TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Manchester United vs Aston Villa LIVE - Premier League November 8

How does this drama end - what’s best for the club ? Another manager, another bounce and then back to square one again ? Or sticking with Carrick and trying to fix the club ? Is that even possible (fixing the club). Is the only real answer completely new owners and tearing everything up and starting again ? I’m struggling to see a pathway here.

stephenjholmes11w ago

Hate to spoil the mood, but we will never amount to anything with the current boardroom and coaching staff. We are trying to drive a Ferrari whilst fuelling it with diesel. The Glazers don't care as, all it is to them is a sweet jar that they keep dipping into. Sir Jim is about as good at running a football team as Jimmy Saville is at babysitting!

jjflash4221w ago

You know,they mite just get that jolt cos we're not too gd to go down.If we go,their cash cow will decrease massively as will their guesstimate of the club being worth £5 billion+.Deffo not in the championship.

apgcfrg2w ago

Where is Amass?!?

davecarey282w ago

I agree unless somebody has a crystal ball this is not good on lots of levels. No good manager in his right mind will touch us and we will end up with another joker. The system is bust fix the system and quick!

antonymmartin842w ago

The strange thing is I honestly don’t know how they go about fixing the mess they’re in. The only solution in my opinion would be to appoint Pep or Don Carlo, but they have no chance of getting either. A long and hard road awaits. Patience will be key. They cannot keep appointing managers and moving on after a year.

caleb.sage2w ago

Summed it up perfectly. United will sack Carrick and then we’ll just see the same cycle again. It’s actually so predictable now.

thetruthpersonified2w ago

I view MC now as a lame duck. Essentially even if we play well and win today, we are all waiting for the rot to return. It was allowed, tolerated or just happened on his watch once, it will happen again. Issues at team level feel largely Ineos driven at this point, but it continues a Glazer trend of poor Exec choices and decisions. Rot spreads...

chillout2w ago

So what’s the answer ? Or isn’t there one ?

epi2media2w ago

Just stop looking back at history and start playing football - today. The players' attitude is rotten. In bottom three now - very soon reality will set in. Man U current team is not even Championship quality. They need to change their attitude now.

jjflash4221w ago

I actually think these players realised in pre season,that the management were so placid with their prep,and these players don't need a second invitation to ease off.still not fit enough,constant dozy starts,no patterns,I can't see these players motivated by any of the staff.I thought Holland was the go to but we look so shambolic so they're having no effect

vatsal2w ago

@epi2media THIS If they think being "Man Utd" gives them some god-given right to be successful then they're due a brutal reality check.

leeclarke05082w ago

It ends with Carrick getting the sack before a new manager gets a long term contract. Rinse and repeat

kyle.dimond2w ago

I can’t see this cycle ending until you tear it all down and start again. It feels like the goal would be to lower some expectations and give someone time to turn it around but the results have been so poor for several years now that you simply can’t do that anymore. And thus, cycle repeats.

john.haigh2w ago

It's extremely difficult. MU disintegrated after Fergie left, never recovered. I'm inclined toward bad almost dictatorial stewardship. Klopp Ancelotti, Guardiola or Mourinho for that matter would be stifled. New football orientated ownership would be a start. Give a Manager control, chuck the deadwood & disruptive mob out. Any repair would still be slow.

chillout2w ago

This is the only real pathway.

jonathan.gorrie2w ago

@john.haigh Isn't there a story that Ed Woodward showed Klopp around Old Trafford and called it 'Disneyland', which really put Klopp off? Certainly underlines what you're saying!

chillout2w ago

I can’t help but think that will only be a temporary bandaid on the pitch. Results will start to slip, Conte won’t get supported and he will make a lot of noise and walk. Nothing will change.

aaditya.krishnamurthy2w ago

Conte had a huge issue with Tottenham players and their overall hierarchy - if he comes to present day United, he might have a full on meltdown that puts his Spurs presser to shame!

aaditya.krishnamurthy2w ago

The fact of the matter is that there is a disconnect with where the fans want the club to be and what the owners are willing to do. Problem is that the owners expect miracles without investment - if you’re not willing to invest, be willing to handle mediocrity and the criticism that comes with it

chillout2w ago

Well that is the rub of it, of course. The owners are very thicker skinned and none of what is going on seems to impact them. Probably because they have little emotional connection with the club.

charlesjones2w ago

This is football. The drama never ends. You’re only ever a month away from crisis at any club.

chillout2w ago

I kind of agree - but I can’t help look at what Arsenal and Villa did with their current managers - gave them time and backed them when the chips were down. Patience has been rewarded at both those clubs.

aryansurajc2w ago

Well for the development they need a complete overhaul, starting with Carrick, and then change in the ownership structure can also help. But yeah they have been struggling for years now, it’s big time for big changes.

jonathan.gorrie2w ago

I genuinely don't think it does end. The blueprint is Arsenal and Man Utd are a much bigger club than that PLUS Arteta would have probably been sacked had there been fans in attendance during his rough patch. United are too ungainly a beast to go through that without the noise being too much for anyone

chillout2w ago

I think maybe only relegation and bring out of Europe may prompt the Glazers to review their options.

jonathan.gorrie2w ago

@jonathan.gorrie Obvioulsy the Glazers going would help but does anyone seriously think that'll happen any time soon?

shamanth.jayaram2w ago

That is the only real answer but it’s never going to happen. Carrick needs to go, even though it’s not his fault. It just isn’t working, and the longer this drags on, the worse it’ll be. Bring Conte in. High risk because he’s crazy but the potential rewards are massive as well

seanfisher2w ago

I think it’s become clear that Carrick is not the answer long-term. But getting the timing right and finding the RIGHT replacement is now all that matters. If it’s handled right and Carrick sets the right tone to hand over to an elite tactician then I have a small slice of hope that it can be fixed

seanfisher2w ago

However it must be said that Carrick can NOT be the only change. Wilcox has to go, and fans need more transparency from whoever comes into replace him

matthew.johns2w ago

I think the only permanent solution is to start again from the top down, but realistically Carrick will go and they will likely have a bounce, and rinse and repeat.

chillout2w ago

If you look at clubs like AC Milan, Juventus and even at late Wenger Arsenal, the clubs that came back from United-like troubles all stopped chasing quick fix signings, kicked out toxic and unmotivated players and completely rebuilt their corporate and sporting structures from scratch.

peter.lynch2w ago

It certainly looks very bleak, but I think they can dig their way out of this. An experienced, no-nonsense manager is the way forward, but I could see an interim coming in now to try and steady the ship. But looks like former players coming into the dugout isn’t the way forward, otherwise the cycle is only going to repeat!

dancoombs2w ago

Obviously the answer is new owners- but 21 years in, this isn’t achievable overnight, or even short term. Just chopping and changing the manager isn’t necessarily a pathway either. We won the last game, let’s see if we get a result and performance today