TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk Manchester United

Who would you like to be the Man United manager?

Ineos can’t decide whether to sack or back Michael Carrick, or who should replace him - Let us know your thoughts!

rackaraisaac71w ago

New coaches New ideas and tactics Same players New promises Old owners without support to a coach Big expectations, Man utd will remain a mid team without trophies fighting for champions league qualification every time. The same players will let poch down, let's keep watching.i think they have start looking for a new coach coz poch is not the solution

winva20021w ago

I have a solution: fire Kerik, then hire him back as an interim manager until the end of the year. This team has no character. It only knows how to play when there's no pressure.

stephendavies199911w ago

Sacking managers all the time since Fergie hasn't worked

kansiimeitungo761w ago

United will not be okay if they keep on sacking coaches

nyakoiphilipm1w ago

The problem of MU is far away from Carrick. Therefore sacking him will not solve our problem, until the owner do the needful. if not, no man coach born of a woman can succeed with this current squad. only Jesus Christ will have that power to change things with this our current squad.

thetruthpersonified1w ago

Just had the thought. The Brains trust are going to sack Carrick and say they are starting a process and meanwhile, Fletcher is caretaker. Please dear God no!! Not that! Anything but that! Someone with a slight clue and some charisma Please... Not the Fletcher-bot. FYI - I am a Darren Fletcher fan. As a player!

gls4united1w ago

It is very interesting to notice that MC is the clear favorite of the people voting. Maybe the higher ups will back him to the hilt. Buy some serious players in January and insist he uses the kids

jackgallagher1w ago

Conte's the best manager of the bunch. Winner through and through. The turnaround he inspired at Juve is one of the best jobs any manager has done in the last 20 years

paulrayner6531w ago

But conte will want control (not unreasonably) and the cowards upstairs won't give him that.

mahomediyoop1w ago

Oops my mistake. It should have been ' Does it makes sense to you'.

mahomediyoop1w ago

Let's talk about a new manager after their is a change in ownership. Until then whoever becomes the manager will experience the same fate as Carrick. Ten Hag, Solskaer, Mourinho, Van Gaal and Moyes. This makes sense to me.

paulrayner6531w ago

Rather stick with Carrick, give some kids a chance and in January buy a decent left back and an experienced proper striker to help Sesko when he is back.

dwykes591w ago

@paulrayner653 the problem is he is not giving the kids a chance. Hasn't started Amass and Lacey should be starting over Diall0

paulrayner6531w ago

Doesn't matter who the manager is.Manager not the problem. Problem is further up with the Muppets who buy average players for £70m+ & then can't sell them for their true value of 25% of what we paid for them when they can't hack it. Can't see any decent UCL quality players wanting to come to United let alone a decent manager unless they get full control.

kierandoody1w ago

Of that list Pochettino is the standout. Not convinced the manager is the problem though - enough have tried and failed now to see the manager is the least of United’s worries.

johnverrall111w ago

Pochettino is the best of these choices by a distance

chillout1w ago

I’m not sure about him - had good teams at Spurs, Chelsea and PSG but arguably underachieved. His overall win rate as a manager is less than 50%. He is a decent manager, but not an elite one in the same league as Jose, Pep, Klopp, Conte, Anchelotti and Zidane. But maybe that is the best United will get at the moment.

lrandall12101w ago

Give it to Cristiano Ronaldo

callum_boyle1w ago

Saw an article from the athletic and Ernesto Valverde felt like a great option. Managed at clubs with big expectations, worked with limited resources (Bilbao Basque policy) and fluent English speaker. Not an ego but commands respect. Better than the other options but I do feel for Carrick. Surprised Deschamps isn’t linked more

dale.odonnell1w ago

@callum_boyle I don't think he's in the running, but a very good shout. 👍

callum_boyle1w ago

Ultimately though, the fish rots from the head and until the owners, Berrada and Wilcox go, nothing changes

antonymmartin841w ago

None of the above get them out of the mess they’re in imo. The problem is that the four managers who could evoke change are all completely unrealistic - Pep, Klopp, Arteta and Don Carlo

thetruthpersonified1w ago

You missed the other unreachable and arguably the best which is Enrique.

djburnzz1w ago

Carrick got UTD to 3rd last year from the brink. No drastic squad changes to blame this season. Besides, some of the worlds top managers had a go and failed. Not sure its a management barrier.

paddygibbs941w ago

You can change the manager all you like but that won't stop the rot. If you don't back the manager get out the club. The next manager will have the same problems as Carrick and all before him. SAF was the last manager to run the football club as it should be run the rest have had to answer to people above and look where that has got us. Keep Carrick BACK HIM

stephenjholmes11w ago

I agreed with everything you said, right until the last sentence. Carrick is a bottle merchant. He continues to use Dalot when Amass hasn't even had a chance. Lacey is being wasted. Our academy is getting destroyed like the rest of the shambles that was once the world's greatest club.

dancoombs1w ago

Sadly the time to back Carrick properly was in the summer, and they failed to do so

george.patten1w ago

Conte would demand standards. Howe is a good pick in theory but I don’t think he is respected enough to take that job right now with how difficult it is

jameslloyd14.jl1w ago

Eddie Howe would be the most sensible hire for me, though I do think Nagelsmann could be an interesting punt worth taking

dancoombs1w ago

I’d be most confident in Pochettino but I feel indifferent to sacking Carrick while the clowns above him remain in charge

dale.odonnell1w ago

I think Conte is the best coach on this list, but that doesn't make him the best fit for United in 2026. His outspokenness would cause panic stations for Ineos. They didn't like it when Amorim spoke out of turn. Ultimately, the owners are the problem. It's not Conte's fault they don't like the truth or transparency.

chillout1w ago

Where are you on Ineos ? Is Jim part of the problem, or potentially part of a solution ?

nigellawless1w ago

What is the problem, how many managers will the players throw under the bus. If the hierarchy constantly get the wrong Manager and cost £15- £20 million in compensation on what seems like a yearly basis. I know what two I'd be firing.

dancoombs1w ago

Easy choice really. Ratcliffe just doesn’t want the hassle to sacking his mates, as it would mean he has to admit making errors in appointing them in the first place

peter.lynch1w ago

Would love to see Conte back in England! Howe may steady the ship a bit but I don’t think fans will be too excited about that one

dale.odonnell1w ago

@peter.lynch Eddie Howe would be an unpopular appointment.

dale.odonnell1w ago

@peter.lynch Eddie Howe would be an extremely unpopular appointment.

shamanth.jayaram1w ago

Has to be Conte for me. Definitely a risk but anyone else will just be a puppet for the board until they’re sacked this time next year

will.butcher1w ago

Would love Howe to get it, deserves it and wouldn’t take any prisoners

chillout1w ago

I’m not sure Howe is strong enough. I like him - but I think United is a toxic mess and would eat him before breakfast.

markmarston1w ago

Poch has the highest floor but not the highest upside. I do like him - safe pair of hands. I’d go for Fabregas & follow Arsenal’s model with Arteta. Let him learn on the job & build from the ground up. Give him good staff & let him slowly improve year on year. Don’t even think about sacking him after 18 months. Assess after 3 yrs. He’s the next special one.

stephenjholmes11w ago

That was meant to be the route with Michael. We have to ask how he has such a transformation in such a short space of time? He doesn't look like he could spell tactical knowhow, let alone deliver any this season. He has totally brought this about himself. Yes he hasn't been backed with transfers, but his total refusal to even try a different approach says it

dancoombs1w ago

Not for me. I respect what he’s building but I don’t want him at OT

jonathan.gorrie1w ago

Conte! Not convinced by Poch, didn't he get fed up of the Chelsea owners in the end? If you're going to employ someone who is going to kick off, may as well go for the one who actually wins things. Nagelsmann is a bluffer and not sure Howe, much as I like him, has the charisma required

jonathan.gorrie1w ago

@jonathan.gorrie I get that Carrick is maybe not the king of charisma but he had the playing career behind him

chillout1w ago

Difficult to see anything changing unless the owners sell. Support Carrick !!