TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Man Utd vs Brighton LIVE Carabao Cup clash

Manchester United are OUT of the Carabao Cup - Give us your INSTANT REACTION

2-0 up to 3-2 down... What went wrong?!

mazambanivs2mo ago

We need to get out of denial that Carrick has been weak against small teams from the beginning. In brief, something is not going right at training, I do not blame the players for that.

mazambanivs2mo ago

Marcus for me is a great player. Our team has better talent than the small teams that give Carrick a headache. Were it not for the VAR error, we could have drawn with Man City. I repeat, it is the technical management at training and during games that need strategically reorientation, with the same players. How are teams with less individual talent winning?

donaghcorby19972mo ago

They got pecked by the seagulls

niko2mo ago

Exiting Carabao, though painful, is not a death sentence. United squad is not as deep as other teams and its one irrelevant competition out of the way. I back Carrick to get it right with the depleted squad at his disposal, and management to recruit quality centre back and striker in January to prop up this depleted and injury prone squad.

niko2mo ago

How come United decisively defeated Brighton away last season but lost at home this season? Casemiro! United is suffering from post-Casemiro partum. We warned Sir Jim not to release such a vital player to United's formation without getting an adequate replacement in place. All our pleas fell on deaf ears. Carrick is never to blame, but the United conundrum.

stephenjholmes12mo ago

I think that they see Baleba as the replacement for Casemiro. Unfortunately if he ain't match fit then he can't put it into action. The biggest problem is that there is NO positional discipline throughout the team, especially in defense.

winva20022mo ago

I’m a bit superstitious, and I believe that bad luck came with Rashford’s return. I don’t think he’s bad—far from it, up to now he’s maybe even among the best. But, as I said, I believe there are “lucky” players and “unlucky” ones.

dancoombs2mo ago

What do you think is going wrong for Rashford? Not having much luck in front of goal atm

aaditya.krishnamurthy2mo ago

This is what happens when you’re unwilling to invest money for good players where you actually need them - the defense has been crying out loud for upgrades, especially at LB but the club just said they’ll make do with what they have and it’s cost them

camerondesc12mo ago

Pretty shocking, looked like a lot of the players didn’t care. Carrick is on borrowed time.

niko2mo ago

No. Carrick is here to stay!

reynoldsm98722mo ago

Honestly this show how much work the team need still and how much money club still need to spend as defending was awful in and we definitely need a left back as proves how light are in that area

dancoombs2mo ago

I was hoping he would give some minutes to Amass. It really seems like he doesn’t trust him. And in that case we should have bought

caleb.sage2mo ago

Carrick is finito. Last season was deffo a very long honeymoon period IMO.

niko2mo ago

Never say never. Carrick has just started. He now knows how the players fit in and who to rely on for what games, after giving everyone a chance. He will end up great.

davecarey282mo ago

Too many missing players on the pitch,. The team selection did not help it was risky from the start. Here we go again 2-0 up and lose a game, why can we not win when leading that is a big worry!

niko2mo ago

Failing to defend is a big worry.

masterageto2mo ago

We have no defence, even if at full strength we are weak, players bought are no more than average, The deep routed problems is no cash, even then quality proven players must be bought.

niko2mo ago

Only Martinez, Maguire, Dorgu, Dalot, Shaw and Ayden should be retained. The rest should be shipped out and replaced. They are not not good enough defence squad players.

jonathan.gorrie2mo ago

The attitude in that second half was alarming. Bleak, bleak stuff.

niko2mo ago

Yeah. The midfielders and Rashford were frustrated cos there was no strong striker to pitch the ball to. Certainly not Sesko who looked groggy throughout!

fresimon4real2mo ago

Too hard to accept this type of defeat, From 2 goals ahead to a defeat But, there's still room for improvement We can do it 💪🏋️👊

dancoombs2mo ago

I like the positivity

wjboxcar2mo ago

What carrick needs is a steady team to grow with confidence, stop this chopping and changing every so often, get your best team together and stick with them, notwithstanding injuries.

nichsmit92mo ago

This is what happens when you put out a C Team of underperforming trained seals. We had two Chelsea rejects, a Barca reject, a Leeds reject and Dalot...

coggy12mo ago

I didn’t understand the team selection when I saw it.For a team that used to win everything to one that wins very little why does Michael choose such a much changed team exempt of experienced players against a team which regularly beats us.Dont want to criticise Michael too much but he needs to rethink his approach to team selection Clive Cooper

peter.lynch2mo ago

Full credit to Brighton here, don’t sleep on them this season. Conceding goals yes, but playing some serious football 🔥

james.brooke2mo ago

Shouldn’t be a surprise really, Brighton are a better team wirh a much better coach. Why did United think they’d be better off by hiring a manager who Boro fans wanted gone? Will go down as one of the worst decisions of the post Fergie era I think

bill30p472mo ago

It's all Michael's fault, if he had put the right players on the pitch we would have won. Don't know what he is thinking.

