Newcastle United vs Sunderland
Join the fan discussion on TalkingPoints around all the latest coverage and reaction to Newcastle United vs Sunderland.
219 comments
Who was Newcastle United's WORST player vs Sunderland - and why? 😡

lawrencegray1940245d ago
Tripera
jonathan.gorrie245d ago
Awful, wasn't he? Surely no chance of a new contract now?
What changes would you make to this team? 🤔

richardremington245d ago
Murphy instead of Elanga
jonathan.gorrie245d ago
Not a bad shout but those two goals in the week might have done him the world of good?
lawrencegray1940246d ago
Leave it alone. Give them a chance to cope with sunderland. It's a new day . ..
jonathan.gorrie246d ago
I'd LOVE to see Big Nick start up top to earn his redemption but just feels so unlikely
Howe disagrees with Bruno 👀 whose side are you on?

geordiekate1340d ago
Both Howe and Bruno are entitled to their own thoughts on that game with Sunderland.
geordiekate1340d ago
You have to give both sides a thought on this one.
james.rutherford341d ago
I'm sitting on the fence. We weren't a mess against Sunderland. We were set up solidly and didn't concede many chances. But our intensity was embarrassing, as was our attempts to score ourselves.
Should Nordi Mukiele have been sent off for his challenge on Dan Burn?
The Toon defender suffered a broken rib and a punctured lung 😳

41ekbod341d ago
Nope it was a 50 50 ball accidental collision, not even worth a yellow both players slid in Burn got there a fraction eralier thats is.
james.rutherford341d ago
Kind of tackle you want to see in a derby! Just a shame it put Burn in hospital, but there was no intent to hurt him.
james.rutherford341d ago
Not for me. It was obviously a heavy challenge, but the kind you need in a derby - exactly what Newcastle didn't do! Obviously gutting for Burn, as he is such an important player for us.
What was Eddie Howe's BIGGEST mistake against Sunderland?
I've no idea why we were so deep, or why Elanga started!

jackgallagher341d ago
Jacob Murphy had to start!
richardremington245d ago
after his production last season as the regular starter, I 'd be furious to be left and forgotten this season, last season 67 min per game, this season 49 min per game
peter.lynch341d ago
Weren't ready from minute one really, more than one mistake
iainroundtree342d ago
Starting with Elanga he has been abysmal dispute how much he cost the club
james.rutherford342d ago
He would look expensive even at £5. Cannot fathom why Howe started him.
Simple question, has Eddie Howe taken Newcastle United as far as he can? 👀

leazesndr342d ago
Eddie is an excellent boss but he is not an elite boss. Some of his recent team selections. and substitutions have been very questionable. Eddie may well have peaked at NUFC but deserves the chance to carry on. Depends on how ambitious the Saudis really are though
jonathan.gorrie341d ago
I agree. He's given me my best ever moment as a football fan but I also think maybe parting ways this summer would be wise. Just feels like the whole club is in limbo right now, and that we need something fresh
bazzak57342d ago
Yes and alot of the players must go
iainroundtree342d ago
Regrettably yes it's down to the players to step up and to prove they are worth there huge wages Sunderlands game showed not a Trot of that I think Eddie Howe has done what he can at the club he can only guide and if the players don't listen what more can the guy do
james.rutherford342d ago
What do you expect to happen next? All the players are talking about a response, but we've heard it all before.
After losing on Sunday, do you think Newcastle United will finish higher than Sunderland this season?
They weren't particularly great, but they didn't need to be.

jordan.harris341d ago
how alarming is it that this is a possibility (if not a probability)
jamie.brown82341d ago
Eddie Howe has a lot of work to do... Right now, I think it's very possible and that is just unacceptable!
petertaylor6400342d ago
I know him that flattened Dan should change to rugby league !
Thoughts on this Eddie Howe comment, Toon fans?
He's got some nerve saying we were good off the ball, we never even put a tackle in! 😡

bazzak57342d ago
Eddie shut up with the comments on TV and do your JOB get the team playing good football with pride for the Fans
bazzak57342d ago
Eddie the fans will not forget this the team is a mess
jonathan.gorrie341d ago
Will take some getting over. Where do you think we'll finish this season if we keep playing like this?
iainroundtree342d ago
It was a poor response, we lacked passion commitment and enthusiasm Gordon was hardly there Elanga was a no show waltermeade was isolated far to often and we didn't press enough we didn't press enough forward
jonathan.gorrie341d ago
Full agreed. Would you drop them all for the Fulham game?
How can this Newcastle team get fans back onside after losing to Sunderland?

