TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk Everton

David Moyes is one of the most consistent managers in the Prem - but fans are often quick to criticise him. Why is this, and does he deserve more respect?

adnan.riaz31m ago

Defo not underrated. He IS rated. He is more underappreciated. That’s the best way to describe him.

shamanth.jayaram1h ago

If you’re a mid table club and want stability, there’s no better option than Moyes. You want something better? He’s probably not the man but there comes a big risk of you decide to change him - just look at West Ham

robi4h ago

I think he gets unfairly criticised. We know his limitations as a manager but he's also working with limited resources and a small squad. Think he needs to win a cup to get some of the doubters fully on-board

james.brooke4h ago

He is absolutely not underrated. The gaslighting over Moyes is on another level. Time for the 🦖to retire. Still never won at Anfield

will.butcher4h ago

The grass is never greener when clubs move on from Moyseh

dakir.thanveer4h ago

I think he is underrated too, but his ceiling is limited. Every club in the Premier League is very ambitious, and there is only so much Moyes can do with those teams IMO

matthew.johns4h ago

I definitely think so in terms of longevity, particularly in his two spells at Everton

johnverrall114h ago

Too risk averse. Football is about joy for the fans and he has always prioritised mid table security over cup success or striving for more.

markmarston4h ago

Spot on

lawrenceduffy555h ago

If Brighton and Bournemouth can find a decent young manager then surely we can, there has to be someone out there with progressive ideas instead of being stuck with a yesterday Manager

chillout4h ago

But in all honesty - Brighton and Bournemouth are much better run clubs. Maybe new ownership will help.

antonymmartin845h ago

Because his playing style is turgid. Don’t get me wrong, he guided us to the only trophy I’ve seen us win in my lifetime (42 years!) and I’ll always be grateful to him for that. But honestly, paying money for a season ticket and going home and away throughout his tenure, it was hard work, especially his last season with us. He should have left in 2023

chillout4h ago

I get what you say - and I have never been a Moyes fan. But would the Hammers be where they are today if Moyes was still manager ?

aaditya.krishnamurthy5h ago

I think he’s perfectly rated - he’s good enough to keep you afloat and maybe even help you move up, but he’s not the guy who will take you to the next level as a team, and he’s shown that everywhere - West Ham and the Conference League win didn’t do much to change my mind

lawrenceduffy555h ago

Nor for me, he is just a safe manager who tries to st his teams up not to lose, all those games managing Everton and he's won absolutely nothing says it all for me

chillout5h ago

But what’s the alternative ? With respect, an elite manager won’t come to Everton at the moment (and even if they do it’s just until something better comes along - how you doing, Carlo?). Maybe go for a younger / less high profile manager from Europe - but they are hit and miss. Everton don’t want to end up like West Ham.

markmarston5h ago

Tbf he has a shoestring budget in his first tenure

jordan.harris5h ago

Definitely underrated! Just picked the wrong big role to leave Everton for - not that he can be blamed for that

chillout5h ago

That is a good point. The United job was much too big for him and the timing was all wrong (who wants to follow SAF and manage such an aging squad that needs a rebuild?), and arguably he could have enjoyed a more successful long term career by being less ambitious with a big move that ended in disaster.

chillout5h ago

It really depends on the aspirations of a club. He is not the tactical genius and motivational figure needed to be a success at the big clubs - but he knows what he is doing and usually gets the best out of the non elite teams. The problems start when fans get restless and want more - but let Moyes go and you might regret it.

markmarston5h ago

Should he get a new contract? Currently due to leave at the end of the season.

chillout4h ago

I think the big issue is the potential change of ownership. A possible sale might put a lot of managers off. The safe decision, if the owners really want to sell, is to renew Moyes for two more years - any any new owners can make a managerial change if they want on arrival.

markmarston5h ago

Absolutely he is - there are still some who want more progression in his team selections & style of play. And I’m one of them! I rate him but for whatever reason, I sometimes struggle to truly get behind him & think he’s the man to take Everton forward long-term. I do accept there is no better manager for the club than right now, with the TFG situation…

dantowen819515h ago

I’m completely on board with you. It’s the Hodgson Palace situation all over again for me Get the replacement right, like they did with Glasner, and you could go to another level Then again, you might also end up with a Frank de Boer. But I think Everton should take the risk