TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk

Manchester United vs Aston Villa LIVE - Premier League November 8

462 comments

Man Utd draw 4-4 with Aston Villa - What is your INSTANT REACTION?

What does this mean for Michael Carrick’s job?

R

rayjud13d ago

In my opinion the first order of business should be to remove Lammens (not good enough), too many mistakes each game, and costing us points. Onana is not the answer either! Find one!!!

D

dancoombs12d ago

Short term I don’t know what the answer is there. I don’t want to see Karl Darlow or Tom Heaton in goal

S

stephenjholmes112d ago

@rayjud Lammens has been hung out to dry because of a team who have zero idea of how to defend. The coaching team are setting them up to bomb forward without any defensive discipline. Lammens has been emotionally destroyed. Started with his mistake at the World Cup, and has continued ever since. Zero clean sheets, zero confidence.

C

cwalker1415913d ago

The International break is the ideal time to change a manager without having to appoint a caretaker. I worry that the club are going to dither and miss their chance. There are several candidates who would be an upgrade on Carrick. Just pick one and get it done.

P

phillipmaxwell202313d ago

Man utd could bring in Scott Golbourne to help coaching the defence.Dean Ashton as a striker coach. Also get the team on creatine energy boost tablets and L Carnitine, keep battling Man Utd and recruit Wilfried Zaha to boost morale in the team. Phill.

B

barryhhd13d ago

Hahaha thats funniest thing I've read, get them on lucozade and Mars bars, and call in the coach from jossies giants 😂

T

thetruthpersonified13d ago

Sorry. How does Zaha boost morale? He he suddenly something of a global motivator?

Open full discussion →

Yellow card for Aston Villa's Zion Suzuki! 90+7'

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

P. Dorgu scores for Manchester United 4-4 90+6'

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

Utterly crazy. EIGHT GOALS at Old Trafford? Can't believe it.

Open full discussion →

Never give up!!!

D

dantowen8195114d ago

A tale of two full-backs today 🤣

D

dantowen8195114d ago

One masterful, one moronic

C

chillout14d ago

But in truth you don’t know whether to laugh or cry.

Open full discussion →

J. Zirkzee scores for Manchester United 3-4 90+2'

F

febced114d ago

I believe in Zirkzee, the Dutch international. He's not serviced as an attacker,, making him the target of unfair nasty comments by OUR fans.

Open full discussion →

Aston Villa makes a change

IN: Brian Madjo OUT: Nicolas Jackson 86'

G

geldroper14d ago

The left side is been a disaster already for weeks or better since the begin of the season a. And Amass still got no real game under Carrick just as Lacey. Hope is gone after today

Open full discussion →

IN: Joshua Zirkzee OUT: Bryan Mbeumo 83'

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Aston Villa makes a change

IN: Ibrahim Mbaye OUT: Leon Goretzka 78'

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Aston Villa makes a change

IN: João Gomes OUT: Johan Manzambi 78'

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Maachistar

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Aston Villa makes a change

IN: Ross Barkley OUT: Alysson Edward Franco da Rocha 71'

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Aston Villa makes a change

IN: George Hemmings OUT: John McGinn 71'

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

IN: Shea Lacey OUT: Amad Diallo 66'

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

IN: Patrick Dorgu OUT: Diogo Dalot 66'

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

IN: Mason Mount OUT: Youri Tielemans 66'

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Yellow card for Ayden Heaven! 57'

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

L. Goretzka scores for Aston Villa 2-4 53'

C

chillout14d ago

This is really rubbing every Manchester United’s fans’ nose in it.

J

james.brooke14d ago

What is Yoro doing

D

dancoombs14d ago

No idea. Heaven has chance to clear it too

E

epi2media14d ago

Can anyone make this up?

Open full discussion →

Shambles

E

epi2media14d ago

I remember playing football as a kid- there were no coaches/managers. At least we showed skill and purpose. These guys are just dreadful!

G

geldroper14d ago

Sorry but stop blaming the owners. The players were good when they came here. The training must be bad and a coach who has no idea what he is doing. His selection has been crap since the beginning of the season He has to leave

E

epi2media14d ago

This is relegation football. The EPL table doesn't lie. This is shocking football for an EPL side.

D

dancoombs14d ago

The defending gives me most cause for concern out of anything. I don’t think Carrick is capable of fixing it

Open full discussion →

J. McGinn scores a penalty for Aston Villa 2-3 48'

Scored from the penalty spot

M

mohan1831014d ago

Want to break my screen with frustration

G

geldroper14d ago

@mohan18310 They are not worth it anymore. Dalot can shoot in his own goal on purpose and Carrick would put him in next game. Dalot should have came nowhere near the field but he is Carrick's sweetheart so he plays just as Martinnez. Hope they fir Carrick today

D

dancoombs14d ago

Another shocking start to a half

G

geldroper14d ago

@dancoombs Expected nothing else

Open full discussion →

IN: Ayden Heaven OUT: Harry Maguire 45'

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Manchester United 2–2 Aston Villa

It's all square at the break

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

What a crazy first half!

