Talk Celtic
Join the fan discussion on TalkingPoints around all the latest Celtic news, opinions, polls and updates.
1,335 comments
It’s not been easy for Luke McCowan at Celtic this season but how confident are you in him going forward?!
A VERY decent display against St Mirren 💪

HUGE injury blow as Mika Baur ruled out for up to 10 weeks! 😔 How do Celtic replace him?!

jasbarr85711d ago
I hope he does well but I feel he is too passive and lacks the will to be constantly in games.
johnprior9991d ago
We saw McCardle for 5 minutes last season and he looked good…. With the call to play the youngsters should he not get a chance????🍀
amirmir3h ago
He should and Donovan is an example of what they can produce. But then again, it took Johnston getting injured for Colby to play so much!
gegillies312d ago
Totally agree got to give the Ox a decent run get h I’ll m back to his proper form HH
amirmir3h ago
And the Ox produces!! 🍀🍀🍀
Here's our predicted XI to face St Mirren! What changes would you make? 👀

mrklln38902d ago
Johnson,.....CD, CCV, Trusty, LS ...........,CM, KT,.........Yang, MB, Jota.......Duran
Which Celtic player, past or present, would make the best GTA character and why?

ackie763d ago
Bertie Auld
mangomic83d ago
Burlington Bertie
amirmir4d ago
Neil Lennon. Big Bobo. And something tells me Samaras would fit right in
As Benjamin Nygren is a doubt, should Martin O’Neill try playing Kasper Hogh and Camilo Duran up top together against St Mirren?
What are the alternative ideas?

chrisjardine883d ago
ive been saying this since the start of season get the 2 of them up top together with Duran in behind or 2 together same line
petercassidy8543d ago
We need to get all the players really fit to many look tired after 70 mins " mcgregor slows play down by his side topside football and is so slow" nygren is never a midfield player he is also to slow and cant tackle.
jjc2734d ago
Hogh is going to go the same way as Adam Idah. Parkhead is a nightmare of a place for a traditional centre- forward as our pedestrian side to side slow pedestrian build up from the back supplies little or no service to the number 9.
What should Celtic do with Shim Mheuka in January?

andrewwestwood804d ago
I like him, hes got something but! Unless there is a loan to buy clause we need to develop our own before developing someone elses kids. This is why we end up with a second rate team, lack of development, a squad filled with loans and mediocrity.
bellm54795d ago
If their not doing it in training,their no gony magically start on the park G
johnprior9995d ago
As unpalatable as it is….. when any club spends serious money on a player he will play until such times that he turns the corner, another club gives you your money back or eventually he’s a real basket case and you take a massive financial hit… I think Dr Who will turn the corner…
Definitely give him a chance in the first team,as for giving oneil funds in January,I wouldn't save the money for the new manager in the summer, definitely don't want him to stay another year,we need to move on ,younger fresher manager McKenna for me
damiansmyth506d ago
Celtic will decide between now & mid January, if they actually need him . We need to play Duran , Høgh, & Osmand , they are our players & we must prioritise the 3 of them .We will have a better idea by then if we need him. Why should we discuss now before decision is needed it’s often better to decide at the appropriate time.
jasbarr85718d ago
Another manager, same doubts. As a Club we don’t have a defined playing system, which means we don’t sign the right type suitable for the team. New manager tries to determine type but in the end signings are a haphazard guess at sell on prospects.
Lucas Clearie is one of Celtic's most promising youngsters right now. Would you give him a chance in the first team?
The 17-year-old has 20 goals in 16 games for the B team 🔥
damiansmyth506d ago
I don’t think fans who probably never have actually seen him play , are best placed to decide whether Lucas Clearie is ready mentally & physically to play for ist team . Coming on a few minutes from end is no way to help to make decision .
gegillies317d ago
Why not give him a couple of games off the bench to see if he can perform in the big league can’t do much worse than what’s happening up front for us at the moment HH
amirmir6d ago
Celtic are too busy enhancing Chelsea's youngsters!
johnprior9997d ago
The best chance to keep these guys is to give them an opportunity….. the best come in and stay in….. McStay, Aiken, Forest, McGrady etc…🍀
amirmir6d ago
100%
Now that all of Celtic’s signings have had time to settle, what do you make of the summer business looking back?
Who has impressed and who has fell short of expectations?

