Talk Everton
Join the fan discussion on TalkingPoints around all the latest Everton news, opinions, polls and updates.
2,116 comments
David Moyes is one of the most consistent managers in the Prem - but fans are often quick to criticise him. Why is this, and does he deserve more respect?

A little "Whisper" from last night... TFG shouldn't be holding their breath waiting for a club takeover given the extreme likelihood of Jim Radcliffe and Co. offloading United in the very near future!!🤔
gramorris2d ago
Buying United is a different kettle of fish to buying us though. We're not in the multi billions valuation
robi3d ago

What should Everton do with Jarrad Branthwaite following Man United’s interest? 👀

andymcglynn273d ago
No sale blues we want players don't sell the one's we've got
shamanth.jayaram3d ago
I’d sell tbh. Injuries haven’t helped him, United are desperate and January is always an inflated market. Get a massive fee for him and reinvest
gomatz773d ago
Not sure about that. He's injury prone but so key to Everton. Would make things really difficult unless they have a plan to replace him
Right side, Left side, Through the middle. Speed, Touch, Attack, Defence, Physical, Goals! This Kid has it all and so much more to come!! He has that "Little something special" and is going to be a mega star! Current value... 6 - 10 £m... No messing about just sign him now!
ptrckbennett4d ago
We are desperate for a proven No. 9 but seemingly obsessed with midfielders Jack Moylan does it all and then some!!! His stats including goals and assists across the Championship, Cup and Internationals so far this season says everything that needs to said!
hurbertmorl4d ago
It's the same with all the top players Graham will leave because of moyes stubbor n ness and we wont get a fee l
Everton’s starting XI when GTA V came out 🤯 Which current players get into the 2013/14 side?

robi3d ago
Baines the best PL of all time for me but will never get the credit cos he played for us. Unreal defending, fast, scored worldies, set piece specialist, deadly on pens
dantowen819514d ago
Look at that backline 😂one of the most underrated back fours in the Prem era for me
dakir.thanveer4d ago
What a team this was! 🔥
How should David Moyes handle Jack Grealish after his apology to Everton fans? 🤔

mikewclayton5d ago
Play them both, with George on the right, then introduce Dibling (right) switching George (left) fazing Grealish out over the season. Johnson a sub for Barry until a decent addition is made.
alangaston1785d ago
sack moyes bring back grealish, it's a no brainer
hurbertmorl2d ago
@alangaston178 your so right we are playing quick attacking football if he plays we lose he slowes the game down and they will take the ball of him
dusters216d ago
At least this situation has forced Moyes to play Goerge more often & he does show more desire to be on the pitch imo, Grealish needs to get his head straight quickly football is only a part time career ie Gazza ??
Jack Grealish featured in a behind closed doors 4 - 1 against Derby County yesterday and then issued an apology. Is it time for him to be fully reintegrated into the team? I imagine we will at least see him on the bench after the international break
jonny9d ago
Very vague from Grealish, admitting he’s wrong without actually admitting it… will be interesting if he plays next weekend, hardly been missed has he
chillout9d ago
What has he actually apologised for ?
robi9d ago
Going on a 2 week bender i guess haha
Which Everton players are you picking to build your dream front three? 😍
Remember, it must stick to the £10 limit 💵

deanb191918d ago
Dixi Dean big Duncan and Dominic Calvin Lewis for me
jonny9d ago
Can I take Lineker, Rooney and Ferguson? 👀 all in their primes of course
daviescallum429d ago
I’d be happy with Dixie & Rom & just play a man down 😂
daviescallum429d ago
Got to be Dixie Dean, Rooney & DCL though
David Moyes’ signings have all had time to settle in at Everton, but who has impressed the most?

