Manchester United vs Manchester City LIVE fallout to offside controversy
Join the fan discussion on TalkingPoints around all the latest coverage and reaction to Manchester United vs Manchester City.
1,024 comments
Life without JJ Gabriel 2 games missed probably couldn't have affected the Brighton game and didn't need him for the U21's tonight as they won without him and won't let him be a free agent yet
dancoombs65d ago
From a first team perspective it’s hard to miss what you don’t have in the first place. A shame but they shouldn’t be relying on a 15y/old to bail them out!
Howard Webb says VAR failed to consider the key point over Enzo Fernandez
Absolutely pathetic!
seanfisher68d ago
The audio recording is shocking.. they didn’t even consider Enzo at all. United right to be furious
Manchester United over achieved last season from the middle of January onwards, this has clearly had a detrimental effect on Carrick so far this season with ridiculous calls for him to go, what would success look like this season now?
ericisgod6669d ago
Apologies to mufcgrw1977 if my coments about fans getting wound up came across as a dig at you...it wasnt (were u born 77 or were you at Wembley)
ericisgod6669d ago
I couldnt understand MUFCGRW why every1 felt we had am EPLwinning side. Or support thinking debt was paid down and we had £250 mill to spend on plyrs? I dont think we were lucky last season, carrick has changed tactics need to go backto them ,(carrick being pressured to play a certain way to appease sir micro management?)
mufcgrw197769d ago
Still positive me - look at how last season started and how it finished….
dancoombs69d ago
City and Arsenal aside I don’t think there are a lot of good teams in the league. Third spot is there for the taking, everyone else has flaws
PGMO changed their name to Pro Ref in the offseason. I would think another name change would be in order after the weekend, any suggestions?!
vatsal68d ago
Pro Ref? More like Slow Ref! I'll see myself out...
stephenjholmes168d ago
It's a shame it isn't PGNO, it could have been changed to PONG. Would have been appropriate, as everything they do stinks!
chillout69d ago
Yes - reverse the order of the R and the O and add another O after the first one.
Matt Donohue is from Greater Manchester could that have some bearing on his decision to allow the goal for City ?
dancoombs69d ago
He was the fourth official who recommended an extra ban for Harry Maguire after his Bournemouth sending off. He’s not welcome back any time soon
stephenjholmes169d ago
Being ex-army, I had 22 years of watching United with people from all backgrounds. In every game the people watching were always either United supporters, or, of WHOEVER United were playing. This hasn't changed even since we have been destroyed by the Glazers. We will always be the biggest scalp, and if the ref/official can make a name off us, THEY WILL!
geldroper69d ago
You will see they are going to use him in3 weeks against Man U
More from Dermot Gallagher on the goal
There is just no justification for the call.
For whatever reason, they have lost focus, they were concentrating too much on whether Fernandez had touched the ball and forgotten to see if he had impacted two United players..
barryroberts7269d ago
VAR is great at certain things for instance offsides and handballs but, this was so obvious that Fernandez was attempting to go for the ball even Stevie Wonder would agree, you only have to look at Martinez and a close look at Lammens in goal as he goes to dive thinking Fernandez will head the ball.
dancoombs69d ago
I wouldn’t say ‘great’ on offsides after the weekend!
vatsal69d ago
Corruption. Plain and simple. Not a simple decision went for us once Foden was sent off. They clearly tried to "make up" for it afterwards.
adnan.riaz69d ago
When VAR really does unite the whole world against it. 😂
seanfisher69d ago
If even Dermot Gallagher is speaking against it then you know we’ve truly been screwed over 😂
dancoombs69d ago
Not even an attempt to defend it
Dermot Gallagher verdict on Ref Watch
Dermot Gallagher does not dispute the decision was wrong. He claims the VAR officials had 'tunnel vision' on the wrong areas.
Lammens is the first affected as he goes to save it and then is clearly off balance, Martinez is dragged away from Haaland as he has to go to him. In my view, the more palatable decision is offside because he has clearly impacted on two United players.
adnan.riaz69d ago
Why are referees like this, including former ones? Just say it as it is. We all know what it was.
dancoombs69d ago
He doesn’t want to upset his pals before the ex ref Xmas party
seanfisher69d ago
“The more palatable decision” … I believe it’s called THE RIGHT DECISION
adnan.riaz69d ago
Pretty much this. Haha. 😂
The real villain: Matt Donohue
VAR official Matt Donohue has previously given a controversial decision against United
geldroper69d ago
He knew what he was doing and will keep doing it against Man U.Fire him as a warning to all referes and VAR
adnan.riaz69d ago
Snuck out of the Old Trafford car park quick time. 😭😂

