Man Utd vs Brighton LIVE Carabao Cup clash
Join in the discussion on TalkingPoints for Manchester United’s Carabao Cup campaign
393 comments
A very harsh set of player ratings are in... Who stood out for you for the wrong reasons?
Give us your player ratings below...

Yeah, done with the lot of you. Too much glass half empty v. glass half full. SAF, a God here asked one thing when he left. Congrats, you have collectively showed that his plea, fell on deaf ears.
kingmoose01866d ago
It was really a poor and unhappy lost, but let stilll give Carrick time to fix more
seanfisher67d ago
I usually like to consider myself an optimistic fan, and I don’t want to jump on a wagon and call for Carrick to go… but that was poor, really poor. Fans were right to boo that performance, and questions should be asked
dancoombs67d ago
One win at a time is all it takes to start building the positivity and trust back. I know the fanbase is reactive but that wasn’t good. In the big picture I reserve judgment on Carrick for now but we know the signs of this doom loop by now
More from Michael Carrick
It's all sounding pretty negative...
We've had small, little things that have gone against us in the last week or two and then it accumulates to feel that it's a lot bigger. I think we have to be honest and say that. The late goal against Everton from outside the box. The [Manchester] City goal the other day. It can all of a sudden roll into something a bit greater but I understand the disappointment because we shouldn't finish the game in that manner with the position we were in and we have to be humble and take that. "We have to find the answers for Sunday.
geldroper65d ago
Players as Yoro ,Heaven, Amass and Sesko have to get playing time to get even better as they are already. By sitting this much you have to expect them not to be ready and that is on Carrick
mazambanivs65d ago
It is more to do with Carrick and his Management Team. The small teams that are beating Man United have less individual talent. We cannot put the better talented players at fault as if they are conspiring to lose games. That is very rare in soccer. We cannot blame them for issues beyond their control. Why lose to even smaller teams? No excuses here please!
niko66d ago
Carrick is not at fault, but the management who are responsible for recruitment. How they had to wait for United to be hammered before it dawned on them that the team needs a strong centre back and a strong striker is beyond me. Yoro, De Ligt, Zirkzee, Sesko are not English Premiership materials and those who recruited them should be sacked!
geldroper65d ago
Iagree with yoro and Zikzee but De Light and Sesko are great EPL players .Sadly Yoro belongs in Spain where he will be great and Zirkzee should be in Italy or Netherlands right now and that is on our managment
mazambanivs65d ago
Can that explain how even small teams with less talented players are winning against Manchester United? I am saying here, yes we may not have the best centre backs in the world etc, but we are getting beaten by teams with less talented centre backs etc.
gijonfabio65d ago
Everyone keep saying Sesko would do better given may be 4 years of time?
Michael Carrick's post-game comments
What is your response to Michael Carrick?
I totally understand the feelings of the supporters. We have to accept it. I totally accept it. It's on me ultimately: as a team what we look like, how we play and what results you get. I take that. I'll take the praise, I'll take the criticism and the upset.I totally understand it for the way the game went. We have got to win games.

niko66d ago
United was unlucky in the matches against Everton and Man. City when points were dropped unnecessarily. But poor recruitment was to blame for losses against Hull and Brighton which is down to management. United still lack a strong proven centre back to plug the leaking defence, and a strong proven striker to feed off chances created by Rashford a Fernandez
gijonfabio65d ago
Sesko is always minus 1 when he starts. He's just a good super sub. Who will now play the striking position. Soon Cunha will be unhappy 😭 so will be Santos and we will have an unhappy dressing room. I hope we finish 7th this season. Or worst 13th
dale.odonnell67d ago
Carrick looked and sounded deflated while carrying out his post-match duties. He didn't shy away from responsibility or throw his players under the bus, but it was still a very hard watch for someone who admires the man.
seanfisher67d ago
Strong comments, taking the blame and defending the players. Let’s see if they return the favour and put in a performance for him vs Fulham. If not, we’re headed for a very familiar feeling
clarrywhitfield66d ago
The usual shite it's not the manager got to go piss em all off start from scratch in third division where we belong. I have
dancoombs67d ago
I just don’t know if they are capable of it
Manchester United are OUT of the Carabao Cup - Give us your INSTANT REACTION
2-0 up to 3-2 down... What went wrong?!