jonny9d ago
What an underwhelming window. Quite like George and Rohl, Hackney will come good but Everton needed starters
kevink4010d ago
I think George and Rohl run close. Both offer huge potential.
robi10d ago
Merlin Rohl. He's rapid and done a great job filling in at right back
Everton’s band of brothers have rallied after a difficult summer - but who has been their best player this season so far?!
Let us know in the comments 👇

mikewclayton6d ago
I voted for Barry, last season (our first sighting of him) he looked as if he had never seen a football before and a complete waste of £27m, I'm sure most would agree with that assessment. Pre season he looked a lot better. In the current campaign he has made great progress and with 10 goals under his belt a 20+ goal season is very achievable.
falder6d ago
Harrison Armstrong for his consistency, forward thinking, forward passing and positional sense with an uncanny knack of finding time and space gets my vote. We all knew his potential and he has not let us down. If only he could add scoring to his performances. £40m offer was the biggest insult of the season. Worth twice what was paid for Wirst.
ajmiller17th6d ago
KDH only really come back to form over last three games before that he has looked exhausted when playing, not the brightest spark on the pitch. George had more about him, and Armstrong pretty good but not as consistent as you would like. It's hard to choose because they all had their up and downs.
I said after the disastrous transfer window that something wasn't sitting right with the Grealish "Loan" deal and it seems a "Tiny" little bit of it is beginning to come clearer as we seem to have "Not included a get out clause" in his contract meaning "We will have to pay City" to take him back!! Can anyone else get that fishy smell?? 🤔
michaelbrown.ifa10d ago
Nah making something up that isn’t there at present that me will tell just get on supporting them all
sunderlandfan1613d ago
Mm, im smelling some something fishy
Everton are reportedly contemplating going back in for Folarin Balogun in January after details of Monaco’s financial troubles were revealed. Should they go for it or move on to a different target?
Balogun turned down a move to the Toffees on deadline day last summer 👀

caleb.sage12d ago
Absolutely not. Too much of a circus last time, look for someone else!
michaelbrown.ifa10d ago
He has had his opportunity and threw it away and hasn’t been playing either d no we missed a dodgy one there.
jonathan.gorrie13d ago
Why bother? Signing someone for the sake of it would be pointless, particularly after what happened in the summer!
daviescallum4213d ago
I don’t mind it but think this won’t happen. Will need a big fee. Get a backup loan striker in or something, Friedkin’s aren’t shelling out when they want to sell
David Moyes’ contract is up at the end of the season… what should Everton do? 👀
Give us your thoughts in the comments! 👇

michaelbrown.ifa110d ago
Just ask West Ham the question they didn’t and look at the mess they are in and we are not. Get him signed up asap!
gizglover81412d ago
Y would u want anyone else he's had no money tiny squad an were still pushing look what happened when he last left
peter.lynch15d ago
I say keep him, doing a fantastic job right now
Well worth a watch, what great football we used to play, and what an unbelievable finisher this man was 🔥 P.s. why have they used him in a Utd kit in the thumbnail 🤔😂 https://youtu.be/s23nZ4C520s?is=Vkz50I05VETl5GJz
dantowen8195118d ago
Reckon Lukaku is Everton’s best striker in the Prem era?
robi18d ago
Yeah. Was lethal
daviescallum4218d ago
Yeah nobody even comes close for me
peter.lynch18d ago
He was an Everton icon! Oh how they could do with him right now 🔥
daviescallum4218d ago
Still never replaced him 😢
How should David Moyes handle Jack Grealish after his breach of club discipline? Is his time at Everton up? 😬
Let us know what you would do below! 👇

pbw2718d ago
He's still a young man so have some understanding. Moyes has the manner to talk to him, at length, be a father, not a Judge, that's what makes a good Manager. Remember great players of the past, like Best etc. they were naive, flattered, indulged when they needed calm, sound advice and guidance, talent needs the right surroundings to perform at its best.
robi18d ago
Yeah. I think it will be a slap on the wrist then get on with it. We don't have enough numbers to be sending him back to City. We knew what we were getting with Jack. A loose cannon at times. But that's just him. Get him on the bench on Friday
daviescallum4219d ago
Rip up his contract
newtonpaul67619d ago
Get over it, for God's sake! He hasn't killed anyone! One f.....g training session! Stop being a Knobhead, Moyesy and leave it now! FFS!
What are your thoughts on a potential move for Marcus Rashford? 👀
Everton and Man United are said to be in talks over January move...

