Talk Celtic Transfers
Join the Celtic fan discussion on TalkingPoints around all the latest transfer news, opinions, polls and updates.
2,754 comments
🤔 Ten signings, £30m spent, £45m brought in... what rating are you giving Celtic's window?
👀 We'll come back to this at the end of the season...

djdocherty5773d ago
Done well but room for improvement
johntaggart120174d ago
Once again the board have played a blinder, as celtic fans lets welcome all the new signings the celtic way hail hail
columbasvs77d ago
It’s too early to judge this fairly but so far it looks like a solid 8.
Do you like the sound of what you are hearing from Celtic's new signing? 🍀😃

damiansmyth5080d ago
How do you know M O’N is furious . He can say one thing to a crowd of journalists whom he has no time for & actually think differently. How do u know MN f.cked up deal . Little or no facts about this incomplete transfer have been released by Celtic
brendyadams79d ago
Also celtic never paid a penny for any incomings,they were brought in off the back of players wee sold and they r still 10-15 million better off
brendyadams79d ago
No1 said it was martin oniell,nicholson is in charge of the transfers so he fucked up,the deal with the club was sorted,the deal with the player wasnt,he clearly wanted to come to celtic though they couldnt sort out a contract with the player,usual penny pinching,they clearly didnt wana spend so low ball for the transfer to collapse
brendyadams80d ago
Martin oniell is raging the geneitis deal.didnt do threw,everything was more less adreed and for some reason nicholson seemed to hav fucked it up 🤦♂️
geobrown4579d ago
Its not for some reason, its because the Board didn’t prepare properly for Euro Qualifier, just like last season, we lose out on £40 Million, they wouldn’t spend £10M on the Midfielder we NEED!
amirmir80d ago
The Arne Engels replacement! Be patient with him, and hopefully, he produces!
What would be your message to Reo Hatate after his stellar Celtic career comes to an end? 🍀🏆

johntaggart120155d ago
Reo Good lu k in your new,career move and ghank you for your servicw to celtic,but it was time too go as the last season and a half your head was not in it and that showed in your performances on the pitch
scottmctaggart6777d ago
Thought he was better than he was
alexmcalroy194677d ago
Won't be missed,non-trier under pressure
Johnny Kenny's association with Celtic has come to an end, as he is set to join Preston. Your thoughts? 🍀🤔

jmccolgan52579d ago
Go with my bedt Wishes Johnny
johnprior99981d ago
Good luck Johnny…… go and play…..🍀
amirmir82d ago
No surprise. Too many players ahead of him, and £3m is pretty good for someone so far down the pecking order!
✅ Celtic appear to finally have their new goalkeeper!
🧤 A deal has reportedly been agreed for Sam Johnstone to join on a season-long loan from Wolves...

fenian.pinguin81d ago
Think his top should read diet.hh
amirmir82d ago
Back-up option improved, no more. He isn't better than Sinisalo, who should remain number one!
damiansmyth5080d ago
Sinisalo will remain ist choice until manager & coaches become concerned he is making too many mistakes . This could take quite a while
duncanbannatyne5082d ago
Guess who ate all the pie's
Midfielder incoming!! 🚨 How do we feel about Oliver Sorensen signing for Celtic? 🤔🍀
Tell us below...👇🍀
faith1nico82d ago
Time will tell if he's tross you can ship him right back to Italy but the way thins are just now he will be a superstar in that team
brendyadams83d ago
Loan deals r useful only with an option to buy,why should wee take on loan players to increase ther value to were its out of r reach to buy that dont make sense,if ur interested in a player put that claus in
antz403683d ago
This season squad mainly a temperry one , new head coach , and football department for next season onwards, Martin o Neill will be last ever Celtic Manager
mikeycolgan83d ago
Last ever!!! I hope not😂
Kieran Tierney needs some competition. Is Will Ferry the answer for Celtic?
Tell us what you think...🤔👇🍀

