Celtic vs Dundee United LIVE
Join the live fan discussion around Celtic vs Dundee United. Follow all the latest scores, commentary and updates.
294 comments
Should Martin O'Neill take some of the blame for the loss to Dundee United?
atozreilly19497226d ago
Like any manager Martin will need to shoulder most of the blame for Weird line up and the mosh mash of tactics and subs
atozreilly19497227d ago
Starting Eleven was like a crossword puzzle: and you easily have flipped a coin swapping 4 staters for 4 on bench/ martins selections were baffling, he ll know he ballsed up Bigtime
rvybw9z4yf226d ago
It’s terrible how MO’N went from hero to zero , after his comments about the anti Celtic Celtic Collective. MO’Ns love for Celtic esp fans & respect for Board members , were the reason that at his age , he gave up retirement to help & ignorant fans who couldn’t manage local pub dart’s team turn against him
jimbo.1955227d ago
We all make mistakes and martin is no different but yes several mistakes were made he needs help the squad he had on his day where on a different level
Your INSTANT REACTION to that loss 😡
Is the title race over?
doranmick87227d ago
Ballocks
terrymccall30228d ago
as far as chris boyd goes only he cares what he thinks!
luckytroll82228d ago
I hope whoever takes over scraps the entire squad and starts over absolutely pathetic performance can't even perform for a legend like Martin O'Neill. Half the players are still from The Ange era it's about time they were gone they're far to comfortable in their regular roles now.
amirmir228d ago
The amount of players that need to be turned over in the summer is incredible. But it's needed.
Big call to start Kelechi Iheanacho vs Dundee United?
What does that say for Tomas Cvancara? Let us know in the comments!
billymc6129d ago
And the league was won🤣🤣🤣
gerry.docherty7229d ago
Doesn't matter any more, that shower of gutless cowards don't have it in them to win the league. Absolute losers the lot of them. Would not keep one player need a whole new squad.
callum_boyle229d ago
Surprised he's gone with Iheanacho, especially as Cvancara has come off the bench and scored big penalties. Back MON though
Pick your Celtic XI vs Dundee United
tonymac44229d ago
Should have played the B Team.
callum_boyle229d ago
Sinisalo, Araujo, Trusty, Scales, Tierney; Hatate, McCowan, Nygren; Yang, Cvancara, Maeda
Agree or disagree with these predictions?
Tell us yours...
tonymac44229d ago
1-2 but the way they played the first half they could get beat. Why is Nygren taking corners ? He's poor at best.
junglebhoys67229d ago
2-0 Celtic.
jonathan.gorrie230d ago
I'm with Paddy
Who starts alongside Liam Scales against Dundee United?
Take your pick Celtic fans, and explain why...
tonycarr742230d ago
Definitely Benjamin Arthur top notch centre back he has a big future 😉
ftgb1887230d ago
Not Murray 😔🙏
celticdave1974230d ago
Arthur
Kenny cannot score goals
rvybw9z4yf235d ago
What has Kenny not able to score goals to do with Kieran Tierney’s rating ?
mikeycolgan228d ago
Some players like Kenny, Ralston and Scales get slaughtered regardless of what they have or haven't done. For instance, why is Kenny picked out for criticism when he has actually scored more goals than Iheanacho and Cancvara and with fewer minutes on the pitch? I don't understand it.
Should Julian Araujo been shown a red card for this tackle? Let us know in the comments.
rvybw9z4yf231d ago
It is absolutely ridiculous that we are discussing the possibility of a red card for Araujo . Week after week huns &their country cousins should have red cards every wk . With Celtic fans talking about a possible Celt red, no doubt we will soon get reds
How good has Yang been this past month?
doranmick87227d ago
Mon
mikeycolgan235d ago
Getting shot of Rodgers has been the making of him. Makes you wonder how many others were held back in their development by Rodgers' stubbornness - Nawrocki for example.
mehalcorcoran235d ago
Totally agreed there id bring back the big polish lad when he did play he was one of the better players at centre back
kruzybhoy277d ago
Been our best player consistently since November
How much responsibility should the players take for Nancy's tenure, given how quickly they seem to have turned it around with Dundee win?
allangordonsmith296d ago
Nancy should never have been Celtic manager. Tisdale should never have been sporting director. This board are deluded and shouldn't get away with making those decisions
rvybw9z4yf235d ago
Allangordonsmith . Board & fans know in hindsight that Nancy & Tisdale were not right for Celtic . Unless you know how to raise minimum of £200m , then u have to suck it up as us cannot plan to buy out DD . As long as u don’t act like the Celtic Collective and do all u can to cause Celtic to lose by behaving as if your head needs examining.