charlesgarside4317d ago
Yes could do worse might give him a new lease of life
daviescallum4219d ago
No no no thanks
bellisandrew51524d ago
He's lost it he's far too lazy if united don't want him why should we lumber ourselves with him
Everton need to sack Moyes, im sorry but his style of play can only beat the lower teams, against the top 8 we crumble, he also never starts our star talents (Dibling, Armstrong, Hackney, and George) I suggest someone like free agent Eddie Howe, at least try and pick him up.
sunderlandfan1627d ago
Yea, and hopefully if they all perform well David Moyes opens his eyes and starts them.
sunderlandfan1627d ago
Gotta wait a month 👍
p.molloy23627d ago
@sunderlandfan16 but seriously though I totally agree he's got to play Dibling and Haydon on thursday + Monday drop Jimmy to full back and let's see what happens 👍
p.molloy23627d ago
Hhmmmm think you need to worry about yer namesake
sunderlandfan1627d ago
@p.molloy236 fair enough, honestly i dont really go for these guys, just raige bait, but ill change it
How excited are you about Harrison Armstrong's development right now at Everton?
Don Hutchison reckons he could eventually get to Declan Rice's level 👀

daviescallum4219d ago
I agree, was imperative we didn’t sell him
sunderlandfan1626d ago
Ikr
sunderlandfan1627d ago
100% He could easily reach the likes if Toni Kroos with the right developnent.
tom.procter27d ago
Wow imagine he reached anywhere near that level 🤩what a player Kroos was
We are in a very serious and worrying phase at our much loved and historic Everton FC as a result of so many failures by so many people who have gotten their claws into us. Yes TFG saved us in a way but boy are we paying for it now! Rumour has it "The Dell Family" are interested & if they do as bad as we are now God help us all with who they are linked with!
ptrckbennett28d ago
Agree 100% mate would love it if Andy Bell could figure something out 💙💙💙
kmm.mace27d ago
Yep. Me too Patrick. Andy was my choice to buy previously when Moshiri was selling. He got a consortium together, but the Friedkins got the nod. I'm keeping everything crossed he makes another bid. 🤞🤞🤞
kmm.mace28d ago
I really don't care how wealthy the 'Dell Family' are. I would much prefer less wealthy owners who are not American & are from somewhere eith a rich culture of footy. Ie not from Trumpton! ( Or the USA as it used to be known).
ptrckbennett28d ago
https://youtu.be/UMaA47B2hEI?is=fpmp4ziZnB-HkYgV
Who should start at right-back for Everton against Arsenal, and why?
Maitland-Niles has had the position held down, but struggled vs Hull and Chelsea...

ptrckbennett30d ago
At least that's what I'd love to be predicted 😂 we need to play at speed if we want to grab something from the game!💙💙💙
ptrckbennett30d ago
Everything to gain - Nothing to lose! 💙💙💙

neilpurcell331d ago
O’Brien
tom.procter31d ago
Wouldn’t be surprised at all. Not sure there is a fixture that’s more suited to him…
Couldn’t help but notice that there are ‘chances to win exclusive calls with players’ if you sign up to the new Everton Mobile 😅 If you could have a natter with one Everton player in the current squad, who would be it be and what would you ask them? 👀
markmarston32d ago
I’d like to get to know Dibling a bit more and find out if he’s struggling to settle in on Merseyside, how he’s dealing with the lack of minutes and what his thoughts on Moyes are 🤔would be interesting…
tom.procter32d ago
Yeah would be good to pick his brains. Reckon my pick would be Rohl, seems like a pretty interesting character and thinker when Everton put interviews out with him haha. Or Dewsbury-Hall/Grealish, both seem proper sound and easy to talk to
daviescallum4232d ago
Imagine I’m already having a bad week, my phone connected with Everton mobile rings, and it’s Michael Keane calling. I’d throw my phone in the Mersey and I’d soon follow it in
tom.procter32d ago

daviescallum4232d ago
Christ, you don’t want to know
How important will Christian Norgaard actually be for Everton? Should he become a regular starter?