Is this the first time United fans are ever agreeing with Jason McAteer?
Surely this has never happened before...
adnan.riaz69d ago
Hell has indeed frozen over.
dancoombs69d ago
First time Jason McAteer has been right about anything
seanfisher69d ago
The bar is low 😂 anyone who doesn’t say this doesn’t know football
How Michael Carrick saw the apology coming
Didn't we all?
adnan.riaz69d ago
He has EVERY right to be annoyed by the decision. It was appalling.
Wayne Rooney says how we all feel
Speaking to BBC MOTD
I'm sick of VAR. It's horrendous.
adnan.riaz69d ago
Get rid of it. The entire thing is so flawed and already feels outdated.
stephenjholmes169d ago
It's just another "old boys club". The matches last season where they didn't use VAR were so full of errors, they had to be doing it to justify continued use of it! The game has been made worse by its inclusion. We will never be rid of it, and we will never rid it of human bias. That is why the big issues are always blatant, and against a select few teams!
Joe Hart hits out at offside call.
Even former Man City player Joe Hart agrees the decision was a farce.
I absolutely cannot believe that all the people involved in making this decision they’ve come up with that Enzo Fernandez did not impact the play “The fact that Enzo Fernandez is there, and makes the attempt to go for the ball, that affects him [Lammens].
adnan.riaz69d ago
I’m yet to see a single person even defend this VAR call.
barryroberts7269d ago
All City and L'pool fans would say it's the right decision.
Calls for refereeing change
Former referee Mark Clattenburg is calling for Howard Webb to resign from his position.
Webb has been in his position for close to four years and has not improved refereeing in England, and it might be time to change the management structure and push to improve standards
geldroper69d ago
He is just as corrupt. Should become FIFA president
eoin69d ago
Get the point, but this was a mistake made in the Var room, is It a training issue or a personnel one?
We are live with all the reaction to the fallout to the Derby farce
Quotes from Mark Clattenburg and Wayne Rooney incoming

thetruthpersonified69d ago
Yes it was wrong. But let's not allow the VAR incident to overshadow the fact that our performances are poor.... Yes we would have got a point, but we should have performed a lot better. Appears to me we are relying on hope and Bruno still!! Where is the United approach? What are we trying to be? Donnaruma made a good save, but we should score!!
stephenjholmes169d ago
The biggest problem was the defence. They have been doing it since the 1st game. They all think they're centre forwards. Bruno was the last man, marking Haaland. Where were the defenders? They were all in the final 3rd! Never going to win anything like that!
seanfisher69d ago
Yeah lots of questions to be asked about the performance. playing against 10 is tough, but we actually looked worse than we did against 11 and that’s a big worry
dancoombs69d ago
Mbeumo undoubtedly should have scored at the end. A draw probably would have been a fair result
So they apologize,makes everything ok then, all those match paying fans have been robbed, the game should be replayed, make it 11 a side as Fodens challenge wasn't a red, give everyone free entry & replay the game, but no they won't do that, might as well not play the game & decide in advance City get 3 points for a VAR fuck up!!!
ian917869d ago
Im not saying we would have won the game but can you imagine if at the end of the season you only needed a draw to win the league or a point to save you from relegation and this happened. This blatant mistake could cost a club millions of pounds. How VAR got this so wrong is criminal
dancoombs69d ago
Considering the money at stakes it is an absolute outrage this amateur officiating is allowed
Why var always favour other clubs over Manchester united
ericlongshaw069d ago
Clutching At Straws There Mate So Why Didn't VAR Look At the incident When The Rat Bruno Kicked Foden First He Should of Been Sent off
stephenjholmes169d ago
So you know more than all of the officials/ex-players, and pundits who have seen EXACTLY the same as you have? Maybe you should apply for a job at "Pro Ref" as you would fit in perfectly!
granitegraham69d ago
It took five minutes for var to find a reason to allow the goal, that clearly should have have been disallowed. It took less for the panel to agree the goal should have been disallowed , everyone already knew that. As for the apology, what good is that. This sort of error happens every week. VAR is not fit for purpose, or the operator's are incompetent.
edughomnengim270d ago
Apologies without point is useless what has happened has happened the three point have been given to them so what is the need for this apology
jonny70d ago
Sorry won’t take back City’s three points will it.
dancoombs70d ago
Yes the apology achieves nothing it’s just them trying to save face. They should ban the VAR officials. I’d scrap it completely if I could
What should be the outcome of the investigation into the incident after this admission of error?
Pro Ref (formerly PGMO) have admitted Erling Haaland's goal should NOT have stood