alexmcalroy194677d ago
Great player, Lionhearted
roughrider00778d ago
get him signed up hes a quality player
faith1nico82d ago
Sign him all day long the guy never stops running and I think hes a better defender than Tierney that will be another player that got away
Name the Celtic players who must leave the club after the LASK horror show? 🤔🍀🤯
Tell us below...👇

johnmerrilees44586d ago
Mon team and sub selection was shocking we had decent attacking players on the bench but chose teens or has-beens the boat was rocky already but he chose to sit back rather than give it everything
iancruickshank2086d ago
Tonecti , mc Cowan kept giving the ball away which led to a goal and hopefully jotta comes back sometime soon as tonecti couldn't lace his boots .the midfield now is bare and if hatati leaves were screwed
stevecargill6486d ago
McGowan, silasolo,rouston. Need a total rebuild of the defence.There is no pace
How would you feel about Jack Grealish signing for Celtic? 🤯🤔🍀

barrylmccarthy84d ago
It will never happen
mrcrobo6087d ago
Mercenary turn coat crapped all over Ireland and then Villa he would make us feel he was doing us a favour and it would make me vomit to see him running around badge kissing at Celtic Park let him go where loyalty means nothing where he belongs .
kruzybhoy88d ago
Why can’t you post my comments ? A bit to close to the bone for you
🔥 GET READY TO WELCOME OUR NEW BOSNIAN BHOY!
🇧🇦 A broad agreement has been reached for Celtic to sign 21-year-old World Cup star Ermin Mahmic!

barrylmccarthy84d ago
Would have liked to have seen him at Celtic but going out the champions league seems to have changed his mind on coming to us
knnymatthews88d ago
Wasn't boards fault that some players were spineless last night. Both mccowan n tounetki must have been worst performances I have seen in a long long time.
kruzybhoy89d ago
Well don’t think any of these guys will be getting signed now , well done the Celtic board I hope your all really proud of yourselves yet again GTF the lot of you’s
How do you feel about Celtic's links with Yukinari Sugawara?
Sugawara plays at right-back!

dantowen8195192d ago
I like Sugawara but I don’t see why Celtic need him? Not after Donovan’s performance the other night
amirmir94d ago
Not needed unless Johnston leaves, which seems unlikely now!
bermingham196895d ago
While AJ is out injured and we don't know for how long then I think Sugawara would be a definite upgrade on Ralston and Donovan.
👀 Martin O'Neill is open to keeping Reo Hatate at Celtic as he holds out for a move to a top-five league in Europe.
🤔 Where will he be at the end of the transfer window?

fenian.pinguin87d ago
Why the Dublin hoops
mrcrobo6087d ago
A top 5 league ! dream on only if the league of Ireland becomes top 5 , lend him to Shamrock Rovers and teach him a lesson it's the standard he is playing at now .
lynnfin12394d ago
As long as he remembers who's paying his wages while he's still here!
Would Lukas Fadinger be a smart signing for Celtic, or should the club be aiming higher after selling Arne Engels? 🤔
Who would you want Celtic to sign? 📝

martin.crawford96d ago
I like him as a player. We could definitely do worse. Probably not the A-list signing we need though
Celtic banked £22m for Arne Engels, but was selling him days before the LASK tie a smart bit of business or an unnecessary gamble?
What would you have done differently?

awilson188897d ago
Played well against Dundee United, no wait
kruzybhoy98d ago
You would have thought our world class board would have learned there lessons from last seasons CL qualifier , done the exact same thing by selling Kuhn
carlmcandrew98d ago
We all knew he was going, why was there no replacement brought in. Too late now.
dantowen8195198d ago
I thought it was a bit odd they’d sell when they have a deadline for registering the European squad!
🇧🇦 Celtic are linked with Bosnia's World Cup breakout star!
👀 The club have held talks with Slovan Liberec over 21-year-old Ermin Mahmic...

