TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk Manchester United

According to press reports, United had contact / exploratory discussions with Poch about a United job in May 2016, December 2018, November 2021, March / April 2022 and May - summer 2024. Five occasions in 10 years with no appointment. What’s changed now ?

stephenjholmes16d ago

Probably the amount of control he wanted. United tried to take shortcuts, and now finally, hopefully they have woken up. I just hope Poch gets time. His contract will be up just as we will start to get back on track, he will then need another 30 months to be challenging for top honours. It has to be seen for the total rebuild from top to bottom thats requied

eoin1w ago

The market has dried Up completely

peter.lynch1w ago

seems like United have been wanting Poch forever. He clearly wasn’t available and they had other plans at the time too, but seems like a match made in heaven now. Whether that works out to be the case remains to be seen…

caleb.sage1w ago

Think it just comes down to timing. Clearly United have always appreciated him, but things just didn’t line up for whatever reason.

jonathan.gorrie1w ago

I think for the first time, United need Poch more than he needs them. Plus, 2016 Mourinho was still a winner (ish). 2018, Ole was the popular choice, 21, 22, 24, Poch's stock had fallen and while Utd weren't amazing they probably thought they were a bit above him until now.

chillout1w ago

And Poch’s stock has risen since then ?

abiolakuye71w ago

Even we the fans need to be patient with the rebuilding process. True be told most of our players are average. We must go through a painful transition.

dantowen819511w ago

It’s very Man United. Shades of Mourinho really, we should have hired him five or six years earlier too. If I remember rightly, it was Poch vs Ten Hag in 2022. In fairness, given that he won us two trophies, maybe that was the right call at the time

knightinwhitesatin1w ago

We signed youngster Tyler Adjei from Reading and will join U18's he's 16 so we'll have 2 Tyler's lol primary postion right wing

knightinwhitesatin1w ago

I must admit I never reckoned him for the job when it was first mooted years ago

abiolakuye71w ago

I think they just got it right now. He is not a manager the board can just push around. He knows what he wants.

dancoombs1w ago

I think he will do well. We just need to back him

chillout1w ago

I hope you are right - but I don’t think this board allow managers to push them around.

antonymmartin841w ago

They’ve got desperate and turned to a manager who is yesterday’s man. I truly believe he will turn out to be a terrible appointment. Will be shocked if he’s still there this time next year

josh.barker1w ago

Just timing, no chance Spurs would have let him go at his peak really

jonny1w ago

Different owners, although they were also there in 2024, they were only getting their feet under the table and Poch had just had his Chelsea fall out! Would have loved him in 2016, 2018 and 2022, can only hope getting his dream job reawakens his desire and passion for management

chillout1w ago

So you think this was a Jim hire ?

martin.crawford1w ago

Nothing, as you will find out over the coming months

dale.odonnell1w ago

It's all to do with timing, so I ask, is this a good time for Pochettino to be arriving at United? I certainly hope so. Fingers and toes crossed.... you name it.

chillout1w ago

It’s a long time since Poch has been involved with a club in the bottom half of the table. Let’s hope he can turn it around - or at least get the club back up the table and delivering in Europe.

dancoombs1w ago

Timing was never right. 2016 and 2018 he was still at Tottenham, we were never negotiating with Levy. 2021 he was working at PSG. 2022 and 2024 we had talks but he had also just left PSG and Chelsea jobs, and both times Ten Hag won out. This time he is more refreshed - and he ticks all the boxes we need right now

james.brooke1w ago

It is fairly strange, as he was arguably a better appointment than whoever they eventually ended up with in all of those years. At this point the opposite is true. Sums United up over the last 10 years. Why didn't they look at Nagelsmann? He'd have been the one for me I think

dancoombs1w ago

I think Nagelsmann is a good coach but totally ill suited to our predicament now. I can already hear the bores like Paul Merson and Craig Burley talking about how he doesn’t know the PL after his first loss, and to an extent, they’d have a point. Difficult task to adapt mid-season to this league - we saw it with Amorim, and there’s no room for error atm

matthew.johns1w ago

I think now feels like the least optimal of those years to have Pochettino, it does feel a bit of a desperation move really.

dancoombs1w ago

By all accounts he is more refreshed than ever. I think the timing could work out very well

shamanth.jayaram1w ago

Better late than never? Wonder how different things would’ve been now if they had got him in 2018

dancoombs1w ago

If he had, Tottenham would never have reach the CL Final

kyle.archer1w ago

What's changed now? Man Utd probably just couldn't find a better alternative this time

chillout1w ago

I guess, having tried a few over the years, they would eventually run out of options! But it’s interesting that this time, a guy who allegedly held discussions for his dream job on five previous occasions is now suddenly the man. Maybe it’s just a reflection of how far United have fallen.

charlesjones1w ago

It’s called desperation I think.

dancoombs1w ago

I wouldn’t call it desperation. He is a coach with serious credentials who is proven in the Premier League

chillout1w ago

I get that - but it appears they may have looked at him a number of times before and it didn’t happen. What makes him right now ?