jd48cam69d ago
Goal disallowed and points shared. Don't matter how bad we played,
febced169d ago
The VAR officials should officiate as on-field referees until the end of the season, and then their contracts must be terminated.
bs54158369d ago
This should have been looked at as two separate incidents, was Haaland offside, no he wasn't. Then was Enzo offside, yes he was, and was he interfering with play ? Yes he was, as he dragged Martinez across to mark him, leaving Haaland unmarked. Whether he touched the ball or not is irrelevant.
stephenjholmes169d ago
That is the sentence "interfering with play". We who don't get paid a penny for our opinions can see it blatantly, and yet HIGHLY paid "Pro Ref" officials can't see it!
dancoombs69d ago
💯
Already an apology… but what good does that do us… 😡😡 A point down while City take all three for an incident that was categorically wrong. There has to be more accountability… but how should the FA, PGMOL and Pro Ref make it right to United? 🤔
sunalike9069d ago
This is very embarrassing.
chillout70d ago
That’s football. There have been far greater injustices, but it’s part of the game.
daviescallum4269d ago
Yeah I agree, it’s terrible, it was a bad decision, but every team has suffered big injustices. Rules shouldn’t change just cos it finally happened to United
dancoombs70d ago
The point of VAR is that there are not glaring errors. That’s how it should be anyway. Clearly they are too incompetent to apply the rules
markmarston70d ago
The only way to redeem it without giving points back (which wouldn’t work) is to take a goal off city in the reverse fixture… in these very rare situations, the goal should be deducted in the next fixture
daviescallum4269d ago
Sets a dangerous precedent though if we start changing results based on bad refereeing decision. We’d be re-reffing every game cos there’s normally at least a howler every other match
chillout70d ago
Aint gonna happen.
jonny70d ago
Agree with that, would be against changing results after the whistle but something has to be done. If City go on to win the league by 3 points there would be rightful outrage
Michael Carrick wants United to win more games
Don't we all...
Move on and learn from it. But we’re not moving on lightly. We’ve got to get back to winning as a team.
barryroberts7269d ago
Stop putting Cunha upfront he hardly does a thing, we know Sesko isn't 100% match fit he must be at least 99% match fit so stick him on from the start, then bring him off with 10 mins left if you have to. Get the players to actually attack the ball when the other team has it, instead of standing that far away you could park a bus. We were rubbish!!
geldroper69d ago
sadly this is Carrick's game plan
geldroper70d ago
If he wants us to score ,stop putting Cuhna in is a worthless striker and sit Sesko. All his weird decesions makes me think he really do not want us to succeed. His love for Cuhna and Dorgu and hate for Sesko and Amass is a sackble offense. Just wondering if Howe is avaible ee
stephenjholmes169d ago
The biggest problem is our defenders. They have forgotten their PRIMERY role. Against city, Bruno was the last man marking Haaland, whilst all our defenders were around the 18 yard line (OF CITY). What hope is there if we have no back line?
granitegraham69d ago
You're right about Cunha as a striker he is totally useless , should be competing with Rashford on the left. As for Howe , please no , needs somebody stronger , who can sort the players out , and stand up to Ineos, maybe Nagelsman,
Youri Tielemans vs Elliot Anderson: Who came out on top?
Man Utd's £35m signing seemed to outperform £116m Elliot Anderson in almost every area

