TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk

Next Celtic manager

Join the fan discussion on TalkingPoints about who should be the next Celtic manager.

575 comments

Could Roberto Martinez be Martin O'Neill's long-term replacement at Celtic?

Martinez will leave Portugal, regardless, after the World Cup. Your thoughts, Celtic fans...🍀🇵🇹👇

J

jas1160138d ago

If his favoured tactics were anything like last night then it's a no from me. I reckon Kieron McKenna is having time out before coming in next season.

M

martin.crawford158d ago

I'd be torn on it. Very similar to Rodgers as a manager, so if he can have the same level of success I'd be delighted

Open full discussion →

Lots of Celtic fans unhappy with Robbie Keane's candidacy...

A

amirmir169d ago

Thank god he isn't going to manage Celtic. If Desmond has any sense, he doesn't consider Keane ever again. He showed his true colours by going to I*rael.

F

ftgb1887169d ago

Isræli spy Robbie Keane

L

liamwinning88169d ago

The right man was picked for the job..god bless martin o'neil..🇮🇪

Open full discussion →

Your reaction to the latest development in the Celtic manager race?

J

johnprior999171d ago

There is obviously more to this than it being a two horse race. Personally I don’t fancy Keane but not from an any other angle than a football one. We have enough issues at Celtic without looking for other “ causes” …….focus on your own flag…..🍀

M

martin.crawford170d ago

Unless we've kept it very quiet, it certainly appears that Keane and O'Neill are the only two candidates

H

hush1888171d ago

Got to be Keane, he’s a born winner and will continue the success and also take us further in Europe. Get it announced Celtic and give him funds to rebuild.

P

paulkelliher88164d ago

Well said I support Celtic first Im Irish & they come a close second . Don't have ANY interest in Palastine or Israel or Iran ect ect . I'm a catholic so have no interest in islam or Jewish conflicts . Keep it out of Celtic park

W

will1888171d ago

Hi,you say keane is a winner, on clubs and country he has managed can you tell me exsctly on what is he a winner, as on celtic brother walfrid was a winner for what the club does,keane has went against what celtic were founded for.(self centred manager) A BIG NO

M

martin.crawford171d ago

Big statement, hope you're right

W

will1888172d ago

There are many of us who dont want keane,infact it is thousands of us who dont want keane, again there will probialy be some fans,that will react badly..

P

paulkelliher88164d ago

But there are also thousands that really don't care about Israel or don't want to get involved in it . There are TWO sides to the conflict . No one wants conflicts or devide .. but people like you (( typical left wing )) want devide .

M

martin.crawford171d ago

Bound to happen

Open full discussion →

Phone him Celtic ffs! Should we get Ange Postecoglou back?

F

ftgb1887169d ago

M

martin.crawford173d ago

I'd give a few vital organs for Ange back

J

jas1160172d ago

Angeball was exciting the first season, during the 2nd season SPL opponents worked out his tactics and he got the Spurs job just in time before he was found out completely. He wont be back.

Open full discussion →

Get the japan coach plays amazing football

P

paddy173d ago

That's a bold shout! Not sure if his management style would suit Celtic

Open full discussion →

I agree with johnrmac

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

If it comes down to these two... who are you picking as Celtic manager?

W

will1888172d ago

Bellamy

F

fezzderges173d ago

Keane easy

M

martin.crawford172d ago

Whilst both lack experience, Bellamy's body of work certainly shows a style of football that Celtic could do with

S

sionbhoy88173d ago

Neither of them , Belllamy has already stated that he wants to stay with the Welsh team, as for Keane he’s just not good enough full stop

M

martin.crawford172d ago

Interesting to hear McGowan saying today that Bellamy is still in the running. He may not be telling the whole truth

Open full discussion →

Have Celtic missed out by not hiring Jens Berthel Askou?

J

johnrmac123178d ago

I’m reading some strange statements on good riddance to Jens Berthel. I think this guy could have been one of the greatest managers to grace Celtic. The way he talks and conducts himself and most importantly the freedom his team played with. Motherwell were wonderful to watch this year.. Our league requires managers like him to put up exciting challenges.

