TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk

Newcastle United transfers

Join the Newcastle United fan discussion on TalkingPoints around all the latest transfer news, opinions, polls and updates.

297 comments

How are you feeling about Liverpool hijacking our move for Victor Munoz!? 😡

Ekitike, Isak and now Munoz...

dantowen81951108d ago

Typical really. The sad thing is that it doesn’t really come as a surprise at this point

dale.odonnell109d ago

United signed Cunha, Mbeumo and Sesko right under Newcastle’s nose last summer too. Ouch.

freddie109d ago

If I were a Newcastle fan my head would be on mars right now! Liverpool are doing this on purpose surely! 😅

View all replies
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

How does the idea of MORE star players leaving after Anthony Gordon make you feel?! 😡

bulmerkirby108d ago

Why are we losing out to Liverpool again

geordiekate1118d ago

Dreadful

jules121d ago

It will be interesting to see if Tonali has any loyalty after we stood by him. However, he looked disinterested once the CL was over. Players we get in aren't going to have the same quality that we'd like to see.

View 2 more comments
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Anthony Gordon's gone - so name your dream replacement here 👇

mcleodmcmac4895d ago

We have Harvey Barns...and give some of the talented young kids they bought a chance …0£ spent

bowkettcraig39121d ago

Vinctus Jr all day

nufc124d ago

Bellingham

View 1 more comment
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Hard choice - but who are you selling if you were in charge? 🤔

Feel free to include anyone not pictured!

gary.howe136d ago

Gordon. He's prone to uncontrollable bursts of 'energy' which often get him into trouble, and the rest of the time he seems half asleep.

geordiekate1137d ago

Anthony Gordon

mcleodmcmac48150d ago

Always injured

View 12 more comments
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

He's set to be on the market this summer.... 🤑

craig1990cd165d ago

40m no more. Top keeper proved what we already knew need to make sure we get it done this time. Future England 1 and hopefully Newcastle’s

jonathan.gorrie178d ago

£40m! He's proven how good he is. Time to make it happen

View all replies
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

We as well close the academy. However does not want bring any youngsters through

thomasrobson109189d ago

In five years how many kids have been giving a chance apart from Milely

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Would you take Wilson back at Newcastle as a third choice striker? 👀

bazzak57268d ago

No we need better a lot better the needs to think BIG

amirmir270d ago

It should be a big fat no. Backwards step, and just not needed. If Newcastle think Wilson is the answer to any of the club's problems, then that's alarm bells in itself.

nalaiahc271d ago

Let Osula and Neave play whenever the chance arises. Invest in long term assuming they are staying.

View 2 more comments
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Will Newcastle United ever see the best of Sven Botman again or would you sell him?

nalaiahc271d ago

The usual - try as best to keep him fit and playing as a Rolls Royce to benefit club and player. Then if the right offer comes and we have backup targets, it gives club and player an option. The worst thing is not shortlisting options. We now have a full time DoF.

saundersalan888274d ago

Hard to say. If his body keeps breaking down no big clubs are going to be in for him, he's missed a lot of football. Therefore he will likely sign his new contract. If he gets fit and plays well then my guess is he will be off.

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

How much money would a club need to bid for you to consider selling Joe Willock in January?

bazzak57268d ago

£25m and yes let him go

stephenrobson7884271d ago

20 million

penny2016leolucy2013272d ago

To be honest in my opinion if anybody is prepared to offer £15m sn̈atch their hand off!

View 2 more comments
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

If you could sign ONE Premier League player this month - who would it be?

penny2016leolucy2013272d ago

It wouldn't be Anderson crazy to pay twice as much as you sold him for! RICE is out of the question, he would be my choice if he was for sale.

lewismileynufc67273d ago

James Trafford

♥ 1

geordiekate1274d ago

ELLIOT ANDERSON

View 2 more comments
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Would you rather Newcastle sign a ready-made No.1 or a young project player?

catherinelee037144d ago

I’d think he would prefer the toon as he will be just over an hour away from where he was born and friends and family.Toon friends of mine and his said toon offered him below what city gave him which apparently was £145k per week.

♥ 1

penny2016leolucy2013272d ago

The answer to your question is Ready Made, but there are other priorities.

jonathan.gorrie275d ago

Ready made to hit the ground running!

View 1 more comment
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Fill in the blank ✍️ Will Osula will be a _ player by the end of the January transfer window!

jonathan.gorrie275d ago

Newcastle. Just feels like a lot needs to happen for him to go.

james.rutherford275d ago

Newcastle! Selling him makes sense for PSR, but wait until the summer when we can properly replace him.

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

You can sign ONE defender in January, who are you taking? ✍️

craig1990cd165d ago

Methalie. Propa talent and not an overpriced prem player in their 30s and wouldn’t be expensive in fee or wages and could build him up nicely with right game time covering for hall.

jonathan.gorrie275d ago

Got be Methalie! We focus too much on PL experience

james.rutherford275d ago

Methalie definitely. He'll be so much cheaper, bags of potential and a proper understudy to Hall. Ake would expect to be a starter at left-back or centre-back.

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Our first CONFIRMED deal of 2026! How badly does our loan system need a revamp, by the way?! 😡

penny2016leolucy2013272d ago

Is AMEOBI in charge of youth Loan policy? If he is then Newcastle should be looking for a replacement. He obviously hasn't got a clue!

james.rutherford275d ago

Glad Ross Wilson was ruthless and made the decision to send him to another club quickly!

oldstream1277d ago

give him a chance.why spend god knows how much ,for a player and don't use him.?