delyuzar2mo ago

We really missed Casemeiro. Our defence is simply not good enough. It seemed the player need the real leader on the pitch..

stephenjholmes12mo ago

The problem is that they all bomb forward. Our DEFENDERS have NO positional DISCIPLINE. We will never win against any 1/2 decent team without a defence!

dancoombs2mo ago

No enforcer, no tough guy. Definitely a profile missing from the squad

steve.platt72mo ago

Diego Dalot should be dropped............from a great height, he's been stealing a living for years,tonight he was even worse than Sunday,and he was shite then, but Carrick is starting to look out of his depth, all the good work last season is unravelling, is it just a coincidence with Rashford being back in the team & the dressing room?? 🤔

delyuzar2mo ago

It probably is, Jose failed when Pogba returned with big money transfer, Ole failed when Christiano returned with massive salary. I just hope Rashford is not the case of this mess…

dale.odonnell2mo ago

Who starts ahead of him on Sunday - maybe Yoro? Could easily be the same again in the full-back positions unless Shaw or Dorgu return. I can't see Lacey starting at left-back against Fulham.

geldroper2mo ago

Glad I didn't see the game. It just would have made me mad. But Man U has to give Carrick 1 more change and if he is losing this one we have to see him gone.

dancoombs2mo ago

First 10 minutes were great!

barryroberts722mo ago

There is no way we will win anything with Carrick, i said that he was great when he took over and got us to 3rd. I thought it was going to be a tough one this season and i was right, the confidence within the team looks shattered from last season, already Fulham is a 6 pointer because of where we are in the PL if we had won on Sun we would be 4th/5th.

lee.connor2mo ago

Just not a very good side are they. Barely got a player who gets in any of the other top 6-7 teams in the league and that’s how far they’ve fallen.

stephenjholmes12mo ago

Every time a Manchester United stat is mentioned it gets wiped out. From loosing to lower league opponents, to loosing after being 2 up at home. The reality is we are on a downward spiral. I keep hoping we're turning a corner, but we keep turning the WRONG corner.

stephenjholmes12mo ago

The only positive to take from the result is that, City won't get to beat us with their under 9s

kyle.dimond2mo ago

Saw an incredible stat about this from Will Jeanes: “United have lost a game at Old Trafford that they were winning at half-time for the first time since Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom was released” Phenomenal.

dancoombs2mo ago

Temple of Doom feels a very good way to describe the feeling at full time

tariappah12mo ago

Is time man united need to sell the club outrightly because we need good investor our midfield add only one issue which was a 6 we needed defenders more but we ended up strengthen the wrong position

dancoombs2mo ago

Midfield did need strengthening. Jury still out on that business. No doubt that defence should have been a major priority too

geldroper2mo ago

Can"t blame to owners. It is clear half the team doesn't care if we win or lose. Never understood why anybody thought Dalot was something special. I do not blame Yoro and Heaven .Carrick has no interest in them and then they have to be heros, Amass still is not playing. He is going to be the next one who want the leave and who cn blame him under Carrick

berny1911ae2mo ago

Gone by December THE SACK

stephenjholmes12mo ago

Hopefully they will get some proper coaches in then. To think that giving the jobs to ex-players will produce the desired results is behaving like the amateur outfit that we look now. If you want quality you have to shop in the high end outfits. We are shopping in Aldi, and getting poundshop staff!

dancoombs2mo ago

I hate to say it but if carries on like this it won’t take until December.

lewiscraig22122mo ago

No desire, no idea, no togetherness, no team spirit. Dalot, Heaven, Yoro, Mazroui would not get in any top 10 Premier league defence.Too many 2nd shelf players

seanfisher2mo ago

Frustrating too that Carrick’s only real answer seemed to be throwing on attacking players and hoping that fixed it

dale.odonnell2mo ago

Game management has gone potty this season.

stephenjholmes12mo ago

I am surprised that you class Zebadee as an attacking player. He is awful. I really can't see for a second what he offers, other than getting caught on the ball, and giving it away.

thetruthpersonified2mo ago

Damn, I am back to again hoping I wake up to a United manager being removed. I knew it, which makes me more angry about the whole mess!

seanfisher2mo ago

You’re already Carrick out?

seanfisher2mo ago

Seriously that last 30 minutes was some of the worst football I’ve seen in the last decade. We were absolutely schooled.

dale.odonnell2mo ago

They had us squeezed in for far too long after their third goal. I was close to eye-gouging myself.

thetruthpersonified2mo ago

Agreed. It looked like pros v amateurs. Men v boys. Big club v small club. Schooled by a young manager who has a lot more of a clue than MC. So cross/gutted/disappointed/ashamed/ all of the above.. Arrrgghhhhh

jamie.theodosi2mo ago

It seems like being a man united fan is similar to being a Dallas Cowboys fan

dancoombs2mo ago

Similar issues with lack of defence

seanfisher2mo ago

Pain

antonymmartin842mo ago

My word. It has to be said, Carrick just isn’t the man for the job. Not good enough for one of the biggest jobs in world football. Brighton absolutely schooled them

dale.odonnell2mo ago

Certainly a hard watch...

george.patten2mo ago

That’s just who United are these days. Not the powerhouse they once were. Still can’t believe they went with Carrick. Literally history repeating itself with Ole

posix.forward2mo ago

Honestly, I have nothing to say. My last comment went to Moderation.