lawrenceduffy5528d ago
Moyes made him look like a Donkey by bringing him on despite admitting that he was no where near fit to play any part Poor management yet again
daviescallum4232d ago
I agree, but Saturday was NOT the time to start bedding him in
jameslloyd14.jl32d ago
I think he’s going to be a very serviceable squad player, but I’ll be shocked if he overtakes Garner, Armstrong or even Hackney in the pecking order
So here we go "watching a 42m striker" FFS PLEASE DON'T DO THIS AGAIN!!!! Does anyone seriously think we are going to spend that amount of money or even a part of that when TFG want to sell??? We had more than enough "GASLIGHTING" last window not to mention the energy crisis and the price of gas these days!!!
bgraneek32d ago
It just doesnt make sence. He looked perfect. I think our scouts have missed so many oppertunities to sign players that have succeeded in other teams.
ptrckbennett32d ago
Ah what could have been if only we'd played it right 🤔 That little moment where he looks up to pass but no one's there so he just thinks what the hell ill do it myself 👀 https://youtube.com/shorts/W-0k3Qd04lE?is=ebifcDTz3rybPx4G
callum_boyle33d ago
Say they were going to sign a striker, who would you pick? I still think it’s madness that you didn’t go all out to sign Troy Parrott. He was literally perfect
Everton legend Duncan Ferguson has been appointed as the new manager of Glentoran! How do you think he will get on?
daviescallum4232d ago
Wishing him all the best
chrisstafford123434d ago
One of the best 👌 good luck big man
kierandoody34d ago
I’d imagine it will go similarly to Roy Keane’s managerial career. The players of today just aren’t built for characters like that and the expectations they have. Shame because football is worse for it.
I think everyone somewhat understood the lack of minutes for Dibling last season… young kid that’s still learning. But his lack of game time this term after impressing in cameos is just baffling. Brennan Johnson coming on instead of him sends all the wrong messages - Moyes isn’t picking his team on merit. Wouldn’t be surprised if he leaves in Jan… thoughts?
daviescallum4232d ago
Moyes honestly frazzled my brain. He’s just like Dyche, has his favourites and won’t ever budge. So stubborn
diydadx6035d ago
I doubt, we would let him go. The squad is far too weak, to let anybody go. Personalky,I think Dibling would have been a better sub, than Johnson, who has been poor so far.
tom.procter35d ago
Me neither. Bundesliga been quite good to top young English talents over the years hasn’t it
Thought I'd give football another go after a truly disgusting window! I highlighted Troy Parrott many times last season and the proof of what we could've signed is clear sadly. So now I have another name in the frame and his form for a while now would be an excellent signing for us IMO... I give you one Jack Moylan of Cardiff City, definitely one to watch!!!
daviescallum4237d ago
No way Parrott would join us and who could blame him
markmarston38d ago
Moylan was in League One last season and it was pretty evident he was wayyyyy too good for that level. Not surprised to see him doing well in the Championship. Good left foot hasn’t he
gramorris38d ago
We know we need bodies, let’s hope they listen @ptrckbennett and stump up some cash in Jan. Maybe they will take a chance on a team In Europe being valued more highly
What's your thoughts on Thierno Barry at the moment? 10 big chances missed in the PL, but six goals across all competitions.
It's fair to say he divides opinion at Everton, but Dewsbury-Hall is a fan...👀