bazzak57342d ago
Drop Elanga and Gordon
iainroundtree342d ago
Have to step up there game literally and have to try as hard as they can no words need saying as they say actions speak louder than words
rosie.tudball342d ago
No words, just actions.
Finish this sentence, the worst thing about Newcastle United's defeat to Sunderland was _

layates341d ago
Wasting Isak’s fee on Elanga and Ramsay. Awful signings.
penny2016leolucy2013342d ago
Newcastle made two disastrous signings, Elanga and Ramsey, this after selling Anderson to Nottingham Forest for a pittance. If Howe continues to make selection and substitution mistakes I can see him going out of the door.
james.rutherford342d ago
Has your feelings on Howe changed drastically since the derby?
tom.procter342d ago
Just seemed to play with fear
james.rutherford342d ago
My thoughts exactly. We looked scared and gave them far too much respect.
Anthony Elanga had a day to forget against Sunderland 😟 Would starting Jacob Murphy have changed things?!

james.brooke342d ago
Elanga needs to play himself into form, but I'd have gone with Murphy definitely. Loves the club, loves the big games, should have played
james.rutherford342d ago
Maybe not, but the decision to start Elanga was crazy. He's been a terrible signing, and to start him away in the derby was really odd by Howe. Barnes or Murphy should have started.
jakob.barnes343d ago
Murphy didn't do much when he came on. I'd have started Barnes - he was one of the only players who looked up for it when he came on
Didn't watch the game, however, Sunderland deserved to win, they've played great all season and we are so inconsistent it's unreal. We need a good hard kick up the rear end, we just aren't playing well enough, FACT!
jonathan.gorrie343d ago
Oh agreed on Sunderland deserving it, painful as that is to say. Agreed on the players too, do you think it's a mentality issue?
nalaiahc343d ago
Lackadaisical mentality - no urgency from management down to players.
Shearer's derby verdict is in! Too harsh or not harsh enough?
I think he's spot on 😠

jakob.barnes343d ago
He's understating it let's be honest. They might as well have not shown up
james.rutherford343d ago
We never looked like scoring, even when we were dominating possession.
Elanga has been incredibly disappointing, but I don't think anyone was helped by Howe's system today
Who was Newcastle United's most disappointing player vs Sunderland?
Feel free to list all of them in the comments 👀

keithbell954341d ago
Its not has important losing a game if you know your team has given 100% and fought tooth and nail. But at the moment those games are getting to be far and few between. Need to sign some good quality players regardless of cost. Not rely on cheap, young untried players.yet
james.brooke342d ago
Gordon - looks like a world beater one game and an egg beater the next. No consistency at all
jakob.barnes343d ago
Woltemade was poor but I think that was more to do with how isolated he was. Elanga, on the other hand, was abysmal! What was Howe thinking??
How has the loss to Sunderland made you feel about Eddie Howe as Newcastle United manager?

stephenrobson7884342d ago
He is still one of the best in the game, he should make his own decisions on team selection and substitutes and stop listening to his side kicks on the touch line
amirmir342d ago
Yes, the performances have been unacceptable. But he has earned the right to turn this around.
penny2016leolucy2013342d ago
Howe has always been frightened to make mistakes, he is getting worse. If Kane was bought Howe would put him on the bench for the first two games saying he was not fit enough for Premier League football!
Give us your immediate (clean) reaction to whatever that 'performance' was!

james.rutherford343d ago
Disgraceful. We looked scared.
liam.mcmillen343d ago
Toothless!
Oh dear, oh dear, oh dear. Was this just unlucky or could Nick Woltemade have done anything differently?
liam.mcmillen343d ago
The OG equivalent of the striker's tackle!
davidcomerford3199343d ago
You'll struggle to find a more bizarre OG this season
What should Eddie Howe's team talk be ahead of the second half?

jonathan.gorrie343d ago
Players need to get their head in the game. The tactics are broadly fine - the execution of them is what is letting us down!
liam.mcmillen343d ago
Completely disagree. I get Sunderland are bang in-form but they were shown way too much respect. Howe should have gone all guns blazing!
What have you made of Nick Woltemade's performance for Newcastle United so far?
I don't want to be harsh to a player who has already given so much BUT.....