58taylorchris2mo ago

The Utd board must take some of the blame with lack of investment in the areas needed. Carricks calm manner is spreading throughout the team. No fire

dale.odonnell2mo ago

Carrick was calm as expected, but he looked and sounded deflated. Took responsibility and didn't throw his players under the bus. Not out of character. He cares, which was never clear under Amorim...

stephenjholmes12mo ago

The decision to concentrate on one area of the field is suicide. When we decide to replace the whole back line at the end of the season, we will see the same result.

pireocoffee2mo ago

Gos Manchester, Go City!

dale.odonnell2mo ago

#115

stephenjholmes12mo ago

I called it a few days ago. Let's see how much time Lacey gets now. Sesko is NOT a starting forward he is only slightly better than Zebedee. Impact sub is all he is good for. We have a grim season ahead!

dale.odonnell2mo ago

Sesko was dreadful. Offered zilch in attack and fell to the ground like a sack of spuds in the build-up to Brighton's goal, when he should have been stronger when holding up the ball. It epitomised his performance when he was flat-footed for Brighton's winner.

dancoombs2mo ago

Yeah I thought Sesko was very poor, too tentative and pulled out of challenges he could have won, including that one where the goalkeeper rushed out

bernadette.khoshaba2mo ago

I agree I don't see it in him...he looks lost and all out of ideas 🤔

jjflash4222mo ago

Agree,when the match needs something different,he doesn't know what to do.He goes to Holland for a chinwag before making a decision.I thought amorim couldn't make decisions mid game too.

dancoombs2mo ago

First thing we should get rid of Jonathan Woodgate as our defensive coach. If Carrick is to stand any chance he needs better around him

jonny2mo ago

I hate to say it, but I just don’t think Carrick has it in him to change this. I don’t want it to get toxic, but if we lose against Fulham we should probably make a change to try and save the season. We look worse than under Amorim right now

seanfisher2mo ago

This is also the first time I have seriously thought this

dale.odonnell2mo ago

I hate to say it, but I agree.

pranav.shahaney2mo ago

What didn’t go wrong? I know Carrick has not been backed in the market but that’s not an excuse for this joke of a performance. First time in 50 years United have lost a game after being two goals up at HT at Old Trafford. I don’t see a distinct identity or the players actually using their innovation. No ideas on how to build out from the back either

febced12mo ago

Absolutely embarrassing. You can never play a back four of Mazeroui, Dalot, and especially Heaven and Yoro. The latter 2 have no idea of the enormity of a club like Man United. You're setting yourself up for disaster. So, Carrick, had to replace the defenders which I wanted at halftime already.

dancoombs2mo ago

Yoro and Heaven showed why they are not a viable partnership right now. Lesson learned

markmarston2mo ago

Carrick needs more time but this stinks of Ole 2.0

thetruthpersonified2mo ago

No more time! Clueless and MC looked little boy lost. There is no tactics, no plan and poor fitness. Admittedly I was not in favour of him in first place. But that was beyond woeful. Brighton did not look remotely stressed with us being 2 up! Says a lot about United.

dale.odonnell2mo ago

Another disappointing blow so early in the season. Carrick is under the cosh now.

dancoombs2mo ago

I think we all knew what would happen when the draw was made but that doesn’t make this any easier. We should be winning especially after going 2-0 up

marshwire12mo ago

Appalling. Can't keep changing the Manager but need to improve veyy quickly.

chillout2mo ago

Even if you could change the manager, who is out there ?

thetruthpersonified2mo ago

Agreed, but have to pick the right manager to stick with!!

bernadette.khoshaba2mo ago

Sick of saying the same things..players not good enough...manager not good enough...poor signings...seriously what is happening 😳

dancoombs2mo ago

I feel your pain. This is on the coaching staff as much as the players. Not good enough

brook0102mo ago

What a waste. Started so well, got our hopes up and then trampled them again 🫠

stephenjholmes12mo ago

Life of a modern United fan.

seanfisher2mo ago

Old Trafford was rocking and everything seemed perfect. We don’t have that killer trait to finish games

dancoombs2mo ago

That was grim. Second half was absolutely awful. Poor off the ball and clueless on it. At 2-0 up we just eased off and you can’t do that at this level

chillout2mo ago

When does this start to become a crisis ?

dale.odonnell2mo ago

Did we have more than one shot on target after the 10th minute? 😐