posix.forward70d ago
Easy to call from hindsight. But Carrick needs to think about playing against 10. You can give players freedom, but always in a structure. 4-1-4-1, or 4-1-3-2 as the base. Mainoo can be the midfield one when playing v. 10.
amirmir70d ago
Anderson looks and feels louder on the pitch. Tielemans was better, just like today.
adnan.riaz70d ago
Youri Tielemans for me. No doubt about it.
Forget the VAR call, the biggest problem with Man Utd's display vs City was _______________?
Fill in the blank? What was the biggest issue with United's performance and how do we fix it?

ianratcliffe196969d ago
We seem to have regressed, 3 shots on target all match is poor.
stephenjholmes169d ago
It is really sad. We looked the better side when 11-11 but just like against Leeds, all intensity went out of the game. The defenders all decided to be centre forwards. We will never achieve anything with such "schoolboy errors". We need to go back to basics. That was what MC did when he came in, and everyone has become complacent!
stephenjholmes169d ago
I have been saying it since the start of the season. No positional awareness. Defenders need to concentrate on defending. When you have so many players in the opposition box, you can't break the lines with great passes. It was also clear once down to 10, the intensity went out of Uniteds play. Mid table mediocrity
barryroberts7269d ago
Rubbish with school boy errors. Yes, we don't have coaching badges but come on we can pick a team to attack and defend better than that. Why are we the only team in the PL who stand around, (what looks like) 7ft away from the person on the ball, stand closer, close them down, players who rush on the ball make mistakes.
Michael Carrick comments on City's controversial goal
The Manchester United boss is not happy.
At the time I hadn't totally seen it. The explanation I got is he wasn't interfering with play. I just don't get it. We try to help referees to come up with the right decisions, it's that how the rules are interpreted. On top of that, where they drew the line was a bit dubious. It's worrying if that's how the game is seen by the officials.
Jim Ratcliffe and Avram Glazer were spotted at Old Trafford watching the derby - Do you have a message for them?

geldroper70d ago
Yes see what being greedy gets you. They are going to be lucky if Fernandes is no saying;no thank you to a new contract
jakonydan77070d ago
They're not bothered by games played at all they only happy when attendance is much and they'll make more profit that's all there for
thetruthpersonified70d ago
Bugger off!! Sorry, only message I want to send. My beloved club is a laughing stock, a shambles and second rate! You are only stewards of Manchester United. You saddled us with debt and now the club is withering and unable to compete. A once great club left washed out by it's owners. Talk about sweating an asset. A sad and shameful indictment!!
City's goal SHOULD NOT have been allowed - according to former referee Mark Clattenburg
Enzo Fernandez was in an offside position and was interfering with play 😡

epi2media64d ago
The debate about Halaand's goal saved us. Even if it ended 0-0, that Man performance deserved no defence - against 10 men at home, for the 2nd time! Maybe next time when our opposition is down to 10 men, Man U should let one player sit out the rest of the match...maybe🤔
ericisgod6669d ago
Haaland offside-yes.. For all the wrongs & injustices we complain about the fact is we lost an a**e kicking comp to a one legged man and at the same time exposed United's frailties. Utd plyrs were worn out after Thurs night UCL.Utd dont have depth. United cant afford the players required to win an EPL or a UCL. Top 4 with an FAC ELC thrown in
mahomediyoop69d ago
FA's biggest mistake was introducing VAR. United was robbed because of VAR's incorrect decision.
City win the game 1-0... What is your INSTANT REACTION?
What can United take from this game? So frustrating...