D

dancoombs14d ago

hopefully we have a second half like we did vs Ipswich...

D

dale.odonnell14d ago

Shocking start but we’re back in it. Good response but we need to find a winner as we have Villa where we want them so long as we show up in the second half and don’t take as long to get going.

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@dale.odonnell, we cannot lose momentum as soon as the second half starts. Got to play with this intensity again.

D

dancoombs14d ago

Well I certainly would have taken that after 4 minutes…

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@dancoombs, I did not see them coming back the way that they did.

Open full discussion →

Y. Tielemans scores for Manchester United 2-2 44'

D

dale.odonnell14d ago

Villa fans gone quiet after giving him stick. Hope it stays that way and we win. C’mon United

D

dancoombs14d ago

That’s more like it!

Open full discussion →

Great spirit from the team this!

E

epi2media14d ago

That's our team right there...Relentless, not playing on the backfoot!! 🤞🤞

S

stephenjholmes114d ago

A proper showing, besides Dalot. He is a f**king liability. Didn't defend for the 1st goal, and now the penalty. Even if Amass is playing for the U21s he should be dragged back, and be on for Dalot

S

stephenjholmes114d ago

It is refreshing to see that they are actually showing determination, passion, & desire. It might not all be finished for us after all 🤞🤞🤞

E

epi2media14d ago

That's the spirit that needs to be shown from first whistle to last minutes as a Man Utd player...!👏🏼👏🏼

D

dancoombs14d ago

Just need it from the first minute of the second half!

Open full discussion →

Bruno Fernandes scores a penalty for Manchester United 1-2 16'

Scored from the penalty spot

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

Why do we make things so much more difficult for ourselves?

D

dale.odonnell14d ago

United never do things the easy way 🥲

D

dale.odonnell14d ago

Terrific play from Cunha to win the penalty, but brilliantly executed by Fernandes. 👏🏼

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@dale.odonnell, both deserve the credit. For what it's worth after such a miserable start.

D

dancoombs14d ago

Is it happening again?!

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@dancoombs

Open full discussion →

Nicolas Jackson scores for Aston Villa 0-2 4'

D

dale.odonnell14d ago

Nightmare for Lammens.

C

chillout14d ago

I think he can be faulted for both goals.

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@dale.odonnell, honestly, the last thing we needed was for him to underperform in this match.

D

dancoombs14d ago

Very poor there. Another player whose confidence has been dragged down

S

seanfisher14d ago

It’s hard to even know where to start criticising

C

chillout14d ago

Barcelona smashed these 3-0 on Tuesday - United two down after 3 minutes!

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@seanfisher, it really is. It can start with Dalot and Lammens, though.

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

Joy for us all. Utterly embarassing.

Open full discussion →

This is embarrassing

S

stephenjholmes114d ago

Thank the lord we still have Bruno

D

dantowen8195114d ago

I can’t blame Lammens. This is just what happens to every young player who comes here with some promise The trauma has bitten him too now

S

stephenjholmes114d ago

He has had no protection from the defence. He must dread playing at the moment.

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

Back to business, isn't it? Roma just being a complete blip performance by the looks of it.

Open full discussion →

Alysson Edward scores for Aston Villa 0-1 1'

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

I. Am. So. Tired. Of. This.

V

vatsal14d ago

Absent midfield Maguire running towards his own goal This is every game since 2024

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@vatsal, I am so over it now.

D

dancoombs14d ago

Dalot and Lammens have got to do much better there. Pathetic

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@dancoombs, a complete Lammens horror show so far. And Dalot, well, we know what to expect from him by now.

Open full discussion →

Back to business, boys? 😭😫

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

FFS! How?

E

epi2media14d ago

Just play the youngsters till the end of the season and prepare for the Championship.

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@epi2media, what a deeply sad prospect.

E

epi2media14d ago

Other teams in EPL do train. This Utd side is a Sunday League team.

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@epi2media, truly shambolic. Can't believe it.

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

Should we really be surprised by this lot? Ugh.

Open full discussion →

We're underway at Old Trafford

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

Cancel the match, please.

Open full discussion →

Senne Lammens during warm ups

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

Going to be a BIG match for him today, especially with how our defence has been this season.

Open full discussion →

Alejandro Garnacho fails to make the Aston Villa squad 👀

E

epi2media14d ago

This young lad damaged himself by subscribing to the toxic attitude of the Utd squad - outside OT, they easily get found out. Only commitment, professionalism and hard work lead to success in football!

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

Don't care how much criticism Ineos receives, but selling him for £40m was one of the best bits of transfer business that Man Utd have done since Sir Alex Ferguson left.

S

stephenjholmes114d ago

The worst thing about it though, Garnacho looks like HE made the right decision now. Who on earth would feel proud to call themselves a United player in this situation?