andrewwestwood804d ago
Too many of the players we brought in thought Scottish football is a cake walk, now they're finding out the hard way.
gegillies317d ago
Duran and Baur are the only two who have come good as for our record signing couldn’t get rid of him fast enough another couple of the aforementioned haven’t really had much of a chance HH
stephenmunro7110d ago
Baur and Duran have been superb, I have every faith in Hogh once he finds the next.
ianmcwhinnie79d ago
@stephenmunro71 Hogh will come good i agree with you and the other 2 you have mentioned are playing brilliant and i think Duran will appreciate out on the wing when Hogh starts scoring and swapping places with Hogh
Where does Benjamin Nygren rank among Celtic signings in the 2020s?
Tell us your top three 👇

andrewwestwood804d ago
If he was a Striker id be all praise for him, but his actual ability as a midfielder is woeful.
joeydollard8310d ago
If he could add game to his goals he would be some player. His goals mask the fact is an average footballer at best
ggillespie06811d ago
He's a very average player who's movement off the ball is awful. A few luxury skills yeah, but goes missing in big games
What do you make of Martin O’Neill dropping Haissem Hassan from the Celtic squad?
Sebastian Tounekti was named as a sub ahead of him…

andrewwestwood804d ago
Another player that thought scottish football would be easy. There is a player there but hes now in his own head second guessing.
damiansmyth506d ago
Obviously fans who don’t know the whole picture can’t make a knowledge based decision. I am certain sure MO’N & SM will play what they think is the best team to win the game . It’s definitely in their best interest, & despite what some fans may think they know who gives them the best chance
dantowen8195111d ago
No issue with it really. If it’s a discipline or tactical issue, back MON. Let him set the standards
What have you made of Cameron Carter-Vickers' performances since returning from long-term injury for Celtic?

damiansmyth506d ago
CCV always thinks he is best cb at club. Many gullible fans believed him. Def Scales is better, I like Murray’s improvement&if he continues will be better than him . Trusty can’t be sure he has missed a lot with his father’s death , but when at his best ,he too is better than CCV who if he doesn’t find top form may well see h
johnprior99918d ago
Until his recent injury he’s been the most valuable player in the league. I think it’s poor that he is being written off so quickly after such a long lay off. Regrettably I accept that he’s lost a yard and if he can’t get back up to speed then it’s time up. However give the guy a bit of time….. he deserves it….🍀
jm94192119d ago
He is as slow as Player as i have seen takes a hour to turn maybe ok for American league
amirmir19d ago
He has declined in recent times, which is a massive shame.
Martin O'Neill is a Celtic legend but is under huge pressure right now. Where do you stand on his future

andrewwestwood804d ago
It really is like watching late 90s early 2000s football. Old tactics that are no longer relevant. Can't see any player being inspired by him or his plans for the future of the club, as there are none, its just let's focus on this season then watch the s**tshow unfold again next season.
damiansmyth506d ago
I think too many fans who MO’N rightly thinks they need their heads examined, have take a personal dislike to the man who rescued us not once but twice last season to win double . Shame on u .
ecosdoors119d ago
I never seen Martin putting it on a plate for Falkirk I never seen him blowing at least 8 golden Goal scoring easy chances .Yous all have short memories.Cut him a bit of slack and let’s move him upstairs Then bring in Lenny until the end of the season. Have a serious approach to Arne SLOTT .?just saying like . One MO’N K T F
Is Martin O’Neill calling all the shots in the Celtic dugout? Questions persist over Shaun Maloney’s role...
Discuss below 👇....