View 1 more comment
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Sign a new right winger in January or wait for Anthony Elanga to come good?

For a minute, in this make believe fantasy land, let's forget about PSR 😂

saundersalan888275d ago

Give the boy time and support him he will come good

stephenrobson7884279d ago

Simply wait patiently, he is a great footballer.

♥ 1

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Prove me wrong: Newcastle United should sell Joelinton in January if they get a big offer 💰

Selling players in January isn't ideal but he has peaked

craig1990cd165d ago

He’s done well. Been an absolute warrior. His transformation from 40 mil flop to pure midfield monster. Has been class but if we get a good offer and can progress as a club then may be time for him to leave albeit with a heavy heart.

saundersalan888275d ago

Not in January, possibly in the summer.

gilly19561280d ago

He has done well but if we want to try and progress and we get a good offer then its time to move him on

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Which player do you regret selling more - Elliot Anderson or Yankuba Minteh?

Thanks, PSR 😡

craig1990cd165d ago

Elliot without a doubt!

geordiekate1209d ago

Elliot Anderson

saundersalan888275d ago

Elliot

View 4 more comments
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Knowing what you know now, would you have sold Alexander Isak in 2024 instead of Elliot Anderson? 🤔

In this scenario, we still win the Carabao Cup by the way 😂

jonathan.gorrie283d ago

Easy to say now of course but we should have sold Isak in 2024 and kept Anderson/Minteh

♥ 1

geordiekate1284d ago

Would sooner have Anderson than ISAK

♥ 1

View all replies
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Who is the one player Newcastle United should SELL in January?

jonathan.gorrie283d ago

I hate to say it, but Trippier! May leave this summer anyway and we need to bank the money while we can

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Who is Newcastle's best ever January signing? ✍

james.rutherford275d ago

It's a fight between Trippier, Burn and Bruno. Think Trippier shades it for what he represented.

jonathan.gorrie283d ago

Trippier! Bruno wouldn't be too far off, mind

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Are Newcastle United missing Alexander Isak?

keithgreener278d ago

Safely yes

stephenrobson7884279d ago

When Woltermade gets the right support he will be even better than he is now and pre -season big player next. NY 2026

♥ 1

stephenrobson7884279d ago

No!

View 4 more comments
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Jamaal Lascelles could LEAVE Newcastle United in January! What are your favourite memories of his career at the club?

rosie.tudball287d ago

PSG of course and the entire promotion season, he was integral.

daniel.owen290d ago

That PSG match felt like a pinnacle for so many Newcastle careers!

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Newcastle United should recall Matt Targett - agree or disagree?!

bazzak57288d ago

Agree

daniel.owen290d ago

Nah. It would feel desperate and send out a pretty worrying message

jonathan.gorrie290d ago

Agreed! Why not use him? It's hardly ideal but we don't have many options

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Are you worried about Livramento's Newcastle United future?

jonathan.gorrie296d ago

Yes but I couldn't blame him if he did leave, should this season continue be a struggle. He's too good not to play at elite level!

james.rutherford297d ago

Slightly, but it will all depend on whether or not we qualify for Europe. Livramento has proven to be one of the Premier League's top right-backs, and should be competing for honours and in Europe regularly.

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

YOU are in control - who are you signing?

penny2016leolucy2013278d ago

Buying Gallagher would be a bigger mistake than buying both Elanga and Ramsey together.

teasheppard1962283d ago

Smit Bilal El Khanouss Diomande

rosie.tudball287d ago

I'm going Trafford and Anderson, wipes the budget but solves HUGE issues.

View 8 more comments
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

You're offered £150m for Sandro Tonali in January, do you accept or reject? 💰

bazzak57288d ago

No we must keep the BEST PLAYERS

daniel.owen297d ago

Yeah got to accept. £150m is ludicrous money. Spend well and we could get three or four quality players for that

jonathan.gorrie297d ago

Accept. That's just too much money to reject. We need to get better at selling players!

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Prem proven or future prospects? What do you want from Newcastle in the transfer market...

daniel.owen292d ago

Yeah but this is the nature of things really. The issue is whether we can actually invest the funds we'd make from selling Livramento sensibly enough

jonathan.gorrie296d ago

Don't focus too much on PL experience, it costs too much money!

daniel.owen297d ago

Newcastle I thought did their best work early in the post-Ashley era, when we went to Europe and bought talented but still quite underpriced players. Guimaraes, Botman, Trippier and even Minteh

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Who is the one player you wish Newcastle United signed in the summer?

daniel.owen297d ago

I wouldn't mind us coming back for Strand Larsen when Wolves inevitably go down and his value drops

jakob.barnes299d ago

Having Marc Guehi right now would have been pretty handy

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

What a strike this is! Toon fans, what do you think about Newcastle's newest target Kevin Danois?

bazzak57288d ago

JUST GET HIM

bazzak57288d ago

Looks a good player

jakob.barnes300d ago

Looks a tidy player!

View 1 more comment
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Who is the one player you were FURIOUS with Newcastle United for selling? Go back as far as you want!

teasheppard1962283d ago

Andy Cole was the biggest and worst move of letting a player leave NUFC

bazzak57288d ago

Anderson

jeffmilne6289d ago

Malcolm McDonald to Arsenal devastated me

View 5 more comments
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion