TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk

Former Celtic Players

Join the fan discussion on TalkingPoints about former Celtic players and where they are now.

275 comments

What have you made of Kyogo since leaving Celtic? 🤔🍀

The Japan star won't be returning to Parkhead, as he leaves Birmingham for the MLS...✈️

P

peter.kanesr56d ago

Chucked it at celtic in his last six months when he had eyes on the big bucks, a la french Eddie ,sadly i think Maeda will end up in the same boat !

J

jimmy1888.cfc56d ago

The grass isn't always greener on the other side look at kuhn o'reilly french eddy dembele jota Tierney probably only successful 1s was the 3 or 4 we sold to Southampton and larsson

F

fenian.pinguin111d ago

Who gives a rats arse left Celtic and fell flat on his arse.

Open full discussion →

Should Gustaf Lagerbielke have been given more of a chance at Celtic?

Now playing for Sweden at the World Cup...🌎

J

jas1160122d ago

Yes, Rodgers was not the best at keeping decent players if he hadn't spotted them.

M

martin.crawford159d ago

He definitely could've played more, but I really wasn't that impressed by him at the time. Not sure we were the right move for him. Rodgers should've let him go to Lecce in the Jan

D

dantowen81951159d ago

I suspect so, yeah. It’s not like the defenders Celtic had at the time have really kicked on since Gustaf left

Open full discussion →

Emilio Izaguirre: overrated or underrated?

J

jas1160122d ago

Neither, he was a better than decent LB, the wee guy rarely let us down.

Open full discussion →

Would Celtic's style be better if Greg Taylor was still at the club?

Share your thoughts, Celtic fans...

M

martin.crawford211d ago

Absolutely, 100%. You can see Tierney getting the ball in areas where Taylor used to operate — it doesn't suit him. It's been a rough transition.

J

johnmc67214d ago

No - the midfield and forward line have significantly regressed and greg needed them to be on their game to give him space, ultimately. And Greg was not a great defender - Tierney and Saracchi are far better on that front.

T

taylorc11214d ago

Tierney POTY, no a snowballs chance in hell. He is one of the biggest disappointments this season. Taylor any day

Open full discussion →

Dembele

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Which one of these was the best striker?

T

tonymac44221d ago

Kyogo closely followed by Moussa.

J

johnstudio17222d ago

Moussa the magnificent

W

williamhartley61222d ago

Moussa

Open full discussion →

Where does Joe Hart rank in the list of Celtic goalkeepers?

R

roncophotography207d ago

He'd be up there with Ronnie Simpson and Fraser Forster.

S

stephenhardie1970217d ago

Jo Hart is up there with atur boruc

Open full discussion →

Name one Celtic player that the club should have never sold

J

johntaggart1201223d ago

No a player Martin O,Neil If we had keep Martin we would never be in this mess we would be going fo the treble

R

rvybw9z4yf218d ago

The Board couldn’t keep M O’N as they were already committed to signing Nancy & Martin only came in as an interim manager for a few weeks . U may be right Celtic Collective would not have actively demotivated team as much if MO’N was present all season

D

daniel.owen231d ago

I'd maybe say Hyeon-Gyu Oh. I can understand why he left but when you think Kyogo was sold soon after and we ended up with Idah, I think Hyeon could have had a big role to play

R

rvybw9z4yf218d ago

Sure poor BR thought he could judge footballers , he messed up our squad with loaning players that could have been very useful & selling Oh . I hope we don’t get a know- all manager like BR again

R

rvybw9z4yf224d ago

OH was sold because once again BR didn’t recognise his ability as a striker . BR demanded the drunkard idah , saying Idah was his type of striker . Hence further proof BR can’t judge footballer or person & that is why our squad is weak

C

callum_boyle233d ago

I think Jota that first time around. Was clearly never going to work elsewhere

R

rvybw9z4yf218d ago

The club had no option but to take the open fortune the oil freaks were offering , The wages Jota was promised, was so bloated that it made no sense & Celtic couldn’t possibly stand in his way . Eventually sense was established

J

jonathan.gorrie233d ago

Agreed!

Open full discussion →

Were Celtic right to let Scott Bain leave in the summer?

Bain could be heading to the World Cup with Scotland

J

jo797522250d ago

Man wanted to go he said he wanted his child see him playing he has done well money wise but he didnt show or put pressure on first team pick 】

Open full discussion →

You have £100,000-a-week you could give to one Celtic player, past or present. Who is getting it?

Let us know why you picked them below

J

jimmy1888.cfc56d ago

Lubo

R

roncophotography213d ago

Billy McNeill.In the early 60's he was earning less than £20 a week.

P

pauldshapero213d ago

Bobby Lennox aka buzzbomb. Man was a rocket!!!

Open full discussion →

Van dijk

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

How many goals would a prime Gary Hooper score in this current Celtic side?

R

roncophotography213d ago

We don't have the same quality in midfield as we had in Hooper's day,so I doubt he'd maybe get as many chances.

T

tonymac44221d ago

About 10 and he would be the top scorer. No service !

S

scorc3529268d ago

Well judging by the chances created he’d have 15 in the games against hearts Dundee Utd and r*ngers in December and January so I’d say 35 for this season.

Open full discussion →

Nobody comes close to Virgil van Dijk in the 21st century...

If you think we're wrong, tell us why 😮

T

tonymac44221d ago

Without doubt big Virgil, nobody even close.

S

scorc3529268d ago

No arguments here. Him and denayer were a cracking CB partnership.

Open full discussion →

Choose one former Celtic player that you would pick to have in the side right now 🙌

Let us know down below 🤔

J

jimmy1888.cfc56d ago

Van dijk all day long he's calm organised positionally strong and got a finish like a striker remember the free kicks aswel

T

tonymac44221d ago

Virgil to steady the defence.