franceswhyte021d ago
Time for change of management that's it
mallinsonphil8621d ago
I wouldn't have maloney any where the tactics, should of gone at the end of the season with martin,it's got to be McKenna in the summer,not moyes massive backward step, boring football the fans won't tolerate that ,need a coach with fresh ideas sort the midfield out and defence,we do have some quality in this squad just tactics all wrong
gegillies3122d ago
I really don’t think all the blame lies at the door of coaching staff the players have got a lot to answer for as well they get paid exhorted wages every week and few put in a shift that deserves such riches , we have plenty of guys on our the sidelines who would probably try harder given the chance to play each week
Colby Donovan officially rewarded with a long-term Celtic contract 🍀 Give us your reaction 👇
alanbhoy7324d ago
I dont get it hes not a RB he wonders all over the park leaves the RB area empty open to counter attacks he has no pace allows crosses to come iit yet fans love him ? He always looks nakkered ? I dont get the hype
jasbarr857123d ago
How a player goes about a game is down to the manager.System of play, positioning and priorities all dictated by coach.
rnggpybk9g26d ago
I’m imagining most haven’t a clue about football not related to a defender..headless chicken running around after a ball …must be so they can sell him only reason …him scales and trusty absolute nightmares every time ball crosses halfway ..good to see Osmond back and jota will improve team .teams figured us out by standing next to mcgregor
johnprior99926d ago
Love it…..the silver cloud in AJ injury fiasco. There was a real danger Colby may never have got the extended run if games he needed to convince in a Celtic jersey…..👏👏👏🍀
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain isn't getting many minutes at Celtic - how do YOU feel about his bit-part role? 🤔

ericarfa196720d ago
The ox should try and leave in January transfer window.To good to be sitting on the bench.
calder197125d ago
Personally think he’s played well in the games he’s played in. But if sorenson is playing before you, then you have to question what’s going on
djdocherty5726d ago
He needs to get in team and play calmac could do with the rest would be good to see how he interacts with Baur
What do you make of Rod Stewart's comments? Do the Green Brigade boycotters have a point? 🤔

ericarfa196720d ago
Rod stewart should go to a nursing home and fade away
boyddickson83129d ago
Who does that geriatric lassie think she is! To talk about the greengrocers that way 😞
amirmir26d ago
🤣🤣🤣
mr.ross29d ago
Yes Rod how many European Trophies..!
Rate Callum Osmand's performance vs Hearts out of 10. Does he start against Celta Vigo?
Former Celtic striker Tony Watt has high praise for the 20-year-old 🙌

billymc61230d ago
Should be 1st on the team sheet after hearts and celta perfirmance, sadly now he prob be out a while,pray not. 🥴🤞🙏
mickmurph196731d ago
Should start
gegillies3132d ago
Boy was a solid 9 , deserves to start on Thursday Hail Hail
Is a front three of Osmand, Duran and Hassan Celtic's strongest attacking line-up now? If not, who comes in instead?
Yang, Jota and others are all in contention too...

pagrant84.ec27d ago
Nigrien wow just done nothing for 90 mins he ain't no midfielder ever
pagrant84.ec27d ago
Magregor is done taking up space used to dictate I haven't seen anything this season at all
pagrant84.ec27d ago
Hassan total waste of money final ball is absolutely shocking does nothing but look good no point if u can't deliver I would put osman in midfield because he can run at people that's what we are lacking in midfield put yang or jota on left feeding osman no brainer
How did Landon Emenalo get on today? Saw he made his debut at last!
billymc61234d ago
The bhoy was solid
gegillies3132d ago
Mheuka needs game time he looks the part and he works hard just needs a bit of consistent game time and I think he’ll really come in to his own HH
callum_boyle34d ago
Yeah agree with Amir. Looked rusty and nervous but he has had little senior football experience so to be expected. Didn’t stop him from shying away and having Mheuka there too will help. The latter definitely needs to play more, I love his work rate
jamesshearman2334d ago
Nice one mate. I’ll be keeping an eye on both as they’re two of our best prospects 👀
amirmir35d ago
Well off the pace. But didn't stop him from getting and wanting the ball. He hasn't kicked a ball in so long, and it's his debut, so it's normal to not be at the pace. But very excited about Emenalo and Shim. The latter looks seriously good.
jamesshearman2335d ago
I assume it’ll be tough for Emenalo to break into the starting XI ahead of Tierney but he looked great in preseason so I’m confident he’ll get better. Would love to see Mheuka get some more game time too as he looks a special talent as you say
Celtic's victory against Hearts may not be one of their biggest in SPFL history but it comes close. Where does that performance rank compared to their highest-scoring wins?
Since Hearts were a title rival last season, that's got to make it one of the best :thinking_face:

