TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk Celtic Transfers

🤔 Ten signings, £30m spent, £45m brought in... what rating are you giving Celtic's window?

👀 We'll come back to this at the end of the season...

djdocherty572mo ago

Done well but room for improvement

johntaggart12012mo ago

Once again the board have played a blinder, as celtic fans lets welcome all the new signings the celtic way hail hail

columbasvs2mo ago

It’s too early to judge this fairly but so far it looks like a solid 8.

billycj15042mo ago

EARLY DAYS players take time to gel it will be fine. Still 5 pts clear and it will increase. Huns look disconbobulated. We will beat them. HH

damiansmyth502mo ago

10 out of 10 . Only problem will MO’N & coaches be able to get the best out of all our new players & tell them into team

iank28162mo ago

brought in 10 players think it has been excellent.

howatpatrick2mo ago

Forget the £15m between the buying and selling profits we lost £40m because those tight idiots who control the money don't have the faith and the foresight in the Team they are supposed to support

hayleywilliamsfan12mo ago

Could've been better, brought in sooner & I would've liked another CB cause trusty is a liability, scales is mediocre and CCV is our only decent one but for the most part the signings seem quality, especially Duran, Hassan & Hogh

whitty.aiden222mo ago

As usual signing brought in too late ,45mill brought in and still the signings were made too late for a competition we crave as fans.

roughrider0072mo ago

good but could have done more with signings

thomaslyon712mo ago

Window has been a good 1. I think we have found a few gems. Hail HAIL. 8 out of 10

hunt8782mo ago

Five out of ten didn't strengthen the positions we wanted to,a ball winner in the middle of the park, and the back four are suspect, needed a centre half, what we have got is not good enough.

theodore1252mo ago

Good but could be better, alway's every window leave thing's until last minute

wylie_p2mo ago

Much better than the last three would have liked a couple more but I think we’ve got more quality over quantity Duran is a great find

pauldshapero2mo ago

Reactive not proactive! We need another window or two to have a decent squad.

wull42mo ago

6/10

jmccolgan5252mo ago

Does it matter what fans think now at celtic i dont think so

malcolmmckinlay232mo ago

Just keep scoring goals any which way

frankmck552mo ago

7/10

knightgeorge19602mo ago

Started very well but very slow. Reverted to type with panic, scatter gun approach to second half of window.

jamesandannedunlop2mo ago

Only time will tell

pinkneymark52mo ago

Unfortunately we will never spend the money to compete with Europes big guns. The signings are what we needed to replace the players who left . We are good enough to beat everything in Scotland but Euro league is us at best. Our fans, me included want more but sadly it will never happen. So lets enjoy this incoming domestic treble.

bkr9112mo ago

Knew all along they would be some sort of bull shit about spending 9 million on another midfielder if we qualified for c/l bet he would have been signed

clark.wotherspoon2mo ago

It's 100% better that last season but I still don't understand why there's a perfectly good left back in Will Ferry right on our doorstep and they've let it slip by.🤷

pol4gapps2mo ago

15 m profit , politburo ensure biscuit tin still intact 10 out of 10. Silent Mick is there for the long haul.hh

geobrown452mo ago

A 3 at best, fail to prepare, prepare to fail

malcolmmckinlay232mo ago

You have not taken your meds today Geo

bfasttim2mo ago

KNThe attacking players from what I've seen so far looks promising but still not enough done to strengthen the back line KT and AJ injured although Donavan has done well and another couple in who can play right back we have no support for the left back position. Again we watch the chance to sign the players the manager wants squandered by an inept board

neil.gowrie2mo ago

Shocking miss out on main midfielder and usual multiple loan signings ..forwards great but usual board failings STB

josephweatherston4852mo ago

7 with it rising if play the Celtic way

brisab27062mo ago

Not just once, twice but 3 years in a row closing the gate when horse has bolted ,losing out on champions league ,to lose 5 goals to average team at 4 nil up says transfer window embarrassment, need better defence sinsalo should have save 3 out of 5 shots ,but as long as Nicholson remains down we will go

dantowen819512mo ago

7 - the attack looks so much stronger than last season. Nearly an 8 just for Duran alone!

amirmir2mo ago

Mixed bag. Loved the attacking signings. Midfield was refreshed. Backline a let down.