mazambanivs66d ago
We need to get out of denial that Carrick has been weak against small teams from the beginning. In brief, something is not going right at training, I do not blame the players for that.
mazambanivs65d ago
Marcus for me is a great player. Our team has better talent than the small teams that give Carrick a headache. Were it not for the VAR error, we could have drawn with Man City. I repeat, it is the technical management at training and during games that need strategically reorientation, with the same players. How are teams with less individual talent winning?
donaghcorby199766d ago
They got pecked by the seagulls
niko66d ago
Exiting Carabao, though painful, is not a death sentence. United squad is not as deep as other teams and its one irrelevant competition out of the way. I back Carrick to get it right with the depleted squad at his disposal, and management to recruit quality centre back and striker in January to prop up this depleted and injury prone squad.
Rashford had to score that chance!
niko66d ago
What about all the chances he created with no lethal striker to score? Rashford is a support striker who operates from the left and needs a central striker to work with. So do Fernandez, Cunha and others.
dancoombs66d ago
I agree Rashford is creating chances the numbers back it up. His teammates don’t seem on the same wavelength yet. He needs to score though; that seems to be a confidence issue
dale.odonnell67d ago
That was his moment. Blew it.
seanfisher67d ago
Seems to have such bright moments in games yet still waiting for a goal for asssit
dancoombs67d ago
He’s not been good enough since coming back ultimately
Goal for Brighton. United trail 3-2
Disastrous second half so far
amirmir67d ago
Soft as shit without the ball are United!
dancoombs67d ago
That goal was just so poor. Shambles
sunalike9067d ago
Na wa ooo
dancoombs67d ago
Sigh😢 nothing is going right at the moment
Changes for United
febced166d ago
A club in the 5th tier of English football.
febced167d ago
Zirkzee must offer himself for sale. He has lost the plot completely.
dancoombs67d ago
Who would take him?
58taylorchris67d ago
Zirkzee should never wear an utd shirt again
Goal for Brighton
Brighton pull a goal back just before half-time. United lead 2-1
dale.odonnell67d ago
Let's not panic.
adnan.riaz67d ago
We must be allergic to keeping clean sheets this season.

dancoombs67d ago
I have forgotten what a clean sheet for United looks like
dancoombs67d ago
Hmm, job not done. Reminder to the team to wake up
adnan.riaz67d ago
Every. Single. Time.

Watch Shea Lacey's goal!
The goal that made it 1-0
dale.odonnell67d ago
Could watch that over and over again. Beautiful cut-in and strike.
Shea Lacey - Like Arjen Robben?
This comparison could catch on?
dancoombs67d ago
Robben was deadly. You knew what he was going to do and couldn’t stop him. Lacey looks deadly when he cuts inside too
A great statistic
Shea Lacey is writing his name in United history here...
adnan.riaz67d ago
We love to see that! Very positive for such a promising Man Utd talent.
dale.odonnell67d ago
He's a special player. A youngster definitely worth putting time into.
adnan.riaz67d ago
That end part...

Love that the goals are instantly goals and there is no messing around with VAR checks tonight!
adnan.riaz67d ago
VAR is such a mess and I would watch more League Cup matches because we don't have to deal with the chaos it causes.
dale.odonnell67d ago
Further proof that football is better without VAR.
adnan.riaz67d ago

GOOOOOOOOOAAAAAALLLLL 2-0 to United
Mason Mount adds a second!

adnan.riaz67d ago
Late to the party, but what a start from the boys! Love to see it!
dale.odonnell67d ago
That's the response we were crying out for. Well in!
adnan.riaz67d ago
We all love to see it!

dancoombs67d ago
What a start! What a response to the weekend
adnan.riaz67d ago
Get these lot playing against Fulham instead of the last lot. 😂
GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLLL 1-0 to United
Shea Lacey on target! What a hit from Lacey as he cuts inside and shoots with his left foot. Assist from Youri Tielemans - but that goal was all Lacey.

adnan.riaz67d ago
The badge kiss was perfect. What a lad.
jjflash42267d ago
To see shae laceys face when he scored was just brilliant.shae scoring that goal after the circus of the last 2 days was perfect.What a proud day for the lad.
adnan.riaz67d ago
The badge kiss was the chef's kiss moment. Love his attitude.
dale.odonnell67d ago
What a strike, lad. That's how it's done.
adnan.riaz67d ago
A new star is born.