carlosmarvelos34d ago
A great result, but it's not the strike partnership that fails us in Europe, but the inability to defend, be it through quality or coaching issues. The greatest of strikers can't shoot from his own penalty box. Our central defenders are basic squad players and we've been crying out for strong defensive midfielders for years
amirmir32d ago
Agree. Without the ball, we cannot cope in Europe!
mickmcbride9534d ago
great victory bit still slack at defending need to do more
amirmir34d ago
Lack of investment at CB could be an issue long term
amirmir35d ago
Better than all those on that list because it's against 'title challengers' 😉
What are your thoughts on the criticism Martin O'Neill is receiving? Is it justified? 🤔

gegillies3132d ago
I don’t want MON to leave he has been a legend for us and I want him to leave a winner but I do think we need someone new maybe big Ange back HH
gegillies3134d ago
I think MON is a legend but I do think it’s time for him to retire and bring back big Ange who played proper attacking football like we witnessed against Hearts , his decision to leave out Tounekti was right he’s not good enough for a team like Celtic young Osmund been out for a while and he done more in 1 game than Tounekti has done since arriving HH
hunt87834d ago
Tounekti is not good enough to pull a celtic jersey over his head again.HH
Club record signing Kasper Hogh has scored in just ONE game this season...Why is he struggling so much?!
jas116033d ago
Id hope Celtic coaches have him and a couple of wingers firing in crosses from both sides incessantly to build his confidence. We can't give up on him, should Duran be injured Hogh needs to be ready.
scorc352935d ago
Firstly Look at how bodo used him and played with him then look at how we use him. There’s a huge difference. Secondly, his confidence is now shot. Use him correctly and watch him score for fun. Use him how we are just now and watch him struggle. It’s really that simple.
petercassidy85436d ago
Got to be very honest just dont rate him he should be by now getting used to how we play" but is slow and just not sharp enough in the penalty area maybe just needs a goal to get him going but its worrying how bad he has been.
How far away are Celtic from genuinely competing with sides like Benfica and why?
peter.kanesr37d ago
Light years away, thank feck we didnt make the champions leage proper or we could have taken sevcos record of the worst team in CL history
kennethmcglin195237d ago
Miles away there scouts are damaging the club, bringing in players that wouldn't get a game in a pub team get rid now Starting with the Captain his legs have gone his passing is dire Murray a joke, Trusty a disaster, Vicers injury prone, could mention a lot more but my finger is to sore
freddie37d ago
A long long long long long long long way off… is that enough longs?
How high is the bar for Colby Donovan, and what can he achieve in his career?
johntaggart120138d ago
He is certain to move away from Celtic to a English club maybenot too a premier league club but championship club for certain i would expect this too happen in the January window,he deserves it he has been our best player from the start of the season
amirmir38d ago
I can't see him leaving in Jan, but I agree, he is showing qualities English teams would love. I hope his love for Celtic keeps him at the club for years, because how everything is being run right now, the club doesn't deserve him.
jas116039d ago
So Guidi thinks McKenna is fave for Celtic job😱. No shit Sherlock, next he'll tell us Friday follows Thursday!
petercassidy85436d ago
What has he won with Ipswich promotion to epl lasted a season back down again .
billymc61237d ago
Dies it not ?? 🤔🥴🫣
oneillgeorge197139d ago
Robbie Savage - the player that Third Prize FC didn't want when he offered to play for free.
The Green Brigade have announced a boycott of Scottish Cup and Europa League matches… thoughts? 👀
andrewwestwood804d ago
Sadly stinks like theyve thrown the toys out the pram because the Europa isnt prestigious enough for them. If we qualified for the CL the board would still be the board and TGB would all be falling over themselves for tickets. Quite sad really.
awilson188840d ago
Good,they are just neds that have cost Celtic fortunes In fines
malcolmmckinlay2340d ago
With you W
malcolmmckinlay2341d ago
Get on and support the CLUB
conor.mccarthybft41d ago
Exactly pick your battles and back the team.
What do you make of Martin O'Neill's decision to protect the board?
davidberry75044d ago
Protesting wearing balaclavas is a ridiculous way to act. Too many fans ignoring this. I'm now looking forward to the next European game without the GB.
