
What do you think of the decision to fire Michael Carrick?
daviescallum421w ago
He had to go but thrown massively under the bus. Copy and paste for every manager that has been and will come
kilham.max1w ago
Right decision. I like him as a person but was clearly in over his head.
pranav.shahaney1w ago
Can’t believe there are 59% who believe he should have stayed. United are 18th right now - one point away from being last. Sure, it’s not all on the manager and there are bigger problems at the club, but Carrick definitely was one of them
johnmartin.jordan1w ago
Carrick should be given till Christmas to turn things around. Hope some of the players who didn't give a toss are now very proud of themselves.
josh.barker1w ago
Had to go but questions should be asked about why he got the permanent job in the first place
franrobtradepoint1w ago
Be honest if Bolton Bury Rochdale or Salford were in the bottom three after one win in ten game's There manager would be sacked. Add to the fact he played left backs at right back Centre half at right back.Mason Mount on the wing. With Lacy and Amass sat on the bench. Thinking will I ever get a chance.
lrandall12101w ago
He had to go with the recent results and the way things are going. But struggle to see much changing with a new man
niko1w ago
I am a lifelong Manchester United fan, and Ive been so since 1966. Sacking Carrick was a horrendous decision. I'm exasperated and heart-broken at the relentless efforts of Ratcliffe, Glazers and Ineos to destroy United. At this stage, I refrain from watching United or commenting on United until the destroyers go
niko1w ago
@niko We have to get our club back!!!!!
david.comerford1w ago
Shocked by how many have called it the wrong decision. He's not the biggest problem at Man Utd but he's still an obstacle to any real success
gehopwood1w ago
Ineos have already bought players who were not good enough for other premier league clubs. Now about to hire a manager who has proved not good enough at2 other premier clubs. The wrong people being sacked.
knightinwhitesatin1w ago
Just when you think nobody can be worse than Woodward and the Glazers along come the 3 stooges of Ineos Ratcliffe,Berrada and Wilcox and in their short tenure turn the club into an absolute joke
caleb.sage1w ago
I’m sure no one saw this coming… at the end of day, he had to go. This ownership is wack, but a team with the players United have should not be in the relegation zone. That comes down to the manager, coaching, the players’ belief in him etc.
mahomediyoop1w ago
I dont think United should have rushed and sacked Carrick. You can't keep on hiring managers and when the results are not right you sack them. Will it be the same thing if Pochetino becomes the next manager? Personally I think the same thing will happen to Pochetino!
chillout1w ago
That is my view - I would have given Carrick another few weeks.
vatsal1w ago
In pure footballing terms, he had to go, but leave it to Ineos to mess up even a straighforward decision. Wait for the international break to hire an international manager, while letting things drift to relegation zone, and never speaking to the fans. WORST IN CLASS!
antonymmartin841w ago
Absolutely the right decision. Regardless of everything that is wrong with Man United, he escaped criticism far too easily imo. He set up a team that was tactically inept week after week, and he is clearly not good enough to manage a team at this level.
james.brooke1w ago
Football is a results business and he currently has United sitting in the relegation zone in mid November. Absolutely deserves to be sacked and he’s lucky that those above him are taking most of the blame. Pathetic stint
dale.odonnell1w ago
Been one of Carrick’s biggest defenders on this, but the sacking was coming. United are 18th in the Premier League after winning 1 of their first 10 Premier League matches. He’s not the only one at fault and I’d much prefer if others were shown the door before Carrick.
seanfisher1w ago
He did have to go in my opinion. But the handling of it all is just so so messy. Wilcox should be out the door first
leeclarke05081w ago
Had to go but Martinez and Fernandes should be ashamed of themselves. Sure when Pochettino comes in they'll start playing again now that big nasty Carrick has gone. Modern day footballers really wind me up sometimes. Carrick was the saviour when they were flying last season...