lawrenceduffy5528d ago
Absolutely not good enough
hiltondavid74230d ago
He isthe worst striker in the Premier league no ball control no good at heading
chrisstafford123434d ago
He's under pressure every day he plays nobody with him if we played two up front for instance say Graham it could make a big difference I'm sure his confidence would shoot up as long as he is the lone ranger the problem will not improve
hurbertmorl33d ago
@chrisstafford1234 you are so right even Graham and dibling is a young version of grelish
Some lovely words here from Harrison Armstrong about the reaction from Everton fans when he was nearly sold. You can tell it meant a lot to him. Still can’t believe TFG were fully gonna sell the best academy product in years 🥴
daviescallum4237d ago
Just proves the power of the fans! We can still make a difference
kmm.mace40d ago
Why are people talking about Harrison's value? That's only a factor if you want to sell. WHY would we want to sell. I hope we are no longer a ' have to sell our best assets' kind of club??
markmarston40d ago
Just a mark of how good he can become…. Like Tom says…. Not interested in selling
tom.procter40d ago
To be clear, I don’t want Armstrong to be sold at any point. I want to see him become a club legend!
chrisstafford123441d ago
TFG have proved they are not interested in this club it's obvious they were only after profit selling Armstrong and already knowing they're putting the club on the market the sooner they're gone the better for all
tom.procter41d ago
Yeah it sure looks that way. Awful, can’t wait until they’re out of the picture
mark.marston41d ago
Tried to asset strip before making an exit... disgraceful from them
Celtic are eyeing David Moyes with his Everton contract expiring next year... thoughts? 🤔

sunderlandfan1626d ago
Same
lawrenceduffy5528d ago
I would Drive him to Scotland myself
anthonymanley195637d ago
Im living in scotland and i have never heard moyes name when celtic fans have been talking about replaceing oneil or for scotland job
Who has been Everton's most successful academy graduate in the Premier League era?
You can't say Wayne Rooney 🤔

dantowen8195145d ago
Osman was so good for so many years. The core of the best Everton side in the Prem era
daviescallum4245d ago
Rooney is most successful, but not for us. Barkley our most talented beyond Rooney. Osman most impactful for us as a club
harveyleonard9946d ago
Has to be Osman or Hibbert, just for impact over such a long duration of time. Don’t see that much these days, if at all
Seven points would be a good return as of now we have young quality players the mixture with the old guard seems to be working much better,outlook for the next few weeks could determine our season
summersp196847d ago
Troy Parrott needed asap
daviescallum4245d ago
Would be a great signing
tom.procter46d ago
Some goal he scored the other night eh!
gramorris47d ago

callum_boyle47d ago
Just a prolific striker away from really striking gold I reckon
Everton's next five games are TOUGH - how will we fare?
Give us your points haul prediction for the four league games, and tell us how that cup game is gonna go at the end of the month 🔮

efcmarko1844d ago
Anybody know if its true TFG are sellin us ? I read it last nite online
brogan44d ago
Yup certainly is mate. Has even been official word from the club
daviescallum4245d ago
Only one I’m certain we lose is Arsenal. The rest there for the taking!!
freddie47d ago
Gonna stay unbeaten!
daviescallum4245d ago
I’d agree apart from Arsenal away lol we always get smashed
Finally! Proper football is almost back. This International break feels like it's dragged on forever. Hopefully we can pick up where we left off with a decent result against Hull 😎
gramorris48d ago
We’ve still got get through one more England game yet 😖
ptrckbennett48d ago
Completely apart from the long drawn out aspect of the never ending window, win, lose or draw I don't really care that much (well I do really) I just want to try to regain my love of the game after a truly sickening experience that came so close to turning me off the game forever and for all the wrong reasons 🇮🇪💙💙💙🇮🇪
daviescallum4248d ago
Thank god. Just glad we haven't suffered like Bournemouth seem to have. Alex Scott out for 2 months 😬
Give away your age… what was your first Everton game? 👀
anthonymanley195647d ago
When i was 10 lived in kirkby my nan lived right by goodison on a friday after school if everton at home wud get a bus to my nans this was 1966 on my own then on the saturday when game was on wud listen to the crowd then the last 15 or 20 min gates wud open if people wanted to leave i wud run in and the men passed me to front wud get last few min of game 💙
malcolm.2148d ago
Everton v Leeds 1974, 3-2 to the Blues, terrific match! And I'm hooked after that! 💙😉⚽
daviescallum4248d ago
I had been to a few before, but weirdly the one I really remember as the first was a 2-2 draw with West Ham in 2011, the season they went down. Fellaini last minute equaliser
Which former Everton player would you add to the current team, and why? 🤔
bannonleonard09543d ago
Enough of these what if questions what bought going out next window and buying Tiago job sorted the Brazilian has got everything good in the air either foot don’t forget he scored a hat trick against us last season and then another two at there ground he’s just the ticket no matter what price
pecco43d ago
Lukaku at the same age, big dunc was great at his time but too many injuries for me….
jimstarkcowden47d ago
Duncan Ferguson
callum_boyle47d ago
He’d keep the dressing room in check 😂