kate.mckenna170144d ago
I think those who seem to think they are, if not bigger than the club, at least bigger than MON, need to take a good look at themselves. There are a lot of fans outside the 'Collective' echo chamber, and they don't necessarily see you the way you see yourselves.
billymc61244d ago
On destroying our great club, open your eyes young lady
billymc61244d ago
You go take a good look at yourself,as a lifelong fan my father took me to lisbon never missed a game since i was 9yrs old, home and away, this board emulates the kelly's thats a statement i never thought i could say, before you rant on, desmond & lawell ha taken more money out of celtic than anyone in our history!! Fact.. also at this stage desmond is bent
freddie45d ago
He shouldn’t be the fall guy, simple as.
What are your thoughts on the Celtic fan protest? Was it the right thing to do? 👀
johnprior99942d ago
Unity wins……🍀
jasbarr857144d ago
Yes
brendyadams45d ago
Im on mixed views on it,thers ways to proteat the anger but protesting against desmond has shown in the past that stadium protests just arnt getting to him,hes blanking the message & the problems so do whats needed to get the message across,hes a stubbourn c##t and thinks hes above celtic,hasnt put a penny into the club,players r bought threw sales of others
callum_boyle45d ago
What do you reckon is the best way to protest? Is it the case of we simply have to stay away from the ground?
Is Celtic’s board completely out of touch with its supporters?
billymc61244d ago
And so are you and your lackey son,
conor.mccarthybft45d ago
Fully agree then leave ....
sammcewan301246d ago
No accountability treat the fans like mugs must have been livid they spoiled his game of golf how dare show displeasure with the establishment, I for one in full support of anyone standing up to this corporate malevolence
kennyhunt10245d ago
No real fans mindless thugs there is other ways of showing your discontent
Which former Celtic player would you add to the current team, and why? 🤔
andrewwestwood804d ago
Henrik with his broken leg would still ve better than most of the crock of s**t we have the now. But different times and football in general is different.
kempdouglas4014d ago
Johnstone , nobody close. Even Larson.
jasbarr857137d ago
Davey Hay.our current midfield is not fit for purpose.
Brendan Rodgers is set to return to Glasgow next year for a Q and A with Celtic fans but if you could only ask him one question, what would it be and why?
jjc27327d ago
Why let that Rat Rodgers into Glasgow again 😨 His style of pedestrian possession football has hampered our team's progress & development.
conor.mccarthybft45d ago
See when you burn toast is it ok then scrape the brunt bit?
wylie_p49d ago
Why did you turn your back on us when we were trying for 10? Was it worth it?
King Kenny makes it to number 39 on TalkingPoints' 50 best footballers of all time! Is that a fair ranking? 👀🍀
madmick88750d ago
I would say yes in world ranking but in British top Ten.
tmcq5051d ago
Having saw Kenny play for Celtic, Liverpool and Scotland he should be much higher than that, the problem is that the majority voting are young and never saw the great man play. If it was down to me he's top 10 easily he was a fabulous footballer it's laughable he's that low down.
freddie50d ago
I probably count as one of the young ones but I’d deffo have him higher based on everything my dad has told me about him ahaha. His favourite ever player
paddy51d ago
39 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 ffs
freddie50d ago
Where would you have put him?
Which Celtic players would get into Rangers' team, and why? Or is Alan Hutton correct? 😳
markmarston49d ago
No bias here…
conor.mccarthybft50d ago
Full of shit
sean7051d ago
Don't know what was funnier Ironsides Hairdoo or his utter lies. 😂
Hugh Keevins has claimed that Rangers will walk their way to the title ahead of Celtic 😯 What is your message to him?
billymc61244d ago
It won't happen
jimgemmell3852d ago
A bit early for those comments , but celtic need changes in January
awilson188852d ago
Keevins reek of urine
What do think of Nygren hitting back at Celtic critics? Fair or has he missed the point?
jas116052d ago
I believe our rot set in from his back pass that led to LASK opening goal. Time for him to shut it and prove hes good enough to start. I have big doubts
jasbarr857154d ago
He should do his talking on the park.
paddy54d ago
He does with goals. But we need more from him
mmaca195855d ago
As a long time sufferer of negative comments online, he has my sympathy 😂
