TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk Everton

Who has been Everton's most successful academy graduate in the Premier League era?

You can't say Wayne Rooney 🤔

dantowen819511mo ago

Osman was so good for so many years. The core of the best Everton side in the Prem era

daviescallum421mo ago

Rooney is most successful, but not for us. Barkley our most talented beyond Rooney. Osman most impactful for us as a club

harveyleonard991mo ago

Has to be Osman or Hibbert, just for impact over such a long duration of time. Don’t see that much these days, if at all

caleb.sage1mo ago

Definitely Gordon, in terms of what he’s achieved individually and collectively compared to Everton’s other graduates.

jamesshearman231mo ago

Anthony Gordon by a mile. He’s the only borderline great player besides Rooney

markmarston1mo ago

Branthwaite is top!

aaditya.krishnamurthy1mo ago

My Barcelona bias is fully showing but if I can’t say Wayne Rooney, I have to go with Anthony Gordon. The kid is a revelation!

leeclarke05081mo ago

I went to a wedding on Friday and an Everton fan told me his fave player of all-time was Tony Hibbert so who am I to go against him! Barkley in with a shout too.

shamanth.jayaram1mo ago

Osman or Gordon if it's not Rooney, but think David Unsworth deserves some love as well. Academy graduate, played hundreds of games, won the FA Cup in 95, managed the academy and even the first team as a caretaker on a couple of occasions

jameslloyd14.jl1mo ago

Gordon I’d have to say. Got 40-odd mil for him and now he’s starting for Barca! Be interesting to see what sort of level Armstrong can reach

tom.procter1mo ago

Osman turned out to be a brilliant academy product. So underrated

markmarston1mo ago

Should’ve got more England caps’

charlesjones1mo ago

You’re probably looking at Osman in terms of impact at Everton. But Anthony Gordon’s career already trumps anything he did.

dale.odonnell1mo ago

Hibbert. What a servant.

peter.lynch1mo ago

Leon Osman and Tony Hibbert were super servants, but gotta be Rooney, one of the best to ever do it

gramorris1mo ago

From an Everton point of view it has to be Osman or Hibbert. I’m not accepting a graduate that only played a season or two for us, Barkley is borderline

freddie1mo ago

Anthony Gordon. He’s cooking atm

callum_boyle1mo ago

The big man: Tony Hibbert. One-club legend

markmarston1mo ago

Leon Osman! Super player

jonny1mo ago

Rooney the obvious, Gordon has been great, Armstrong looks strong. But I think Ross Barkley has had a very underrated Premier League career.

markmarston1mo ago

Barkley was so good for a couple year spell… could’ve achieved more I feel. Super talent. Both footed as well

robi1mo ago

Other than Rooney probably Anthony Gordon (as much as it pains me to say it) or Leon Osman. Notable mention for Eric Dier. But soon to be Harrison Armstrong