TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk Manchester United

🚨 Mauricio Pochettino looks set to become the new Man United manager, with a deal being finalised to replace Michael Carrick. Give us your instant reaction

davecarey281w ago

I hope he gets rid of the oldies with big contracts and players who are injury prone or who are unfit. That's quite a lot of them going, and then gets a shed oad of hungry new players and uses academy players also who all want success not ones we have who await their pay cheque every week!

gjchapman81w ago

If Poch, can work with young players, then let him use our academy players, who have fire in their belly's. Don't let us be like Wilcox's Southhampton and sell them for a profit.

kilham.max1w ago

Good choice for now. He’s a calm presence who should steady the shop for a while!

febced11w ago

I agree 100%. I assume he will be given the green light to sign new players, a request denied to Carrick. MC was literally thrown under the bus. Let's hope for the best. I'm not excited by MP 's appointment.

davecarey281w ago

I wish him all the best he will need it persuading hierarchy to buy players he wants instead of who they want as cheap replacements

brexitant1w ago

Employing an Argie especially how that country has treated us trying to declare the Falklands theirs. give some of our youngsters a chance to play together and most of all get another great Robson in midfield, someone with BALLS. So many of us just don't recognise this once great club, it's like the days before Ronno was manager.

ericjsmithesq1w ago

@brexitant Not much of one, but one think about before it happens....... the little Argie will be on the pitch in the next game he is allowed after suspension

daodumoses19831w ago

You shouldn't continue to blame coaches for the mishap in Manchester united. Give the coach quality players who can stand for the club. The full backs needs overhauling. Remove tired legs and bring in fresh and experienced energy to the team. Let Bruno and Mbuemo not start every game.

chrisflood1471w ago

I think like before united will be great for a few months and players will down tools again.Should have brought in Roy to clear that dressing room.

vatsal1w ago

@chrisflood147 Do you think the players downed tools this time? Those comebacks don't happen under a checked out dressing room. There are serious tactical issues, and even bigger ones above the manager, but I don't think player power was an issue this time.

knightinwhitesatin1w ago

Just when you think there can't be anything worse that can happen to any club than Woodward and the Glazers along come the 3 stooges of Ineos Ratcliffe Berrada and Wilcox and in their short tenure of the club turn it into a laughing stock in no time at all and Carrick is Moneymore fall guy for them

vatsal1w ago

@knightinwhitesatin No statement from any individual. Praising Carrick for professionalism when they showed none, and now the buffoons who hired three managers in three managers are empowered to hire a fourth. It's a circus, Ineos are clowns, but nobody is laughing.

deansexton461w ago

at the moment utd haven't got a Clue,it I just 3 guy's who think they can help utd but sadly haven't got a clue,Wilcox would find it difficult directing traffic all 3 wouldn't be able to orgaize a party at a brewery,so we have no chance in getting help on the pitch

antowzky1w ago

Now we just need to give Shaw, Mount, Rashford, Dalot, Ugarte and Maguire new five year deals each! So yet another manager can be unsuccessful! Luckily the performance on the sporting side doesnt affect business so much. Best in class!

mohan183101w ago

This will definitely happen, then the rumours about we signing kane in each window.

dancoombs1w ago

This is my concern- that Poch will give too many undeserving players another chance

paulsworld711w ago

Given the number of managers/coaches we’ve had since SAF I would have thought those in their ivory towers would have figured the manager is not the problem. There’s quite a few players we need rid of and experienced forward thinking people at board level who have more than a clue what they are doing and need to do.

dale.odonnell1w ago

@paulsworld71

antowzky1w ago

@paulsworld71 those ivory towers dont seem to come with mirrors. Otherwise they would've spotted the problem real quick

rackaraisaac71w ago

But always a garden without its real tool for practice may grow nothing except weeds, I think before poch, let's start looking for another coach coz I am seeing failures only, if a person who played for the club, failed then you who coming to seek for job and lastly the players man I have

rackaraisaac71w ago

They are right to change but with the defenders we have even if u bring pep he won't accept them, I see instead of sending Carrick away. Give him the money or buy him the players he wants then we see

stephenjholmes11w ago

Carrick doesn't want to try anything other than regurgitating the same dross weak after week. He has assets that could potentially change the whole trajectory of the team, but he never had the guts to try. Rashford got his chance under Van Gall due to injuries. He took that chance. Others need the chance!

