TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk Golf

Is Rory McIlroy now the greatest European golfer of all time?

ranillabean8813h ago

happy gilmore

peggyjkaler5d ago

I don’t think he is a consistent golfer. He goes from 65 on wel too 77 the next. The has never shown the consistency of a GREAT golfer

jamesshearman235d ago

How can you complete the career Grand Slam without being a great golfer?

antonymmartin846d ago

So so tough. I think Rory leads just by a whisker. Faldo is my all time favorite golfer so it’s hard for me not to pick him haha. Seve had a huge impact on the sport, but Rory’s 6th major and CGS gives him the edge

donaghcorby19976d ago

He has been for years. Stats back it up but also cultural relevance and intangibles that make someone a legend.

jamesshearman236d ago

It’s Rory by a distance now. The second Masters ended the debate. His longevity has been incredible and he can work his way up the top 10 all time list with a few more majors

jordan.harris6d ago

By a distance is crazy! You born in 2000 or something

chillout6d ago

Where do you place Seve and Faldo in terms of all-time ?

jordan.harris6d ago

Think people really forget how strong the European Tour was in the 80s and early 90s

chillout6d ago

Who you thinking of ?

kierandoody6d ago

Currently reading his biography. Statistically he already trumps Faldo and Ballesteros for ‘big’ wins, I don’t see how it’s up for debate. You forget how good he is because of how relateable he is, breezes through courses then in the following tournament looks completely lost. He’s definitely the most important player of the post-Tiger era.

adnan.riaz6d ago

In the modern format, without question he is. In history, it’s so hard to say. Rory vs Faldo is like Messi vs Pele — different eras, so it’s always difficult to have a clear picture.

chillout6d ago

Would have been interesting to have seen how these three would have stacked up against peak Woods.

peter.lynch6d ago

He is indeed! Major count alone takes him there in my opinion, but combined with everything else there is no question 🐐

leeclarke05086d ago

Recency bias at play but yeah he takes it for me. The scary thing is he's got more titles to win yet

johnverrall116d ago

It’s hard to make an argument for anyone but Rory at this point, especially as he won’t have even stopped winning yet.

chillout6d ago

Seve apparently won 89 professional tournaments over 21 years to Rory’s current 45 in 17 years (Faldo 43 over 20 years). Rory has played in the most competitive era of the three, with Seve playing against more of the all-time legends. Faldo was tail end Nicklaus and Watson and retired as Woods arrived on the scene.

chillout6d ago

This is a difficult one. Faldo and Rory (so far) have won 6 majors each, with Seve on 5. But Rory is the only European player to win the Career Grand Slam. He has probably done enough already to wear that crown - but one more major would do away with any doubt.