D

dancoombs14d ago

Dropped or a conveniently timed injury/illness I wonder

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@dancoombs, him not being in the squad is more of a benefit for Aston Villa than an advantage for Man Utd!

Open full discussion →

Confirmed Man Utd XI vs Aston Villa! Thoughts on Carrick's selection? 🤔

T

thetruthpersonified14d ago

I actively hate Wilcox face!! It is like a Picasso cubism without any redeeming features...

S

stephenjholmes114d ago

How can he not be sacked. We are a club in dire straits, and he is the architect of our downfall.

D

dancoombs14d ago

I have one positive - which I hope is a positive at least: Yoro getting a chance at CB

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@dancoombs, long overdue. He has stood out compared with so many others this season.

S

stephenjholmes114d ago

Not being funny but he will probably be played at centre forward under these clowns

S

stephenjholmes114d ago

I give up. A few weeks ago I actually put £20 on us to be relegated, as I have zero confidence in this current circus. My £680 is getting to seem more safe by the week!

A

adnan.riaz14d ago

@stephenjholmes1, no matter how bad Carrick is, they would sack managers left and right to make sure Man Utd aren't relegated. Don't think you'll see that £20 ever again.

V

vatsal14d ago

@stephenjholmes1 Congrats on getting richer mate. Ornstein just said we have no plan for beyond Carrick anyway.

Open full discussion →

How does this drama end - what’s best for the club ? Another manager, another bounce and then back to square one again ? Or sticking with Carrick and trying to fix the club ? Is that even possible (fixing the club). Is the only real answer completely new owners and tearing everything up and starting again ? I’m struggling to see a pathway here.

S

stephenjholmes114d ago

Hate to spoil the mood, but we will never amount to anything with the current boardroom and coaching staff. We are trying to drive a Ferrari whilst fuelling it with diesel. The Glazers don't care as, all it is to them is a sweet jar that they keep dipping into. Sir Jim is about as good at running a football team as Jimmy Saville is at babysitting!

J

jjflash42214d ago

You know,they mite just get that jolt cos we're not too gd to go down.If we go,their cash cow will decrease massively as will their guesstimate of the club being worth £5 billion+.Deffo not in the championship.

A

apgcfrg14d ago

Where is Amass?!?

D

davecarey2814d ago

I agree unless somebody has a crystal ball this is not good on lots of levels. No good manager in his right mind will touch us and we will end up with another joker. The system is bust fix the system and quick!

Open full discussion →

Shea Lacey to get his first Premier League start? What do you make of our predicted Manchester United XI? 👀

S

stephenjholmes114d ago

I said previously, we will get zero points before we play Coventry on 10th December. After that nothing until Palace at end of December. Then nothing until March. Championship awaits

G

geldroper14d ago

Like to know where the light is hiding. Another blunder of Carrick. Really hope he gets fired today

M

mufcgrw197714d ago

I think he has to, was unsure before as think for his development giving him more minutes each time to build up is better but this is now a must win and amad has been decent in the press but woeful in front of goal and generally off it since he came back from the injury, Lacey’s cameo in Tuesday was impressive

Open full discussion →

That's it from the first half of Michael Carrick's press conference

O

ogohadolefrancis14d ago

Management should try and realeased money so the coach can sign more players. If you are not delivered you will be on the bench because Many players are hungry to show their talent

O

ogohadolefrancis14d ago

Coach is not the problem his trying is best. The problem is the players and the management

A

adnan.riaz16d ago

Let's hope there are three points waiting now from the Aston Villa match. Come on, boys, let's not waste the momentum from the Roma match now.

Open full discussion →

Latest on Patrick Dorgu's recovery

A

adnan.riaz16d ago

That means he isn't going to start, right?

D

dale.odonnell16d ago

A

adnan.riaz16d ago

@dale.odonnell, Michael Carrick's injury updates are so painful to hear now. It's like De Ligt all over again.

Open full discussion →

Carlos Baleba update

D

dancoombs16d ago

It's a big loss long term. Can't see him back until mid-December

A

adnan.riaz16d ago

Man, this is so annoying. He was looking good since his return from injury.

D

dale.odonnell16d ago

Such a blow. Can Tielemans step up alongside Mainoo or is that role better suited to Santos? 🤔

A

adnan.riaz16d ago

@dale.odonnell, I think he should start Santos for the first half and then bring Youri for the second half against Aston Villa.

Open full discussion →

Michael Carrick on Ole Gunnar Solskjaer

A

adnan.riaz16d ago

Ole was a real one.

Open full discussion →

Michael Carrick warns success takes time

A

adnan.riaz16d ago

Pretty much like every other former Man Utd manager before him. When will Ineos wake up and see the reality?

D

dale.odonnell16d ago

United need to start winning matches consistently before there’s talk of success. Of course it takes time.

A

adnan.riaz16d ago

@dale.odonnell, I would like this comment twice if I could.

Open full discussion →