Newcastle United vs Crystal Palace
Join the fan discussion on TalkingPoints around all the latest coverage and reaction to Newcastle United vs Crystal Palace.
97 comments
Who was Newcastle United's most disappointing player vs Crystal Palace? 😡

jonathan.gorrie224d ago
Tino. Loved him but starting to feel as if he's got eyes on a move. Am I being harsh? Probably - but he's been so far off it
I'm going to be honest - almost all these players are in my bad books after Sunderland - but is this our best XI right now? 🤔

Bruno Guimaraes can't stop scoring! How many will he get this season?
The Newcastle United skipper is on fire 🔥

jakob.barnes320d ago
11 or 12 goals. Could do with a few more assists too mind you. Still going to be an unreal season for Bruno 👏
tom.procter321d ago
Think at least 10 and a few more assists
rosie.tudball321d ago
The record for a Brazilian scoring in the PL is 15..I think he'll fall just short with 12, but hey, we'll take that 😅
Now that livramento is back fit I'd play miley seems like he can play anywhere and can put a good ball into the box and looked good going forward
owensje919191321d ago
I agree,somewhat with that but I still think our best 4 back there between if all were healthy Is Hall,Livramento,Thiaw /BDB but Shar adds so much as does Trips(I think both will retire with us)
Where is Lewis Miley's best position - RB or CM?!

lyleknighting321d ago
Central midfield no doubt about it, (similar too, but even better than Michael Carrick was)
james.rutherford321d ago
Totally agree. Been great at right-back but his future is always going to be in the middle. Who should he start ahead of?
jeffmilne6321d ago
His best position is anywhere he is picked he is improving every game. He reminds me of Paul Madely now sort out a new contract for him
prinnpa54322d ago
Anywhere. He is an outstanding talent
owensje919191321d ago
I'm just not sure he can push any of the 3 in MF off their spots at the moment, I was saying should take Big Joe off and put Woltemade at CAM with Wissa up front With Gordon and Murphy on the wings but Murphy didn't play well at all honestly 🤷🏽🏴🏳️
Who would you start at right-wing going forward, Jacob Murphy, Harvey Barnes or Anthony Elanga?

prinnpa54322d ago
For a winger I can count on one hand the number of times Murphy has taken on an opponent and beat him. That is a wingers job. At least the other two can beat a defender.
james.rutherford321d ago
Agree mate. He struggles unless he can get an early cross in. What have you made of Elanga so far?
james.rutherford322d ago
I'd make Gordon play over there and get Barnes now the left
jonathan.gorrie322d ago
Barnes! That was dreadful from Murphy today
mijmo1860322d ago
Probably Barnes
THREE HUGE POINTS! 😍 Give us your three-word review!

james.rutherford322d ago
Poor start, improved
nalaiahc322d ago
about time boys
jakob.barnes322d ago
Perseverance. Gritty. Deserved 👏
Who was your MOTM against Crystal Palace?!
THREE CRUCIAL POINTS 😍

geeshawg7620321d ago
Lewis Miley is such a composed player he was 100% MOM
scott.mason321d ago
Has to be Miley!
rastamousechef321d ago
Lewis miley what a player defo gotta get a call up for England
This is why fans hate VAR...
jakob.barnes322d ago
That was so annoying cos that finish from Gordon was great
mijmo1860322d ago
From what I've read about the incoming changes to VAR, Wissa's goal would have stood
Big injury boost ahead of Palace! 💪 Would you start Botman?

james.rutherford323d ago
Nah I'd keep him in reserve until the FA Cup vs Bournemouth.
Sound logic or stubbornness from Eddie Howe here?

saundersalan888324d ago
I reckon he was spot on, there was no onslaught, a few moments yes and we lost control of the game a few times. That happens away from home. We are missing leadership atm, trippier and burn back soon.
james.rutherford323d ago
Totally agree. We didn't play well, but we got over the line. The lads will probably take more heart from wining like that compared to a 5-0 rout.
jonathan.gorrie324d ago
Plan A has hardly been of the soundest logic this season!
james.rutherford324d ago
What he has said is fair. It wasn't quite an onslaught from Burnley. They had us under pressure, but we defended well enough.
Massive injury boost! But what does this mean for Lewis Miley? 👀

jonathan.gorrie324d ago
Keep him at RB and let the players feel their way back into the side
james.rutherford324d ago
Back to midfield for the kid. Maybe he could benefit if Tonali continues this poor run of form.
The XI we think Eddie Howe will name against Crystal Palace - what changes would you make? ⚫⚪

jonathan.gorrie324d ago
I just can't see him changing too much just yet. Maybe for Leeds on Weds..
trevor.arkle324d ago
Way off Barnes left W. Let Gordon know it's not his ! Tino England RB is a no brainier. Miley in for Sandro until you tell me ! Wizza starts game time required. Botts in Needs to get back into it Thiaw needs him . This will leave a fair bench . Trevor Thailand
james.rutherford324d ago
Agree on Barnes. I think it's so harsh he is either benched or forced to play on the right.
saundersalan888324d ago
I think that's the team he will play and also the team I would probably go with. I don't think we will see woltemade and wissa together until we have another fit striker to come in. Should be exciting when they do though.
If you could make one demand of Eddie Howe before Newcastle United play Crystal Palace - what would it be?

jonathan.gorrie324d ago
Tell big Nick to stay up front!
saundersalan888324d ago
Change your skin tight trousers
james.rutherford324d ago
Do you think that is what is holding us back haha?
The last time Crystal Palace came to SJP...
jonathan.gorrie324d ago
That penalty was so so so bad
james.rutherford324d ago
we were so ruthless that night! something we haven't been at all this season bar Everton...
mijmo1860324d ago
Tino
If Tino Livramento is fit for the Crystal Palace game, who are you playing at RB? 🤔
keithgreener323d ago
Depending how things are going game wise give Livermento 30 min or so no need to rush him back
jonathan.gorrie324d ago
Got to be Miley, he's growing into one of the most important players around!
james.rutherford324d ago
Stick with Miley and then ease Livramento back in. Let's not rush him.





pandglong1224d ago
Another Isak?
jonathan.gorrie224d ago
D. At best.