dantowen8195198d ago
Usually, if Como want someone, that’s a pretty good marker of their potential!
martin.crawford99d ago
I would be absolutely buzzing with this - but given his similarities to Nygren, could indicate something going on there
👀 Blackburn boss Tony Mowbray has left the door wide open for reported Celtic target Balazs Toth...
🧤 Could we be looking at Celtic's new goalkeeper?

eoin99d ago
Thats a great response from the blackburn manager, would be a great signing
chillout99d ago
Mobray is too long in the tooth not to accept reality.
👀 Gvidas Gineitis, Niko Sigur... will Celtic end up with one, neither or both?

djdocherty5789d ago
We definately need both in if they are ready to perform as we need them to play.
raymondduffy89d ago
If Sigur is a defensive midfielder…get him! We’re desperate for some muscle in there.
mcdowallandrew90d ago
Looks like celtic are about to make a 110% challenge on the S.P.L & EUROPE 🏴🇮🇪
🚨 Another deal seemingly close for Celtic!
👀 The loan of Chelsea left-back Landon Emenalo is reportedly nearing completion...

brendyadams93d ago
No option to buy is abit stupid,the club needs to move forward and identify what they need,does brilliant for celtic then the price goes threw the roof out of the price tag of.celtic
brycecarroll6793d ago
Maybe Chelsea dont want him to sign for anybody else
jamesshearman23101d ago
Emenalo was excellent for Chelsea at the start of preseason and I’m actually surprised Alonso hasn’t kept him around. Should be a very good signing for Celtic 👏
martin.crawford101d ago
Great to hear!
Haissem Hassan is Celtic’s third signing of the summer 🙌 Give us your reaction Hoops fans 💚
martin.crawford101d ago
The more I read about him the more buzzing I get
barrycrawford87101d ago
👏👏🍀🔥
ftgb1887102d ago
Oh god the board are planning something aren't they
callum_boyle101d ago
The pessimist in me was thinking this 😂 season has started well, we’re signing our key targets. Just waiting for a season ending injury to someone or them saying to LASK that they can just have our CL place lol
Is Mika Baur the perfect replacement for Engels?
martin.crawford101d ago
Baur more of a Hatate replacement I think. Gineitis more similar to Engels
jas1160102d ago
If Engels is going for 25m + 5m add ons, then I expect and hope we insert a sell on clause. Thanks for the memories Arne, good luck
paddy102d ago
Would be gutted if Engels left. Would love to see Geinitis come in.
🧤 Would Nick Pope be the right goalkeeper signing for Celtic?
amirmir102d ago
Never in a million years. The Glasgow pressure will eat him alive
jackgallagher102d ago