How do you now feel about Celtic's decision to let Stephen Welsh leave?! 🤔
jas116052d ago
Typical from our useless board, but apparently MON didn't fancy him😱😱😱
paddy55d ago
Welsh was simply not good enough. I’ve no idea why we keep coming back to this.
jimmy1888.cfc56d ago
He was a good servant but obviously was losing faith when he had a good season a few years back and they then brought in garbage to replace him happens all the time with academy players they leave celtic and get games like calum on loan and scales on loan and Christie on loan some come back improved some just keep getting farmed back out but good luck
paddy55d ago
The problem for Welsh and other players who have left Celtic like him is that he couldn’t handle the pressure of winning every week. That’s why he’s shining where he is
What did you make of Carter-Vickers’ comments? Is Sutton correct or was the defender simply telling the truth? 🤔
jonf606755d ago
Remove Martin O'Neill from the equation and our coaching staff hardly set the Heather on fire. Whatever the coaching staff are doing the style we're known for isnt there, the fitness isnt there.. we seem incapable of playing thru a high press, consistently give away the ball under no pressure. in the final third don't seem to able to put in a decent cross
amirmir54d ago
The fitness part is spot on. Very concerning.
jasbarr857156d ago
Sutton sees no wrong from his former boss.The coaching is very suspect, tactics are rigid and fitness levels seem short of what is required.
paddy55d ago
He can’t see past O’Neill’s failings and that is clouding his judgement
callum_boyle56d ago
They’re all like it though. Lennon, Stan Petrov etc. We all admire and love O’Neill for what he did in that first spell and last season but he can’t be immune from criticism. Baffling take from Sutton
paddy56d ago
Sutton is so far off the mark here it's unreal. CCV was simply giving an honest account of what EVERY Celtic fan can see. Sutton has had a nightmare here.
Who is Celtic's best winger right now and why?
jimmy1888.cfc56d ago
Remember we still have the superstar from Portugal
amirmir55d ago
I agree. But he has been out for so, so long, you worry if he will find his touch, speed and form again. This isn't any normal injury lay off.
johntaggart120157d ago
If james forrest could last 90min i would have no hesitation in saying him, toneski just doesent do enough for me he is the only winger that goes backwords more than he goes foward , We have to give hassan time before we can judge
jasbarr857159d ago
Yang by some distance. Defends better, works more consistently and scores some goals.
amirmir58d ago
Aye, without the ball he is underrated, more so when you consider how that midfield is without the ball.
Eddie Howe...c'mon guys..wise up...Neil Lennon will be the cheaper choice and a nice wee don't rock the boat guy...start from the top and work through the team and get rid of the deadwood..mcgregor included..the guys past his sell bye date..🇮🇪
liamwinning8859d ago
100% Peter..id do it myself but i have a job that keeps me on my toes..🇮🇪
petercassidy85459d ago
Howe going to either manu or spurs depends what manager gets sacked first who in there right mind would want to manage celtic in this present situation .
paddy60d ago
There will be riots if Lennon is anywhere near The Celtic Way
After pulling out of the Scotland squad, would retiring from international football help prolong Kieran Tierney's Celtic career?
mrcrobo6056d ago
Yes , unlike Scales whose international career should now finish his Celtic one after he was one of those voted to play that game against israel especially as he had a choice .
araff6158d ago
I thought he had retired from football, returned to us just to top up his pension. At least thats what it looks like from my seat.
matherskorbean59d ago
Keep moving the international is vital to the country, that we back our country,and stand strong as we evolve in the mould, ..........3



dantowen819511h ago
He’ll have to get up to speed quickly! He’s clearly not a long term answer but against average domestic sides he’ll be fine
mm1972w1h ago
big games NO..that yesterday was his standard it's not just him they are other players that's their standard to
amirmir32m ago
Agree but I would keep him in the starting XI for now though. Let's see how he uses this confidence which he hasn't had for a long while.
jasbarr85712h ago
He lacks pace and panics in high pressure games. He played well yesterday but they are not a good side. I do wish him to succeed; it’s up to him if he can raise his game.
amirmir34m ago
Agree. He needs to be much further up the pitch. He can't handle the ball when dropping deep.