TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk Golf

Where do you rank Gary Player among the greatest golfers of all time

pqhawkins1mo ago

Woods - Hogan - Jack - Jones - Snead... Walter Hagen should be ahead of Player. Hagen is one of the most underrated players of all time. He was the first American to win The Open, and won it 4x. Five PGA Championships, and five Western Opens (which was like a major back then). He was a six time Ryder Cup captain, and won 11 majors.

bpwatson20251mo ago

Id have to say 6th i know I'm going to get a lot of backlash but Nicholas Woods salinzer mclroy hogan player

jordan.harris1mo ago

I think 6th is very fair tbh

walkercharlie8281mo ago

Top 5 when you consider everything he did in world golf back in that ers

dond1mo ago

I totally respect those opinions who feel Player is top three. 👏👏👏

dond1mo ago

Hogan, Byron Nelson, Saracen, Jones immediately come to mind but it depends on how to quantify it. His impact on the game doesn’t jump out at me. Again, I’m probably adding his personality into the equation. His self aggrandizement always bothered me. And the stunt at the Masters by his son left a bad taste in my mouth. I believe that was the venue.

jordan.harris1mo ago

Yep, agree with a lot of this. He provides entertainment but no one has praised Player higher than Gary himself

chillout1mo ago

The picture on here looks like an old Phil Mickelson !

antonymmartin841mo ago

It does actually, Phil is a top 10 all time player imo now you mention his name. Truly incredible career that he doesn’t get enough credit for due to the controversy he’s been involved in over the past few years

dond1mo ago

Well, reluctantly I concur he’s one of the greatest ever. Never much of a fan as I thought his outward persona was always so self-absorbed. Because he craves attention it has been himself who has been outspoken about his greatness and that’s never a good look. That said, his accomplishments are many and deserve respect and recognition. Third greatest? Nah.

chillout1mo ago

Who would you have above him. Jack and Tiger are really the only two. Maybe Palmer.

johnverrall111mo ago

I think he really is a love or hate character. I have to say I love him personally! As for where he ranks in the best golfers of all time, I’d say fourth or fifth.

jordan.harris1mo ago

Somewhere between 5-8 I think. Woods, Nicklaus, Hogan, Jones is the top four and then I have Gary battling with Palmer and Hagen

antonymmartin841mo ago

5th for me, behind Woods, Nicklaus, Hogan and Bobby Jones!

pqhawkins1mo ago

I would rank Sam Snead ahead of Player.

chillout1mo ago

Palmer ?

chillout1mo ago

Top 3 - like many of us said a couple of days ago!

pqhawkins1mo ago

Gary Player is not top three of all time. I honestly don't think he's top five all time. I would definitely say that no top 10 list of all time would be complete without Gary Player on the list