nashtims68d ago
I have had time to think so not an instant reaction. MU were poor, the allowed goal was a poor decision, a lot went wrong. My question though: Playing at home, Why were we so passive?
edvinbakiri22atc69d ago
I think Dorgu was a disaster. Very poor defending and didn't looked well in attacking role. He succeeded only 2 or 3 crosses an all of them were through in the middle of the City defence without purpose or intent of reaching his teammates. The rest of crosses were intercepted. His pass was and still remain poor.
barryroberts7269d ago
Yep i agree with that also Dalot had the worst game ever, mistake after mistake, Maguire had a good game hardly a mistake made, he kept Haaland quiet until Martinez took over and he scored. Why was Dorgu in the right back position? where was Dalot?
davecarey2869d ago
It was a shambles, harping on about the city goal is not the issue. City had 10 men and we still could not beat them. Lots of negatives to worry about.
dancoombs69d ago
Fair comment. We looked lost in attack and couldn’t get the momentum going. Not enough incisive play from the wings/full-backs
Zirkzee ON, Rashford OFF
geldroper70d ago
What is carrick's thing with Cunha who is in this game so bad .It is like playing 10 against 10 Maybe it is time to get a better coach who doesn't believe in sweethearts
Win or lose, one thing is clear: Kobbie Mainoo is the best midfielder in Manchester
jihad.dinero2270d ago
Pains me to see him loose when he is giving his all 😡
sunalike9070d ago
We don't deserve to loose?
barryroberts7270d ago
A draw was what we deserved not the win, we weren't at the races today.
dancoombs70d ago
We didn’t deserve to lose
jonny70d ago
Kobbie definitely doesn’t
Goal for City 1-0
geldroper70d ago
offside all day long , answer to var mistake on red card
eoin70d ago
Looked offside initially, but the lines show was the right call
dancoombs70d ago
Doesn’t matter - Enzo is offside and clear interfering with play
sunalike9070d ago
Fernandez fine attempt. 🔥
Wow Mainoo hits the post how close was that?! Surely a goal is coming
james.brooke70d ago
It was…
markmarston70d ago
Yep… gonna be a long half for City
Second half begins
geldroper70d ago
Fernandes in sec half one of the worst players on the field. and season this far. Never came back from world cup
jihad.dinero2270d ago
I have love hate relationship with my wife l dont need one with my team also. Teasing me they about to do something then nothing 😡
Think something we can all agree on is just how pointless these HT interviews are
george.patten70d ago
Awful. One of the worst ‘new’ things football has tried. And there has been a lot!
seanfisher70d ago
Completely agree, can’t believe they were interviewing Carrick after the second half had kicked off!
chillout70d ago
About as interesting and necessary as a hydration break in a air conditioned World Cup stadium. I don’t think they are mandatory, though, are they ?
markmarston70d ago
Literally get nothing out of the players anyway… and understandably so. Pointless
Mark Clattenburg verdict on Phil Foden red card - Exclusive
brogan70d ago
@mark.marston
markmarston70d ago
Fairs… I mean the only reason Foden’s kick was showing studs was because he’s on the ground after getting fouled & then kicked first… bit of a technicality really. They both shouldn’t have done it. But fairs, I am wrong in the laws of the game
Half-time: 0-0
jonny70d ago
Get Sesko on, our best chances are coming down the flanks
stephenjholmes170d ago
We were here against dirty Leeds a few months ago. Remember how that ended😭
vatsal70d ago
The pressure is that a win is EXPECTED now. No hiding place.
Famous last words, but we look by far the better team! City haven’t had a sniff outside our individual errors👀 And now they’re down to 10❤️
theworm70d ago
All playing with their legs
theworm70d ago
Cunha's good but not cut out to be a striker and no cross into the box cause he's not there Other teams uses their striker no matter what but Man UTD keep benching theirs
theworm70d ago
I'm so angry so angry man Rather lose without deficit this is not just a lost but also a disgrace
Red card to Phil Foden!
jamie.theodosi70d ago
Bruno Fernandes is the most disgusting rat in world football. An absolute cheat.
thetruthpersonified70d ago
Def red, but Bruno should have received a yellow.
markmarston70d ago
Fair
markmarston70d ago
Bruno lucky there…
jonny70d ago
Lucky to get studs to the gut?
Still 0-0 but United are playing with confidence
adnan.riaz70d ago
With Phil Foden off, this is where we really need to pounce now.
Elliot Anderson should be booked already that’s twice he’s clattered our players in the opening 10
brogan70d ago
Very surprised he let this go. Get it’s a derby but… yeah that’s a booking in any game



jonny64d ago
U18s were great today! Decongested-Seiros looks very exciting 🔥Ratcliffe out