TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Man Utd vs Brighton LIVE Carabao Cup clash

A very harsh set of player ratings are in... Who stood out for you for the wrong reasons?

Give us your player ratings below...

knightinwhitesatin2mo ago

Still we'd have faced City in the next round so wouldn't have gone much further

iceman212022mo ago

i think they should drop the back 4.............when playing a cup game you pick your strongest team....................

johnmartin.jordan2mo ago

This United team going nowhere. Cannot see them getting any result in London weekend. Another loss may signal Carricks farewell in January.

dancoombs2mo ago

We got to beat Fulham surely?!

freddie2mo ago

Lacey was good, then that’s it! The rest need to look at themselves

vijarul2mo ago

The team played like a lower division side, playing without commitment, intensity, control and pressing. Passed were sprayed all over. It's obvious that Carrick lacks tactical acumen, astute thinking and ability to improve individual players. If he continues the team will finish in the bottom half only if not relegated.

seunhurlag2mo ago

God will bless you.. The team needs improvement and not with Carrick, because the team lack tactics, vision. Even the match we win. Man United don't play good football

roulsty712mo ago

They do it every time,get a new coach in play like champions,then it starts ,they just stop playing,they did it on every manager since Ferguson.I don't believe it's Michael Carrick. We have players who been there for years,it's time to get rid. Stop wasting money,get the players the fans deserve.

eugenepeter202mo ago

Carrick should be sack

dale.odonnell2mo ago

Who’s your replacement?

patrockslowkey2mo ago

Team looked the same against City. Very slow and sluggish to respond. FITNESS ?

seanfisher2mo ago

Yeah the intensity and physicality is just not there. Really worrying

adnan.riaz2mo ago

Dalot must be sold ASAP!

geldroper2mo ago

He wqs terrible in preseason too; Just as Heaton, too old and bad but cheap. Just as our owners want

adnan.riaz2mo ago

rbrown0806502mo ago

No tempo, players looked unfit, overrun in midfield, sloppy in defence. Apart from that, it was great!

vijarul2mo ago

Winning and losing is part of any sports but what's unacceptable is the way the team played in all the matches this season, no intensity, no pressing, no creativity and poor passing. And the Manager is squarely responsible for these pathetic displays. The earlier he is replaced the better for the team.

jjflash4222mo ago

The midfield were invisible.they did absolutely nothing.

pranav.shahaney2mo ago

Agree with this. Lacey looked like he was the only senior player playing with a bunch of kids from the academy. Shocking performance from United. The worst I’ve seen in years

dancoombs2mo ago

I could probably give you five or six similar under Amorim maybe worse but I take your point! Terrible. Agree on Lacey. I’m concerned about Rashford a little

dale.odonnell2mo ago

Not harsh... completely fair. A shocking display. The only player who looked like he wanted to be in the team to face Fulham on Sunday was Shea Lacey. The youngster was the silver lining on a disappointing night for United.

seanfisher2mo ago

Completely agree, a small flicker of hope in an otherwise dismal display

stephenjholmes12mo ago

I actually think there should be ratings for the coach. The starting 11 was suicide. You can't make 8 changes against a quality side. The substitutions were just as bad. I think Michael either needs to change his coaching staff, or he needs to walk. Having your mates around you, isn't good for business.

seanfisher2mo ago

If there was a coach rating, what would you give Carrick out of 10?