robdunning411w ago

@rackaraisaac7 Totally agree, the manager knows the team he wants, it shouldn't be down to the board to select players and then say there you go, you get players for where there is shortfalls, you cant blame carrick, I think things were turning and the success would have come

caleb.sage1w ago

Poch is a safe bet and still a good coach. Go for it💪

thugthugger39101w ago

@caleb.sage He never lost a dressing room in all the clubs he coached.

don5977531w ago

I hope im wrong but the problem is upstairs n have a bit more faith in the youth but will poch play them knowing he's got a load of overpriced assets not in the shop window

karl43watkins1w ago

And you think he's better than Carrickf did nothing at spurs will not be good for us

stephenjholmes11w ago

My mum could have done better than Carrick. It hurts to say it of 1 of our greats, but he bottled it.

davecarey281w ago

I will give him 12 months if he's lucky, he hasnt got the win ratio or backbone of someone like Conte.

davecarey281w ago

I will give him 12 months if he's lucky, he hasnt got the win ratio or backbone of someone like Conte. In the short term Wilcox and Berrado will find some money to save themselves yet again, but then Pocho will get disenchanted, its a poison chalice no wonder the best managers will not touch us.

josh.barker1w ago

He’s a massive upgrade on Carrick but still not sure he’s the right man. Feel like he peaked at Spurs

febced11w ago

Change is painful, so yes, it's necessary. Pochettino coming in, I'm sure suddenly money will be found to buy players,,and Berrada and Wilcox will be vindicated.

adnan.riaz1w ago

This was not on my bingo card for 2026. 😭🥲

febced11w ago

I assert it's totally humiliating for MC to report to Carrington on a daily basis, with no closure on his future. It's employment abuse of the highest order.

kilham.max1w ago

Feels like this has been on the cards for a decade! A good manager but unsure if he is the long-term solution. Should steady the ship but can he truly turn the club around when the main issues sit above?

stephenjholmes11w ago

Who has been able too so far? I think outside of a Klopp, Enrique, Pep, he is about as good as it gets.

epi2media1w ago

There is a long queue at Utd bank. He will have a brilliant run , then when a little extra work is demanded, the players will start - "The 'Senior' usual suspects r said to prefer Emery! Demise Incorp! and downhill we go again to the next in the queue. Meanwhile we are laying off loyal workers and squeezing fans while paying off failures. Remarkable!

david.comerford1w ago

The market isn't great, but when was the last time Poch was genuinely impressive in a club job?

adnan.riaz1w ago

Literally Tottenham and that’s it. And even then, his Spurs run had no silverware to show for it.

pranav.shahaney1w ago

Best manager to bring in during the current circumstances

adnan.riaz1w ago

The bar is at an all-time low, isn’t it? 🥲

epi2media1w ago

Welcome to the United Bank of Manchester, Poch - a guaranteed minimum £5m if you fail - and you can bring a few hangers on too, to add to the £5m. Your enablers can't wait to walk around during matches under your mgt - they are always there, in few good times and many very bad times. You lucky person! I hope to land some job like that soon!🙂‍↕️

adnan.riaz1w ago

It’s an easy payday. Wish I would have become a manager now. Maybe in the next life, I suppose…🤣

apgcfrg1w ago

Let's just carry on with manager merry-go-round. It would be too sensible to give Carrick more time.

adnan.riaz1w ago

Oh, the cycle always continues at Man Utd. We’ve had to live through this for 13 years now.

lrandall12101w ago

I think it’s a positive change, but again, these players just seem the problem

jjflash4221w ago

I agree,out of the coaches listed,poch+unai are the best coaches,these players need to be told to just play+train.i remember what he did with kane,he looked bang average but poch got him fit,hungry,with targets and if the players zip up,he'll improve them.ps.leave laurel+Hardy in Monaco and get someone top notch to work with vivelli.

adnan.riaz1w ago

Like Roy Keane said, they’ll throw this manager under the bus just like they did with Ole. Rinse and repeat.

will.butcher1w ago

I really like Poch. Hopefully the black hole that is Man United doesn’t swallow him up and spit him out

adnan.riaz1w ago

As a Man Utd fan… I wish I shared the optimism.

dale.odonnell1w ago

Sadly, the same owners remain, and there are no signs of Wilcox or Berrada going. Best of luck, Pochettino. You'll need it with those clowns calling the shots.

adnan.riaz1w ago

I was wondering why I saw Berrada and Wilcox with red noses during the Villa match. 🤡

roycheong181w ago

If Pochettino fails, then Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox must resign.