fhogg343d ago
Waste of money, he has no attributes , slow, poor first touch, slow, weak, never wins an arial duel, never makes runs into the box.. how Newcastle wasted all that money in the summer, they need to sort out their scouting system
jonathan.gorrie343d ago
Too weak so far. I do not like being critical of him but that wasn't good enough
This is what we live for! Forget the nerves - I'm now asking you how many goals Newcastle will WIN by today?
jonathan.gorrie343d ago
Fancy us to win it by one goal, late on to really silence the crowd 😍
The team news is in! That's a BIG call on Anthony Elanga - how are you feeling now the XI is out?
maliajohn71343d ago
3 points for the makems
jonathan.gorrie343d ago
Ha! Think Elanga was the wrong call? I'm a little confused by that decision, I can't lie.
james.rutherford343d ago
Stunned elanga is starting. Glad Miley is in midfield.
jonathan.gorrie343d ago
Unless Barnes has picked up a knock, it does feel harsh!
Which Newcastle United player do you trust most to handle the pressure of a Tyne-Wear derby?
jonathan.gorrie343d ago
Bruno and Burn to stand up and be counted 💪
james.rutherford343d ago
Bruno definitely.
If you couldn't say Shola Ameobi, who is the one Newcastle player you instantly think about from Tyne-Wear derby history?
keelz343d ago
Shearer
scott.mason344d ago
Kevin Nolan!
jonathan.gorrie344d ago
Ryan Taylor!
Anthony Gordon is Newcastle United's best hope of beating Sunderland on Sunday. Prove me wrong.
james.brooke344d ago
Needs to just pretend he's playing in the Champions League. Might be tough against the Mackems though, that will never happen 🤣
carrickfan21344d ago
Have you ever seen a Mackem in Milan… 😂
jonathan.gorrie344d ago
Big-game player! He can silence the Stadium of Light!
So much has been made about the midfield and goalkeeper selection dilemmas, but who are you starting in central defence?
carrickfan21344d ago
Dan Burn has to start, he gets what this game is all about
scott.mason344d ago
Burn has to start. If Pope is fit, he has to start. Thiaw starts too.
james.brooke344d ago
As long as Thiaw is playing I'm not sure it matters too much. He is the main man
I think I'd start Lewis Miley instead of Tonali
jonathan.gorrie344d ago
Big call! Tonali has been off it of late, so I can see what you mean. Would you go for Joelinton then?
mike.hassan344d ago
Actually for this game yes we need a strong a forcer for Sunderlad be arsed kick the crap out of the midfield
This is our predicted Newcastle XI to face Sunderland! Would you make any changes?
rexn343d ago
Just a personal thing but boyhood supporters should be up for it, so Miley and Murphy would be starters for me.
jonathan.gorrie343d ago
Really am surprised that neither Murphy nor Barnes start!
keeley344d ago
Miley to start
david.torr2345d ago
Ramsdale should start but this is the best team
jonathan.gorrie345d ago
I like your thinking! What's your prediction for the game?
Who are you starting in midfield vs Sunderland? 🤔
carrickfan21344d ago
Bruno, Joelinton and Tonali… have to go with the strongest three
billy.meyers344d ago
Miley has to start with Bruno and Tonali - need a local lad in there who understands the importance of this game!
scott.mason344d ago
Bruno, Tonali, Joelinton!
It doesn't look like we're wearing black and white on Sunday - how do you feel about that?⚫⚪
carrickfan21344d ago
For the best! Kit clash would be too much
keeley344d ago
It’s so annoying!
scott.mason345d ago
My eyes wouldn't handle both teams wearing stripes with white on it.
You can pick one player to score the winner against Sunderland on Sunday, who are you going for?
mark344d ago
Gordon...lads on 🔥
jonathan.gorrie344d ago
Good shout! Feels like he could silence the home crowd
scott.mason345d ago
Sandro Tonali, Sandro Tonali, he drinks Moretti, eats spaghetti, and he hates Sunderland 🎵 If he scored the winning goal, the away end would go off
daniel.owen345d ago
Miley or Burn, for the funny factor


jonathan.gorrie244d ago
My head is hot. Prove it on the pitch!!!