james.brooke16m ago
He is absolutely not underrated. The gaslighting over Moyes is on another level. Time for the 🦖to retire. Still never won at Anfield
will.butcher20m ago
The grass is never greener when clubs move on from Moyseh
dakir.thanveer20m ago
I think he is underrated too, but his ceiling is limited. Every club in the Premier League is very ambitious, and there is only so much Moyes can do with those teams IMO
matthew.johns21m ago
I definitely think so in terms of longevity, particularly in his two spells at Everton
johnverrall1123m ago
Too risk averse. Football is about joy for the fans and he has always prioritised mid table security over cup success or striving for more.
markmarston11m ago
Spot on
lawrenceduffy5553m ago
If Brighton and Bournemouth can find a decent young manager then surely we can, there has to be someone out there with progressive ideas instead of being stuck with a yesterday Manager
chillout34m ago
But in all honesty - Brighton and Bournemouth are much better run clubs. Maybe new ownership will help.
antonymmartin8455m ago
Because his playing style is turgid. Don’t get me wrong, he guided us to the only trophy I’ve seen us win in my lifetime (42 years!) and I’ll always be grateful to him for that. But honestly, paying money for a season ticket and going home and away throughout his tenure, it was hard work, especially his last season with us. He should have left in 2023
chillout35m ago
I get what you say - and I have never been a Moyes fan. But would the Hammers be where they are today if Moyes was still manager ?
aaditya.krishnamurthy1h ago
I think he’s perfectly rated - he’s good enough to keep you afloat and maybe even help you move up, but he’s not the guy who will take you to the next level as a team, and he’s shown that everywhere - West Ham and the Conference League win didn’t do much to change my mind
lawrenceduffy551h ago
Nor for me, he is just a safe manager who tries to st his teams up not to lose, all those games managing Everton and he's won absolutely nothing says it all for me
chillout56m ago
But what’s the alternative ? With respect, an elite manager won’t come to Everton at the moment (and even if they do it’s just until something better comes along - how you doing, Carlo?). Maybe go for a younger / less high profile manager from Europe - but they are hit and miss. Everton don’t want to end up like West Ham.
markmarston59m ago
Tbf he has a shoestring budget in his first tenure
jordan.harris1h ago
Definitely underrated! Just picked the wrong big role to leave Everton for - not that he can be blamed for that
chillout1h ago
That is a good point. The United job was much too big for him and the timing was all wrong (who wants to follow SAF and manage such an aging squad that needs a rebuild?), and arguably he could have enjoyed a more successful long term career by being less ambitious with a big move that ended in disaster.
chillout1h ago
It really depends on the aspirations of a club. He is not the tactical genius and motivational figure needed to be a success at the big clubs - but he knows what he is doing and usually gets the best out of the non elite teams. The problems start when fans get restless and want more - but let Moyes go and you might regret it.
markmarston1h ago
Should he get a new contract? Currently due to leave at the end of the season.
chillout37m ago
I think the big issue is the potential change of ownership. A possible sale might put a lot of managers off. The safe decision, if the owners really want to sell, is to renew Moyes for two more years - any any new owners can make a managerial change if they want on arrival.
markmarston1h ago
Absolutely he is - there are still some who want more progression in his team selections & style of play. And I’m one of them! I rate him but for whatever reason, I sometimes struggle to truly get behind him & think he’s the man to take Everton forward long-term. I do accept there is no better manager for the club than right now, with the TFG situation…
dantowen819511h ago
I’m completely on board with you. It’s the Hodgson Palace situation all over again for me Get the replacement right, like they did with Glasner, and you could go to another level Then again, you might also end up with a Frank de Boer. But I think Everton should take the risk