adnan.riaz1w ago

They should both have been axed now.

dale.odonnell1w ago

@roycheong18 Why give them another chance?

george.patten1w ago

Is this the last blockbuster move United can make before they lose their pull? Feels like it. Will be interesting to see if Poch can make it work

adnan.riaz1w ago

Just the same song and dance number. Just the money is running out for United now. 🫠 Shame we have no deb… oh, wait a minute.

dancoombs1w ago

I’m not happy with another managerial change - but I am content with the choice of replacement. I think Pochettino is a good option to move forward with

adnan.riaz1w ago

It feels like we’ve seen this every single time. I think we’re all just fed up and want some kind of meaningful stability now.

jameslloyd14.jl1w ago

Should’ve come in post LVG/Jose, but I think this is a reasonably good hire. A manager with international respect, has managed some of the best players in football and seems intuned with the cultural DNA of the club

adnan.riaz1w ago

We had this with Youri on the pitch. Could have signed him ages ago, but then got him well past his prime. And now it’s Potch’s turn. Every. Single. Time. 😫

shamanth.jayaram1w ago

Obviously a massive upgrade on Carrick. Will bring a good style, give opportunities to young players and likely get the fans back onside. But is he the man to make United great again under this ownership? I have my doubts

dale.odonnell1w ago

@shamanth.jayaram That's the big question.

adnan.riaz1w ago

Agreed. And nope, he isn’t. Poch will meet the same fate as the rest. We never learn from our mistakes!

johnverrall111w ago

Pochettino is a massive upgrade on Carrick or any manager United have had since Mourinho. Can’t believe there’s so much negativity around this appointment

charlesjones1w ago

It’s an upgrade but I can see him going in 18 months again. Poch not done anything notable since 2019 at this point!

peter.lynch1w ago

Wow, big news. Feels like United have been after Pochettino for years, so I’m sure there is plenty of excitement to finally get him in. Things can only get better surely?

leeclarke05081w ago

He'll get them attacking again but does feel like he's coming a bit too late. That said, I sense until Wilcox is gone not a great deal will change.

jonny1w ago

It’s long been said Wilcox’s fate is tied to Carrick… we can only hope

kierandoody1w ago

How many memebers of staff will be cut to pay for his pay-off in 18 months when he becomes the latest scapegoat for this ownership?

kyle.archer1w ago

At least Pochettino taking over Man Utd will stop the endless speculation about him taking over at Man Utd...

dale.odonnell1w ago

@kyle.archer Bravo. 🤣

jonathan.gorrie1w ago

Good coach but has been a declining force since leaving Spurs. It’s all a bit meh

seanfisher1w ago

It feels a bit like a… soft choice? Can just see him getting walked over by the players and the media. The pressure of this job is so underestimated and I fear this could be a disaster given that he’s a long-term project manager and he won’t get any patience

jonny1w ago

I get the criticism but I think it’s a great appointment, even if just to stabilise the club and get us back to competing every season (which we need right now) - Trusts youth - Exciting football - Proven in the PL - Charismatic - Passionate - Doesn’t let the players walk all over him Delighted with this

seanfisher1w ago

I agree with the first 3 points but I just feel like it could go the same way it went at Chelsea for him

charlesjones1w ago

I can see your point but also the players did kind of walk all over him at PSG

chillout1w ago

Underwhelming choice. Managing Team USA is probably where his level is now - but you can’t blame him if he signs up; the kiss off pay when it all ends in tears will be very welcome. He won’t be out of work for long either if that happens either.

mervyn-cedric-hipperson1w ago

What has he won? I don't think it's a good choice,but if he comes get behind him and hope that the managment finally get the right players in

jonny1w ago

Just to point out we are in the relegation zone, we don’t need to worry about winning things let’s just finish in the top half and win some games first!

orme20091w ago

He won nothing with Spurs, why would it be any different with him in charge at Man U?

aaditya.krishnamurthy1w ago

I think that’s the point - they need a steadying presence who can do the leg work for someone to take over later. I liken it to how Xavi helped Barcelona get back to winning before Hansi Flick made them a better side

charlesjones1w ago

Feels like this is 6/7 years too late. Then again, I liked Poch at Spurs so who knows

brogan1w ago

Agree with this. Not sure I really wanted him to come back to Spurs tbh despite how much we love him. Having said that, he can galvanise a team but just think United are doomed the way that club is atm