually want?

P

patrockslowkey208d ago

There isn't one. He proved he can handle pressure. He bleeds Man U blood. What More do we need. Wake up Ratcliffe

S

steveex2005209d ago

My 3 options, Tuchel, Zidane and Enrique are not available so it must be Carrick. If the owners have doubts then give him a one year contract. If he continues to do well then give him a 3 year one

N

nigel_shacklady209d ago

Anyone but Garath Southgate. I've been a United fan for 60 years and will stop watching them if its Southgate. I'd Sooner Amorim.

O

omar687mo203d ago

Exactly my thoughts too. It's going backwards if you get Southgate. My 55 years of supporting this club will stop as well.

Open full discussion →

0

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

No Negelsmann

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Where does Julian Nagelsmann rank in Man United's new manager shortlist?

Would you be concerned of his similarities with Ruben Amorim and Erik ten Hag?

B

beattoncorrin214d ago

He won the Bundesliga with Bayern, so has Vince Kompany, does this make them elite ??

D

danielopoo52214d ago

If scared of carrick the best option is Luis Enrique pliz

G

georgewilliamz502222d ago

He is a top level manager than carrick

Open full discussion →

How do you rate Roberto Martinez's chances of becoming Man United manager?

Is he a viable contender?

J

jf7dw878s8212d ago

If he gets the job, I 'm not watching United till he leaves

D

davecarey28213d ago

It's not April fools day again is it?

P

petermajur543218d ago

Poor

Open full discussion →

Would you like to see Gareth Southgate become next Man Utd manager?

J

jd48cam214d ago

No.

F

freddie237d ago

He'd bring players closer together as he is a bit of a yes man, but in terms of his managerial ability, deffo not

D

dancoombs238d ago

Never!!!

Open full discussion →

Let's give Carrick a chance to prolong that mood which failed many previous managers been hired

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

For now, Carrick is the best because seeing is believing. You can't doubt what you see. But let's see how it goes at end of 12 games.

C

cjllmota3241d ago

Yeah just let's hope he can learn how and when do substitutions ,not like when maguire had the red card and he take cunha out when with Bruno he is the best player in keeping the ball and leaving others that can't even control the ball and even less make good passes forward

V

vatsal280d ago

Think the job is his to lose if he finishes higher than fourth

Open full discussion →

Michael Carrick

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

I would have liked if Carrick brought Rooney or Ven Nistelrooy in for striker coach and teach our young strikers the skill to be great

H

housleychris5245d ago

NOT Rooney. Good as he was he's not going to be taken seriously, unfortunately. By the players, and the MU fans, yes but not by the media, and these days that's something that has to be taken on board.

Open full discussion →

Martinez to centre midfeild Yoro at the back. Give Harry a new contract.

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Luis enrique

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

That guy is not going bald

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Carrick is my guy

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

UEFA champions league qualifications

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Michale Carrick if he keep up current Man utd permanence!!

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

SAF wasn't a prolific manager prior to MU

D

deanrobinson595285d ago

He won a European cup with Aberdeen (that's not nothing!!)

Open full discussion →

It would be brain dead to give Carrick the job if he gets top 4 I'd still not be sure he was sacked by Middlesbrough after two seasons He has one game a wk How would he manage 4 competitions like Arsenal I not repeat Ole at the wheel If he gets the job it should be one year rolling contract Sick of all these shit managers walking away with tens of millions

S

stephenjholmes285d ago

Are you Roy Keane in disguise? Only him, Neville, Scholes, and Butt Crack would talk such drivel!

I

israelchidi58285d ago

How many games in other competitions did Amorin play this season and still flopped. You may not like Carrick but the results speak for itself, your opinion will be different if it was another name.

Open full discussion →

Carrick only

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Any coach who wants more time to show good results is not good for manU

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Zinedine zidane

D

darrynlowdon282d ago

Zidane will be France manager after the world cup

D

deanrobinson595285d ago

I'm pretty sure he's got some kind of arrangement with the french football federation to take the mantle of France manager after the world cup. But you are most definitely spot on he would be my 1st choice. Our players didn't respect Amorim. Zi Zu Would 100% have the players respect if not he would demand it!!!

R

rickiepaul77285d ago

I agree..

Open full discussion →

Ancelotti will be perfect for United. But he needs to be given time and money to arrange and position the team for both domestic and European football success. With him on board, a UCL trophy might be on the cards. That's his speciality.

M

mcharopatrick63290d ago

Is Currick given Money 💰 and time to show quality 🤣🤣

S

seanfisher297d ago

I feel like Ineos will be scared of Ancelotti not being a long-term project

Open full discussion →

Who should be the preferred option of a striker for Manchester United

Z

zeke.wolf42297d ago

Depends on the opponent. Against a low block, we need Sesko, because he's a finisher as well as a link up man. Other games, where we want fluidity, Mbeumo or Cunha are ideal. Horses for courses

Open full discussion →