Is it wrong that I don’t trust Karl Darlow because he’s ex-Leeds? 😅
dancoombs67d ago
I think that’s fair - but sadly he did win on his last game at Old Trafford 😢
Full-back details
Noussair Mazraoui is expected to start at left-back with Diogo Dalot on the right
seanfisher67d ago
Probably a smart decision to surround Heaven and Yoro with experience
stephenjholmes167d ago
Dalot needs to remember he's a DEFENDER. If he goes bombing forward tonight leaving the centre backs exposed, we will get demolished on transition. We need the defenders to concentrate on defending.
dale.odonnell67d ago
100%, Sean. It's been a while since we saw Mazraoui perform well, but he's shown in the past that his versatility can be an asset to United.
Joshua Zirkzee must be wondering if he will ever start a game if he can’t start here. This season is not shaping up well for him is it?
stephenjholmes167d ago
Zirkzee performed in preseason against slower teams. He doesn't have the quality for Premier League football.
knightinwhitesatin67d ago
Has only really been good a couple of times in pre season and is only really just taking up space on the field and wage structure
amirmir67d ago
The funny thing is, I could see him balling elsewhere like Antony. But it doesn't mean he is good enough for Man United. Although he should be getting a start today in this much-changed side.
stephenjholmes167d ago
He isn't quick enough with his decision making. He will never be good enough to start for United.
dale.odonnell67d ago
Sure, but in a slower league.
Competition rules: Penalties after 90 minutes
dancoombs67d ago
Get Bruno on in the 89th if we are level
dale.odonnell67d ago
Very specific; I like it. 😄👏
dale.odonnell67d ago
Let’s get this done in 90 mins 🤞
Give your INSTANT reaction to Man United's XI vs Brighton in the EFL Cup
barryroberts7267d ago
Apart from the back 5 players it was a strongish team, we started slow then we scored 2 cracking goals after that we did nothing, too much trying one twos and flicks when we didn't need to, why don't we ever just shoot? The best player on that pitch tonight was Lacey and he came off, why? he hasn't played much 1st team football. It was Pathetic 2-0 lose 2-3.
dale.odonnell67d ago
Buzzing for Lacey. C’mon lads. 🙌
knightinwhitesatin67d ago
Not a,bad starting 11
We are live ahead of kick-off at Old Trafford and the team news will be out shortly!
seanfisher67d ago
Probably a bigger match than we’re giving it credit for, have to win this one and get back on track
thetruthpersonified67d ago
Agree, Brighton play a lot more attractive football than we do at present and have the ability to score. Tough match these days.
stephenjholmes167d ago
I really hope that the focus can return to football. Let Amass, and Lacey play!
dancoombs67d ago
Feeling optimistic we have got to go for this one 👍
Shea Lacey with a perfectly timed message ahead of the game
dale.odonnell67d ago
Shea Lacey is a red. Give him a start tonight and show JJ’s dad what he cost his son.
thetruthpersonified67d ago
Two things I would suggest... Why did Carrick not give the lad a start in preseason or at least a whole 2nd half. And - we can all name a lot more top players from the Barca system than we can from United or any PL system. Timing feels v strange though!! Something has clearly happened..
dancoombs67d ago
Yeah. I did see a valid point made - why give Ethan Williams 45 mins vs Rosenborg if we were going to sell him and JJ is the future
spanishharlem68d ago
Darlow in. Amass in. Would now rest Bruno and Mainoo. Long season ahead. Would love to see Lacey in. Heaven I believe is going to be a fine player and Zirkzee. He's here so use him in rotation. Was good in preseason
seanfisher67d ago
You got it pretty spot on!
What is YOUR starting line-up for Manchester United vs Brighton?
calvinedube64867d ago
Yes
dancoombs68d ago
Another question - are we sure Lammens starts? Could we see Karl Darlow?
stephenjholmes168d ago
Wouldn't be the worst call. Lamens could do with time out of the limelight.
stephenjholmes168d ago
I would be playing Amass instead of Dorgu.
Michael Carrick gives Luke Shaw injury update
eoin68d ago
Surely give Amass the minutes, have seen far too little of him for a player in a position of such poor depth
geldroper68d ago
And he has to be fantastic otherwise Carrick is going tosay that he is no good. That would be his excuse evenknowing that has has not played for whenever at the first team.
dancoombs68d ago
Makes sense. Dorgu poor in derby, Mazraoui likely to play with Dalot rested at RB or vice versa - so play Amass - easy
adnan.riaz68d ago
As a Man Utd fan…