aaditya.krishnamurthy1w ago
He shouldn’t have been hired, this is the same mistake United made with Ole, and the fact that they expected different results is insane - a new manager won’t turn things around overnight - need one who can get them out of the duldrums for good before thinking about competing
dancoombs1w ago
If they didn’t hire him in summer- every time the new boss lost, it would have been ‘get Carrick back’ He did too well last season for our own good
thetruthpersonified1w ago
I wonder if MC had been informed a few weeks ago, after the Bournemouth match. So MC knew the position and thus it was not as disrespectful as it appears. If not, it is disgusting treatment!! Right decision, but disgraceful. I gotta assume MC knew all along.
dancoombs1w ago
I think board are too indecisive for that
paulrayner6531w ago
We are a poisonous mess and joke of a club. All the previous values instilled by SMB and SAF have been swept away and the way we treat some legends eg Whiteside, De Gea, Ole and now Carrick is scandalous. Hard to carry on supporting this shambles with any passion. 😞
will.butcher1w ago
Harsh cos it isn’t his fault, but it had to happen
thetruthpersonified1w ago
We do not know how much was his fault. I agree there are significant issues elsewhere in the club, but that does not automatically mean that MC was good and not a problem.
jamesshearman231w ago
The correct decision but it has been handled so badly. He should never have been offered the job in the first place but where’s the respect for a club legend? You don’t agree a deal with Poch while he’s still there
peter.lynch1w ago
He had to go sadly. Not entirely his fault but he could have done much, much better. Could be a while before the club gets back to where it really belongs
callum_boyle1w ago
Hung out to dry and made to take the flack for a group of charlatans above him. He wasn’t a brilliant manager but the messing about and incompetence from Wilcox, Berrada, Ratcliffe and Glazers have played a huge role in issues on the pitch. This shouldn’t taint his legacy in any way
matthew.johns1w ago
We all knew that it was coming! United will probably have a bounce now with Pochettino coming in, but long-term I think the same issues will prevail once again.
epi2media1w ago
Another Episode of our Comedy Show begins. We just got another mgr🤣. Yay!!The Accounts Team, please start preparing another Sack Budget after paying the US £9m and MC £3m. This is fun. At the same, pls check for other operational areas to downsize, or better still, just increase ticket prices. The fans will always buy! Thank you.
kyle.archer1w ago
Even if Carrick was or was not the right choice to be given the job full-time, the circus at Old Trafford will continue with the current Man Utd players
camerondesc11w ago
Was inevitable. Don’t think poch is the answer though
chillout1w ago
There always was going to be a fall guy - Carrick only had to look in the mirror. Hope he is gonna get a big kiss off wad.
jameslloyd14.jl1w ago
The right decision. Yes there are deeper issues at Utd but he shouldn’t evade criticism. One win in 10 is horrific
knightinwhitesatin1w ago
The three stooges Ratcliffe Berrada and Wilcox are more to blame than Carrick it's been a disastrous farce since Ineos was given control of football matters they're even worse than Woodward and the Glazers which I didn't think anyone could be worse than them
barryroberts721w ago
I agree it's bad the way it was done, but nobody has said anything about Palace and Frank. Hopefully if it's defo Poch he gets full control of buying and selling players.
monstermunch1w ago
I think it was the right decision, but not necessarily because Carrick wasn't good enough. It was a mismatch from the start. He wasn't really set up to succeed by the people above him, and ultimately he's paid the price for that. Changing the manager is easy, but unless those higher up take some responsibility, what really changes?
dancoombs1w ago
Right now all I can see if the pathetic way Ineos have handled the situation. So, so poor
orme20091w ago
He was great as an interim manager, but not for the full time post. The correct move
charlesjones1w ago
Right call. He should never have been hired really.
camerondesc11w ago
I said this after he did well as interim, was always going to end up like this
eoin1w ago
Agreed, job was too Big for him. Still have United Hope last season though and UCL , Will be remember fondly for that