TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk Manchester United

Ineos must take responsibility for the way they have treated Michael Carrick - Do you think any lessons have been learned?

Do you believe Wilcox and Berrada will pay the price at the end of the season? Will Pochettino be treated any differently?

arjunvetri11191w ago

The fact is Carrick has never been a proper Coach and the last season results were only due to the efforts of the previous Coach Ruben. When it was decided to make Carrick the permanent Manager, the writing was on the wall since he lacked the tactical acumen, versatility, tactical awareness of opponents and managerial skills.

knightinwhitesatin1w ago

Have you ever known whatever industry or occupation do the top brass ever take responsibly for thier actions I was in the Army reserves for 13 years the best NCO rank is a 2 striper the Sergeant is told to get the men to do something so he gives the corporal the orders who passes them on to the lance jack who tells the men what to do & I can blame him

gwcghw1w ago

Sums up the club's ambitions. If you don't want to win anything get a coach who hasn't won anything except the French Farmers League. Anyone want to use our season tickets?

deansexton461w ago

Ineos Don't learn lessons don't be so silly that would mean they actually care but it's so Obvious they only care about Radcliffe

matthew.johns1w ago

I highly doubt it. This is the way they think they should run the club and I’m not sure they’re bothered about what people think of it. I feel sorry for Carrick as he is the latest to get caught up in it!

daviescallum421w ago

No chance they’ve learnt anything, it’s been over a decade of failure after failure. Time to go

kyle.dimond1w ago

I just can’t see it changing whether it’s Carrick or Poch. It might improve in the short term but I feel like we may as well just set the crisis timer back a bit

pranav.shahaney1w ago

Poch’s title says head coach. I hope he’s come in with assurances over more control on how the club is run. If not, rinse and repeat

geldroper2d ago

@pranav.shahaney As long as we not getting rid of bad players we are going to be the same and hopefully not relegated.Still not crazy about MB and Amad. They both need to many changes to score. We need a explosive striker and Sesko is a great sub

charlesjones1w ago

Interesting that there’s been no exit interview with Carrick the way there was with Solskjaer. Wonder if he was given the option?

chillout1w ago

Carrick is just a pawn in the game. He knew that signing up. And he will be another manager who will do well financially from United’s systematic problems. Is the lack of respect and humiliation worth it ? Hell, yes!

adnan.riaz1w ago

Michael Carrick's treatment has been awful. Ineos made this 20 times worse based on that alone!

thetruthpersonified1w ago

Firstly - I am no defender of the Exec or owners. Despise them all and none are fit to be involved with United. I genuinely felt that after Bournmouth a deal was done with MC and the International break. None of us know, but isn't it possible MC knew and was aware in advance? Now I am still not saying it was right at all. Was still disgusting to watch..

adnan.riaz1w ago

@thetruthpersonified, it was like watching a wounded animal being kept alive for the sake of it. Didn't put him out of his misery and embarrassed Carrick more with how they handled it.

kilham.max1w ago

Yes they do. Carrick, like managers in the past, has been treated with a lot of disrespect. So many leaks about his replacement before he’s been sacked!

adnan.riaz1w ago

@kilham.max, sums up modern football and the state of Man Utd. Gone are the days of the Ferguson era and how controlled and measured this kind of stuff was.

paulsworld711w ago

Ineos and Ratcliffe simply don’t care. There’s only one way and it’s their way. We can see they are wrong but,to them, fans are just revenue lines on a balance sheet. They have treated Carrick appallingly in my opinion and I think it’s gonna be a continuation of rinse and repeat.

adnan.riaz1w ago

@paulsworld71, Jim is a ruthless businessman, as shown by all the cuts that were made. It shouldn't come as a surprise, but my word does it hurt as a Man Utd fan to see it.

thugthugger39101w ago

@paulsworld71 so you wanted Ineos to buy Rogers,Mahew fernandez,Elliot anderson sane season on what budget? they had plans they had agreements on how to strenghten the team. its a plan it doesnt mean it must work.

febced11w ago

Does Ineos, with Berrada snd Wilcox accept that they maltreated Carrick❓ Ineos is an entrepreneur, Berrada and Wilcox are subservient to him, so the lesson that they can learn: "Treat others the way you want to be treated". Be humane.

adnan.riaz1w ago

@febced1, how Berrada and Wilcox are still in jobs baffles me beyond belief. Dream big, kids, because quite clearly you can achieve big without ever delivering anything on a consistent basis.

mufcgrw19771w ago

Why even ask this - they have treated managers with no respect the whole time they have had sporting control, fans with utter distain, no is the answer

adnan.riaz1w ago

@mufcgrw1977, all of the getting sacked is a telling sign, as it is. But some have had worse treatment, including Louis van Gaal and now Carrick.

dancoombs1w ago

Perfectly summed up. I think there is no amount of editing that Amazon can possibly do to make Wilcox and Berrada seem remotely competent. There's no way they can still be here this year if we are a serious club

stephenjholmes11w ago

This surely is Last chance saloon for Wilcox and Berrada.

adnan.riaz1w ago

@dancoombs, those Amazon cameras are going to be working overtime. What an awful time for United to sign up to that.