R

roughrider007248d ago

big virg

Open full discussion →

Where does Gary Caldwell rank in the list of centre-backs Celtic have had since 2000?

S

scorc3529268d ago

Top 5. Could tackle, could head it, could pass it. Very underrated at the time.

Open full discussion →

Hyeon-gyu Oh continues his storming start at Besiktas... he looks a different player!

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Who is a loan player you fell ln love with while they were at Celtic?

N

nodrog.dleachim1950223d ago

Jason Denayer

R

rvybw9z4yf251d ago

This would be an awful decision, B Mc Neill would cost about £70 per wk maximum . H L about £50k max So does that mean u would be fraudulently fiddling Celtic out of nearly half the money for yourself

J

jmcg85282d ago

Bellamy and, to a lesser extent, Paddy Roberts

Open full discussion →

Was Shin Yamada unfairly treated at Celtic?

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Who is your favourite ever Celtic loan signing?

L

lynnfin123284d ago

Has to be Cadete

Open full discussion →

Was Hyeongyu Oh given a fair chance at Celtic?

E

edwarddelaney49134d ago

Kyogo kept him out

L

liamwinning88134d ago

Defo not..🇮🇪

F

fenian.pinguin286d ago

No

Open full discussion →

Arron

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Jimmy Johnston

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

He was underrated

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Which Celtic player was the better out of the two?

Who gets your vote? Cadete or Di Canio? Comment why you picked your choice

R

roncophotography213d ago

Can't make a comparison.Very different players.One a lethal finisher and the other a magician with the ball at his feet. The West Ham fans voted Di Canio they're greatest ever player in front of Bobby Moore for what it's worth.🤔

M

martingrehan24285d ago

Di Canio absolute genius!

P

pat.clark009287d ago

Superb striker would’ve scored 50 if DiCanio hadn’t been so selfish

A

amirmir285d ago

Agree. But sometimes Di Canio being selfish is what made him the genius he was. Joy to watch.

Open full discussion →

Mist underrated player at celtic ehat a wee gem he was always put his heart in2 it miss him badly

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Which Celtic player had the biggest impact despite spending one season at the club?

C

celtsmadginja287d ago

Arrange mooy

S

steven9761289d ago

Joey Barton. Lol

Open full discussion →

Was Leigh Griffiths underappreciated at Celtic?

J

jmcg85282d ago

Yes

C

celticfc88282d ago

Yes,he was a great wee striker, as good as Greaves.

B

brian61738287d ago

Yes

Open full discussion →

Were Celtic right to let go of Mikey Johnston?

J

johnprior999171d ago

I was surprised he didn’t make it a Celtic… got a fair chance but unfortunately he didn’t really take them…🍀

P

pauljaconelli84171d ago

Waste of time and efford

R

rvybw9z4yf223d ago

I don’t think they should . He suffered a lot of injuries. At Celtic he didn’t seem to have proper coaching & one to won training by a coach interested in improving him

Open full discussion →

Matt O'Riley returns to Brighton.

M

martin.crawford198d ago

Is the Pope a Catholic?

L

lynnfin123281d ago

In a heartbeat! - if only!#

J

jmcg85282d ago

100%. But it's wishful thinking

Open full discussion →

Hyeon-gyu Oh: overrated or underrated?

I

ianmcwhinnie7244d ago

Yang should be long gone he was the hero with the Motherwell game everybody including myself talking going to sell him then one of our best players they all failed yesterday thinking we just had to turn up then bang if you go into games especially this time of the season just having to turn up now it's hope results go our way and don't make the same mistake

M

mikeycolgan244d ago

Underrated like so many who weren't one of BR's favourites.

P

paddy244d ago

Agree with this. Should Never have sold him or Adam Idah

F

fenian.pinguin286d ago

Underrated

Open full discussion →

Celtic hero Virgil van Dijk creates Champions League history at Liverpool.

B

brian61738287d ago

No

T

tonymac44297d ago

Players of his quality will never be seen again under this Board of hopeless cases.

P

paddy297d ago

Could not agree more, mate.

Open full discussion →

Which former Celt who is still playing would you bring back to the club?

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Sead Haksabanovic: Overrated or Underrated?

P

paul.skelton299d ago

Great player couldn't understand why we let him go

Open full discussion →

Not all are

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

In a heart beat!

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

We could be doing withhim now

No comments yet. Be the first.

Open full discussion →

Which former Celtic player are you picking to come back?

B

busterbrady6183d ago

Jimmy Johnston

D

daniel.owen214d ago

Talking of recent departures, I'd love a 2026 version of Frimpong back

T

tommyc7216d ago

Mr Henrik Larrson ASAP

Open full discussion →

Sum up Nicolas Kuhn's time at Celtic...

O

o.danny1212287d ago

Yes. But I think he always saw us as a stepping-stone.

Open full discussion →

Mark Viduka's time at Celtic was...

B

brian61738287d ago

Brilliant player

S

smuddger1952300d ago

Ha ha! If only we coud turn back the clock! Smashing player

L

luckytroll82303d ago

Viduka was brilliant at Celtic I was a fan of his but he was also a disappointment at the same time constantly in the news about wanting to leave for a "better" team. He'd signed for Celtic and disappeared in his first week wanting to go at the very start. Never have I seen such an uncommitted player in my life. Yet he was absolutely fantastic for Celtic

J

jimmchugh1957290d ago

Couldn't agree more .Moody player but magical

Open full discussion →

Hayato Inamura's Celtic signing: What on earth happened?

G

gordoh010860298d ago

Inamura was bought on the back of the success of other signings from Japan in the hope of buying cheap and selling big! However for whatever reason he wasn’t afforded the time to settle in and become acclimatised to the Scottish game.

Open full discussion →