M

martin.crawford177d ago

Totally agree, pulling the wool over your own eyes to say that there wasn't something special going on at Motherwell this year. I'd have taken him. Let's see how he does in France

M

mckeendianne179d ago

Absolutely NOT.. he is not good enough for Celtic.. good riddance.

L

lonecelt67179d ago

After his reaction to our late penalty award I lost any hope/interest that he would be a potential Celtic Manager. We can do better

Open full discussion →

Should Celtic hire Jens Berthel Askou as the next manager?

What do you think? Let us know in the comments 👇

G

gegillies31186d ago

If he decides to come to Celtic I'd be really happy , look how he got Motherwell playing were probably the best attacking side in the league , if he can do that with a team with a lot less resources than Celtic I'd love to see what he can make us produce I think he'd be a great addition 🍀

S

spanielodonel976186d ago

No give job to Martin O'Neil for as long as he wants to stay let him get some new players in take it from there 😉

A

alangodfrey123187d ago

Definitely he has experience of managing in Scotland and has his Motherwell side playing very good football. A style i'd love to see Celtic return to. I'd also like to see MON retained as Director of Football.

Open full discussion →

Should Celtic re-appoint Neil Lennon as manager?

Chris Sutton has completely shut it down!

P

paddy184d ago

God no

R

rycemcdonagh197d ago

NON

A

amirmir197d ago

Great to hear everyone is aligned and it's a big fat no.

Open full discussion →

No to Bellamy either, was a good striker but not the temperament to be a Celtic manager.

P

paddy184d ago

No chance

D

dhxw448m5f180d ago

No wise person has suggested N Lennon . He has certainly given enough to Celtic

Open full discussion →

Steve Clark, no way , snoresville football , would not play Celtic way.

P

paddy184d ago

Get that so far to f….

Open full discussion →

I hope Scott Brown gets to manage Celtic one day , just not yet.

P

paddy184d ago

Don’t think it will happen for him I’m afraid

M

martin.crawford199d ago

He'll have to earn the right, which he certainly hasn't done yet

Open full discussion →

Think I would do to be fair - he’s achieved a fair bit in a few countries with some high-pressure clubs

D

dhxw448m5f189d ago

Neil Lennon has been a true Celtic legend , who risked his life for Celtic , I think we should remember him gladly and enjoy all the trophies he helped us to win

Open full discussion →

Just don't take SCOTT BROWN lol

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Should Celtic make a decision on Martin O'Neill's permanent future before the end of the season?

K

keenanjohn148184d ago

Yes A.S.A.P

M

mikeymo485192d ago

Martin is a legend brought back twice to save the team from total disasters.

B

boyleb1959198d ago

As long as he is healthy and wants the job. He has done wonders for the Celts. Deserves the respect. Hail Hail !!

Open full discussion →

No chance

B

bill_hancock233d ago

I have been following Knutsen and BODO/GLIMPT for a few seasons now. There has a few top European clubs sniffing around him and he has turned them all down. I can't see Celtic having enough pull to be able to entice him to Paradise.

B

billybarry9213d ago

Yeah bud, I completely agree with EVERYTHING you have said. I'd love Knutsen, but I doubt he would come to us, although, you never know. Celtic are a massive draw.

C

callum_boyle231d ago

One of the reasons why Knutsen is so successful is because he has the licence to do anything he wants to make the team better. No chance Desmond and co will allow that

Open full discussion →

Martin O'Neill along with Shaun Maloney would be brilliant

D

dhxw448m5f189d ago

There isn’t a snowball in hell’s chance of that partnership & although it was a brilliant partnership this year , I very much doubt if it would be repeated next season

Open full discussion →

Steve Clarke to Celtic: yes or no?

B

boyleb1959198d ago

No

B

brycecarroll67207d ago

No

R

roncophotography208d ago

Done his coaching badges with Fred Flintstone n Barney Rubble.If you want stone age fitba,then he's yer man.