dantowen81951102d ago
No, don’t like this. Celtic have literally just moved on an old, declining goalkeeper who is poor with his feet
Who should Celtic sign after the Hassan deal is done?
harriskandil17102d ago
GK left back and a midfielder either to be a starter if Engles leaves or a backup if he stays
johnprior999102d ago
We currently have one left back (KT)…..Doh 🍀
johnburns912103d ago
Midfilder goalkeeper leftnacl sorted
€20m for Fares Ghedjemis? Are Celtic right to walk away, or should they pay big for a player they clearly want?
paul6103d ago
He’s not a £20M asset. Celtic are absolutely right to walk away. His price went from €6M to £10M in the blink of an eye. His agent has been hard at work but he’s overstepped the mark on this one.
iancruickshank20103d ago
Celtic could buy a couple of players for that amount , but if they had sold meada for the price of £25 million that Nottingham forest had offered at 1 point they could have had the extra cash to have a go for him .
dantowen81951103d ago
I’d walk I think. Celtics problem here is there’s gonna be a bidding war, and Monaco have £50m to play with after selling Akliouche to psg
😲 Celtic have been linked with a stunning move for Hearts star Claudio Braga!
ftgb1887102d ago
Just give him a big fat bag of cash he'll suddenly be a Celtic mega fan even though he's supposed to hate us
ecosdoors105d ago
This Should have been done in the prior January Window What a Quality Player and scoring for fun . Good luck in this one . HH9 TWICE Y N W A
callum_boyle106d ago
Am no convinced on him. He comes in on the left but if we can get better for the money they’re asking for we should look elsewhere
A would rather no be in champions league with no signings cause we could be really embarrassed one day if we meet big teams, am dreading it with this squad a shambles.
paddyd813105d ago
A know a would rather not get beat with wee teams in champions league, way crap we play
paddyd813107d ago
Money goes to Board anyway, it's not as if they will spend 40 million.
graham2271107d ago
So you would want us to miss out on the £40 million prize money that we would receive through qualification for the group stages? It would mean there would be no excuse to strengthen the squad even more in January and keep our foot on Sevco's throat.
🚨 CELTIC ARE FINALLY CLOSING IN ON HAISSEM HASSAN!
stephenmcgrath15104d ago
Why are they taking so long ffs
ecosdoors105d ago
This Will Hapen ASAP And will be a Magnificent acquisition.With a Lefty Gingking Box to Box down both lines when it’s required.Also in the Inverted position will score goals KTF OH and a Speedy healthy recovery to the BOSS One MO’N Y N W A
graham2271107d ago
It's all finally coming together.
😳 Celtic's hopes of a Julian Araujo return this summer are seemingly dead in the water...
martin.crawford108d ago
I'm not sure if this was ever happening, to be honest - but if it means we keep Johnston, great
Next year will 60 years since celtic won European Cup Dermot Desmond and board need to ask themselves what are we about No ambition only banking money and beating rangers There's no way engels and johnstone should leave If I was Martin o neill I would walk away from a cowardly chairman and board
malcolmmckinlay2379d ago
Do not forget CELTIC where the first team to win the EC,over night they became british
💥 Celtic can't afford to risk entering their Champions League play-off under-equipped, but face the imminent sales of Engels and Johnston.
ecosdoors105d ago
CORRECT JAMES
liamwinning88106d ago
If you don't want to play for celtic then go take the f--k tablet..just remember the grass isn't always greener..kyogo will testify to that..🇮🇪
graham2271107d ago
Wouldn't miss Engels as he's been a serial underachiever since he signed for us. After the empty shirt performance he put in against Dundee, if we can make ANY sort of a profit on him then the sooner he's gone the BETTER.
graham2271107d ago
As for Alistair Johnston, he's under contract for another three years, so he should be told he's going nowhere until at least the end of the season and to knuckle down until then. There should be no hiding place for Nicholson and the charlatans on the board if they let him go in this or the NEXT transfer window AND on the cheap.
Araujo and Sarrachi should have been offered contracts, can see why they didnt opt for Iheanacho, when we have 2 decent strikers and Osmand as another option, weak in defence tho
martin.crawford112d ago
Wages are a major stumbling block for Araujo, on £65-70k at Bournemouth
rod188850110d ago
He isn't good enough in the first place. He's not what we need IMO.
jas1160111d ago
That can be offset with a signing on fee

johnstudio1764d ago
Would like Maeda back on loan in January, he's already been warming the bench at Ipswich of late, if it doesn't work out for him their, then, so if there's a chance! big miss for the hoops.
djdocherty5773d ago
He's difinately a much needed addition to the team I'm sure there is more to come from him.
rebel1314.2874d ago
Fk sake if that wnks saying it he's just jinxed it. The guys a bias k Boyd clone. Now Duran has shown some great play so far but lets not get carried away. Better than Maeda? Or the wee man in his prime. I hope so but they 2 were special, lets just see how it goes and not put too much pressure on him, anyway Baur is looking a great player as well.
amirmir74d ago
He will be near the top in a few years!
stevenpetrie4274d ago
Duran is a class signing