dw19163867298d ago
Nancy didnt even pick MONS brain about celtic the day he started and he paid the ultimate price for it so good riddence 2 him and he will be laughing all the way 2 the bank with his pay off 33 days for £££ how much i wonder??? And the GB should be 1st thru turnstyle coz there is no atmosphere at all without them HH
rvybw9z4yf235d ago
Of course he wouldn’t pick MO’N’s mind, Nancy’s football philosophy would be exact opposite to MO’N . Nancy all about entertainment & results to follow , MO’N all about results, if u want entertainment, Martin would advise u to go to cinema . It didn’t work out for Nancy & he needs to work out why ,if he wants to manage in Europe . Listening to MO’N won’t h
gtt1967298d ago
Shame nancy away as he was good for rangers and wish they had kept him
Who is Celtic's Man of the Match vs Dundee United?
moonboy662298d ago
Tounekti for me but the real stand-up for me was Maeda's lack of emotion after every goal. Time to go.
rvybw9z4yf235d ago
Why , if a player runs around kissing badge u are happy with him
juliesshearer298d ago
Yes, I agree. His expressions were very deadpan. He didn't show any emotion at all..even at the end when they were clapping for the supporters. Was he always like that?
fenian.pinguin299d ago
Scales
callum_boyle299d ago
Yang gets the MOTM again. He's been brilliant these past couple of weeks
The team I would start against Dundee United is...
stephenjohnston83300d ago
Have to start sinasalo. Kasper is finished. He puts players under pressure with his poor passing then blames everyone else
jimbo.1955301d ago
Only one change Schmeichel not fit to slow at getting down to his right as seen last week end terrible
marksamson34.ms301d ago
As good as he can put out, Martin will play an open attack with crosses coming in , and Kenny gets a chance to grow and develope , dizien and nygren will support with goals.
Send in your score predictions for the return of Martin O'Neill against Dundee United. We'll say 2-0 to Celtic
louisenelsonbarrie5300d ago
3/0
charleneandjoanne300d ago
I’ll say 3 or 4-0. 2 goals each half
hunt878300d ago
4-0 celtic HH
I'd havr Martin O Neill til' end of season then go for the Motherwell manager. His philosophy is press high and attack. The players he has just now at Motherwell play with energy and it's what Celtic need, a bit like big Anges way of playing
scorc3529303d ago
I’ve been very impressed with him as well. In the short period he’s been there he’s transformed them. I’ve said it since the 3-2 home game, and it still applies as I missed Roma,Motherwell are the best team I’ve seen at parkhead this season
Tell us your starting XI for Martin O'Neill's first game back
tonyrotch1888300d ago
Sinisalo
gerdon301d ago
Why does most folk want Scales to stay. I remember the saying " its like a hoat tattie" and that's what thg Scales is like when opposing teams do a high press. Any port in a storm is Scales s motto. He needs to go with Kenny, Ralston and Schmeichel
rvybw9z4yf235d ago
Gordon , I presume u admit u know nothing at all about football, or u wouldn’t make such a stupid mistake
carmoucheian301d ago
Sinisalo
jrconcertina37d ago
If Kasper is going to play a half then put the wide men with him who are going to aim their crosses at him,don't take him off and then put on those players Have Hassan jota and Kasper together Put Duran Osmond and Hassan together. Kasper will score goals but he has to get the ball played to him in the air not on the ground...
b9w8n948hc8d ago
I thought Hogh was signed as a target man to run on to balls from the wing so last night he gets taken off at HT and two wingers are put on I’m a bit confused
johnprior9998d ago
Vickers is on the naughty step…. He’s been the best player in the country since he arrived. If he’s “fit” he should be starting…….simple…..🙄🍀
louiselang678d ago
We were held to a draw because we lost 2 goals that should've been defended better.Also,we lacked in midfield.For me Nygren has been AWOL in last few games.Why isn't the Ox getting game time?10 minutes at the end while Nygren adds nothing for 80.Our midfield is sadly lacking too and the Board knew that.
eddiewhitelaw8d ago
12 crosses in the first half to supply our penalty box striker and he got on one to set up the goal, take him off put Jota and Hassan on and we have 28 crosses in the second half. Sorry to say the management is clueless about modern football
cameronmacvicar28d ago
It's not good enough. Defence is so poor, no midfield. Why was Carter Vickers not playing, and how why not sub Nygren earlier? Major problems going forward
jjc2738d ago
Why do people like you always jump to criticise the defence. What about the hatful of scoring opportunities missed by our forwards Games are won by us scoring more goals than the other team you know !
martin.crawford8d ago
@cameronmacvicar2 Surely it's not still because of the comments after the derby lol
amirmir8d ago
Hassan was very good. Scales was poor from a defensive aspect, as was the whole team! Defence still an issue.
scapaldi19688d ago
Hassan should have started the game with Duran as our main striker. Hogh should have been on the bench
martin.crawford8d ago
@scapaldi1968 Yep, that's pretty clear after how the second half went. Fairs to Hogh for setting up the goal though.