TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk

Celtic Players Out On Loan

Join the fan discussion on TalkingPoints regarding Celtic players currently out on loan and how they're faring.

83 comments

Maik Nawrocki's Hannover 96 loan spell has ended. What next?

Nawrocki missed out on promotion with Hannover

davidirvine701122d ago

Get him back in, excellent player 👏

♥ 1

spanielodonel976136d ago

Yes was good when he had game time so would keep him definitely

♥ 3

weefatboy1969138d ago

This would be a HUGE mistake, he's a great defender. HH

♥ 5

View 1 more comment
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Has Stephen Welsh earned a Celtic second chance?

15 wins in 33 games at Motherwell. Keep or cash in?

spanielodonel976136d ago

Keep him at celtic

paddy136d ago

No. Needs to go. Been at Celtic all his career and is yet to hit 100 appearances

qhsm4jzz99147d ago

He’s returned from loan once. He’d be a great addition to the squad again

♥ 2

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Interesting words from Johnny Kenny... Thoughts?

aidbyrne60d ago

It was Kenny's misfortune that Martin O'Neill chose to cling to the manager's job rather than step aside at the right moment just as the door was opening for a potentially elite level successor. O'Neill wouldn't give Kenny a look-in, instead shipping him out to Bolton on loan and inexplicably turning to Cvancara and Adamu in his place.

skevd6360d ago

I don't think Kenny has had enough consistent game time to really settle but he will do a job wherever he ends up ,would have liked to see him stay he is Celtic through a d through would always play for the top with pride

alanbhoy73161d ago

Id bring him back now we need someone to make an impact

♥ 1

View 8 more comments
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Should Celtic give Maik Nawrocki a chance next season after impressive Hannover loan?

Let us know in the comments!

johnprior99980d ago

Surely he must be ahead of Dane or is it the home development aspect at play??….🍀

pauljaconelli8480d ago

Maybe should not be selling him as way Nicholson said we aint buying alot or anymore blaiming other ppl cause our board are miserable

liamwinning8880d ago

100% he should..saves the board from spending two and a half million on another centre half..i think he's better than scales and trusty..🇮🇪

View 10 more comments
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

He's now enjoying life on loan at Hannover...

peter.kanesr160d ago

Never given a chance , better option than Trusty , who gets bullied by physical players and moans about it !! Could learn from CCV ,who never got bullied, if he was fit and we had never employed that waster nancy , league would have been won at christmas as usual !

♥ 2

rvybw9z4yf172d ago

This is just one example of the self egot BR . No Board could please him or satisfy him with players , he either rejected quality players & bought inferior or if Celtic signed quality players he ignored them & caused them to lose interest in playing for us . Stupid Celtic Collective blamed Board

♥ 2

ninedarter203d ago

I liked him he was confident on the ball.

♥ 2

View 1 more comment
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Luis Palma: overrated or underrated?

martin.crawford149d ago

Overrated, and I'll die on that hill

jas1160150d ago

Not a team player, when glory hunting constantly trying to score directly from corners says it all.

♥ 1

daniel.owen179d ago

Very silky but never thought he really had that turn of pace

View 1 more comment
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Were Celtic wrong to not give Hayato Inamura a chance at Celtic?

Does he still have a future at the club?

martin.crawford154d ago

Regardless of whether he comes good, a woefully handled signing

jas1160159d ago

The way Lagerbielke, Nawrocki etc were treated by Rodgers shows his analysis on players he didn't spot to be severely flawed!

♥ 1

illuminifty237d ago

He was refined

♥ 1

View 1 more comment
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Would you give Luis Palma another chance at Celtic?

gerrymcmac375158d ago

Definitely No , just not good enough to wear the strip !!!

alanbhoy73161d ago

Yes hes better than wingers that replaced kunh missed jota aswell

♥ 1

jas1160169d ago

When he played in the hoops, it was all about Palma eg forever trying to score direct from corners, not a team player, never will be.

View 3 more comments
🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Luis Palma to remain in Poland until the end of the season, but move to Lech is not currently 'financially viable'

eckw64w282d ago

They knew the price Celtic wanted b4 the loan, now and 4 a while they've been saying we can't afford it. Bring him back, and loan him to a team that can pay for him now. Not just the January window.

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion

Should Celtic consider recalling Stephen Welsh in January?

gregorykerr1.gk278d ago

Most definitely

algourdon88278d ago

We need to think long & hard about ALL our current loanees & their possible future contributions to the second half of the season - knowing our miserable, greed-ridden & unambitious Board, we won't be spending ANYTHING in January window... Maybe a few free transfers/loan deals??

amirmir298d ago

Only if Nancy is serious about playing him on a regular basis. Otherwise, don't waste his progression at a very good Motherwell team.

♥ 1

🙂Add a comment…Open Discussion