dancoombs68d ago
Oh yeah. The one game injury that turns in two that is suddenly two months and surgery.
There will be no VAR for Manchester United vs Brighton in the Carabao Cup... Are you happy?
dale.odonnell67d ago
Happy! VAR has been terrible for football.
roycheong1868d ago
I just find it ridiculous regarding Haaland's goal. Both Enzo and Haaland were obviously offside. How could his goal valid
dancoombs67d ago
There is just no explaining it. Ridiculous
johnmartin.jordan68d ago
Whatever about Var the next two games could decide Carricks Man Utd future ?
dancoombs67d ago
We must win vs Fulham and Spurs in the league. Gets tougher after that, Leeds, Bournemouth, Chelsea





knightinwhitesatin66d ago
Still we'd have faced City in the next round so wouldn't have gone much further
iceman2120266d ago
i think they should drop the back 4.............when playing a cup game you pick your strongest team....................
johnmartin.jordan66d ago
This United team going nowhere. Cannot see them getting any result in London weekend. Another loss may signal Carricks farewell in January.
dancoombs66d ago
We got to beat Fulham surely?!
freddie66d ago
Lacey was good, then that’s it! The rest need to look at themselves
vijarul66d ago
The team played like a lower division side, playing without commitment, intensity, control and pressing. Passed were sprayed all over. It's obvious that Carrick lacks tactical acumen, astute thinking and ability to improve individual players. If he continues the team will finish in the bottom half only if not relegated.
seunhurlag66d ago
God will bless you.. The team needs improvement and not with Carrick, because the team lack tactics, vision. Even the match we win. Man United don't play good football
roulsty7166d ago
They do it every time,get a new coach in play like champions,then it starts ,they just stop playing,they did it on every manager since Ferguson.I don't believe it's Michael Carrick. We have players who been there for years,it's time to get rid. Stop wasting money,get the players the fans deserve.
eugenepeter2066d ago
Carrick should be sack
dale.odonnell66d ago
Who’s your replacement?
patrockslowkey67d ago
Team looked the same against City. Very slow and sluggish to respond. FITNESS ?
seanfisher66d ago
Yeah the intensity and physicality is just not there. Really worrying
adnan.riaz67d ago
Dalot must be sold ASAP!
geldroper67d ago
He wqs terrible in preseason too; Just as Heaton, too old and bad but cheap. Just as our owners want
adnan.riaz67d ago
rbrown08065067d ago
No tempo, players looked unfit, overrun in midfield, sloppy in defence. Apart from that, it was great!
vijarul65d ago
Winning and losing is part of any sports but what's unacceptable is the way the team played in all the matches this season, no intensity, no pressing, no creativity and poor passing. And the Manager is squarely responsible for these pathetic displays. The earlier he is replaced the better for the team.
jjflash42267d ago
The midfield were invisible.they did absolutely nothing.
dale.odonnell67d ago
Couldn't agree more that the players don't look at it - fitness-wise - since the beginning of the season. A bigger worry is when they can't grind out results.
adnan.riaz67d ago
The tempo was seriously concerning. We looked lost as the match went on.
pranav.shahaney67d ago
Agree with this. Lacey looked like he was the only senior player playing with a bunch of kids from the academy. Shocking performance from United. The worst I’ve seen in years
dancoombs67d ago
I could probably give you five or six similar under Amorim maybe worse but I take your point! Terrible. Agree on Lacey. I’m concerned about Rashford a little
dale.odonnell67d ago
Not harsh... completely fair. A shocking display. The only player who looked like he wanted to be in the team to face Fulham on Sunday was Shea Lacey. The youngster was the silver lining on a disappointing night for United.
seanfisher67d ago
Completely agree, a small flicker of hope in an otherwise dismal display
stephenjholmes167d ago
I actually think there should be ratings for the coach. The starting 11 was suicide. You can't make 8 changes against a quality side. The substitutions were just as bad. I think Michael either needs to change his coaching staff, or he needs to walk. Having your mates around you, isn't good for business.
seanfisher67d ago
If there was a coach rating, what would you give Carrick out of 10?