Open full discussion →

Mon dof maloney manager megregor his no2

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

He'd be good but he needs a good transfer budget to build his own squad so the board better splash some cash

D

dhxw448m5f189d ago

The Board will not be found wanting, as long as manager & recruitment team work with Board , they will have agreed budget, but if manager goes public blaming Board wrongly ,then co- operation may no longer exist & transfer money dry up

Open full discussion →

Bellamy that is

B

billybarry9213d ago

I don't think Bellamy's the right man for Celtic. Managing an international team is COMPLETELY different to managing a domestic team, especially a club the size of Celtic Football Club.

Open full discussion →

He wouldn't come to the club as far as I have heard.

R

roncophotography199d ago

Clarke said he wouldn't either.But that was because he was smart enough to realise he had as much chance as I had of being offered the job.

Open full discussion →

He has seriously impressed in charge of Wales...

D

djdocherty57180d ago

No

M

martin.crawford184d ago

Yes, I'd be massively in favour of Bellamy having watched his Wales side... shades of Ange with the football. He's a fantastic communicator, too. Not many better options for us should MON leave

B

boyleb1959198d ago

No

Open full discussion →

Celtic dont want keene wee need two bring neil lennon back its lennon for me

C

charlie.k229d ago

Sorry under no circumstances bring Lennon back

R

rvybw9z4yf228d ago

I was a great supporter of N Lennon the player & the manager , but he has done 2 stints as manager & 2 is definitely enough

Open full discussion →

Why not offer the celtic job to neil lennon he was a loyal celtic man he is celtic threw and threw just like martin oneill thats my opinion wee don need to look far its lennon for me

S

scorc3529251d ago

He’s had 2 goes at it already and the second time around ended up a complete bust.

B

billybarry9213d ago

Look, Celtic need a man who can take the team to the next level. Winning quadruple trebles was great, but what happened when we went up against clubs in Europe? We need a proven manager to take us into European competitions and make an impact

Open full discussion →

Agree or disagree?

L

lynnfin123191d ago

I totally agree with billybarry9

M

markrigley49191d ago

Appoint Larsson or Lubo or even both !!

L

liamring50192d ago

Agreed

Open full discussion →

If Martin wins the league should he stay on a permanent contract?

S

scorc3529254d ago

It depends on his appetite for the job and whether he himself believes he is fit enough for it. He looks absolutely drained at every post match interview. But if he wins the league then we should at least have the decency to find out.

R

roncophotography208d ago

If we win the double I feel he should be allowed to decide if he takes the reins for another season.You're right about him being drained, but when he took over the team was running on fumes.If the board hadn't halted his progress with the Nancy farce we would be chasing a treble.

P

paddy256d ago

I don't think he has the appetite mate.

Open full discussion →

Jens Berthel Askou to Celtic: do you see it happening?

S

synhmc5f5h198d ago

I don’t think someone who can only get the better of us when we have Nancy in charge is the ideal or appropriate choice.

J

james.hamill22198d ago

Yes

J

jas1160198d ago

Desmond will be looking southwards to Cardiff where an Irishman has been managing, Brian Murphy will be his choice, unfortunately!

Open full discussion →

Martinez is overrated, and achieved next to nothing. Everton went backwards under him. If we can't get Knutsen, we must move for Askou before another club snaps him up.

S

scorc3529261d ago

Knutsen. MON. Ange. Askou. In that order of preference. If nothing comes of that then consider others.

Open full discussion →

He is on a short-term contract at Sweden...

M

mcewen27251d ago

No way

K

kennyogden1251d ago

I'd rather have Nancy back ffs.

M

monser1964252d ago

No he had his chance

Open full discussion →

Who would you prefer to become the next Celtic manager?

Tell us why in the comments...

T

tom.mcveigh24227d ago

Martinez is experienced and knows the markets. He wouldn't accept 2nd best from the Celtic board

G

grayneil227d ago

Neither. Take the punt on Knutsen from Bodø/Glimt

R

rvybw9z4yf228d ago

The manager I want is someone who can discuss candidly with Board & be capable of winning Board to his way of thinking .A Board at loggerheads with manager is unlikely to have a good team of players

Open full discussion →

Absolutely boring ho in but wouldn't he come

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →