Talk Villa
Join the fan discussion on TalkingPoints around all the latest Aston Villa news, opinions, polls and updates.
649 comments
Domestic football returns đđđ How do you see the next five games shaping up, Villa fans?! đ€đȘ

jordan.harris3d ago
Very good chance of four wins here!
dantowen819513d ago
I think three home wins and a tough draw at Ipswich - I like Gary oâNeilâs side, think theyâll survive this year
Aston Villa vs Sunderland last 5 head-to-heads

markmarston4d ago
Canât see anything other than a Villa win here. Sunderland got a big one before the break but theyâve been pretty poor all season
Aston Villa signed Alysson from GrĂȘmio for ÂŁ10m in January, but what have you made of him so far this season?

peter.lynch10d ago
Really thought theyâd struggle to replace Rogers but heâs enjoyed a great start. Always looks dangerous and clearly knows how to find the back of the net âœïž
jameslloyd14.jl10d ago
Looks really talented. Quicker than Rogers and probably even better close control too. Will have to keep a close eye on him infront of goal but the talent is there. Villa recruited so well in the summer
amirmir11d ago
What a find! Mbaye has started well, but it's Alysson who is looking like the ÂŁ60m player from PSG!
A few things will be on Villa fansâ minds at the moment: Is Emeryâs tactical approach becoming predictable ? is Zion Suzuki becoming a concern ? Are Villa too dependent on John McGinn ?
dantowen8195111d ago
Suzuki reminds me a bit of Vicario when he first came to Spurs. Great shot-stopper but if you struggle physically from set pieces, this league will take full advantage
Amid all the noise, Unai Emery is set to sign a new Aston Villa contract đđđ How do we feel, Villa fans? And how far can Emery take us?
amirmir17d ago
Unreal news. Another trophy incoming in the coming years, I am sure off it!
What have you made of Nicolas Jackson's start at Aston Villa so far? And how many goals do you see him scoring?

jameslloyd14.jl26d ago
Heâs brilliant and Emery will get the best out of him. Expect him to get 15+
jordan.harris27d ago
Heâs really surprised me. I donât know why because Emery should not be doubted
peter.lynch27d ago
Not sure I agree about that speed call⊠or maybe those City defenders were just pacy⊠đ big call but heâs hitting 15 in the league this season âœïž
Victor Lindelöf signed for Villa on a free last summer. What have you made of his performances during those 12 months?
A deserved MOTM display during the 1-0 win at Newcastle!
jordan.harris33d ago
Great signing on a free!
amirmir34d ago
Outstanding and underrated. Kamara, Tielemans and Lindelof are Villa's free transfers of recent times. Proves that market works.
Two wins in three now⊠Villa always start slow but I thought this might be the season they drop into the bottom half of the table. They are slowly proving me wrong. Whatâs the realistic goal for Unai Emeryâs side this term? đ€
james.brooke34d ago
Gotta be aiming for Champions League spots again. Canât rule them out of a surge up the table, obviously capable of winning a lot of games on the bounce as they showed last year, but theyâre not a title challenger. Another trophy should be the aim as well, FA Cup probably
markmarston34d ago
Blimey you reckon? I think top 7 would be a mega success. Even top 10 would be better than expected. Theyâve lost half of their side.
Mbaye, Manzambi and Jackson started together for the first time. Aston Villa scored six goals vs Fenerbahçe. What can the trio achieve in the PL this season?
dantowen8195137d ago
Jackson looks absolutely red hot. Maybe the most complete version of Jackson Iâve seen. I think he and Manzambi are such a good partnership with Jackson running in behind and Manzambi occupying the spaces he creates
dancoombs36d ago
Iâm impressed by Jackson too. While I thought the transfer fee was ridiculous at the time, Iâve been reconsidering that a little lately
amirmir37d ago
Centre back and a lack of Tielemans is my only worries. But these three look seriously good, and there is quality behind them. Aside from title challengers, everyone is indifferent in the PL,, which opens the door for this attack to fire us to Europe again. But a long way to go.
jameslloyd14.jl37d ago
Villa deserve so much credit for how theyâve replaced Watkins and Rogers. As good as they were, I think these guys can reach similar heights
Unai Emery's side yet to win at Villa Park this season. Will the three stands prove to be a problem, or is it just a poor excuse?
amirmir42d ago
Poor excuse. The team is showing very positive signs, you can't blame the three stands for the defending/individual mistakes.
Some early winter transfer noise is already emerging! What do you make of Aston Villa being linked with Endrick once again?
freddie46d ago
Most overhyped player in the world
jordan.harris46d ago
I donât get this at the minute. Great talent but another loan deal?
amirmir46d ago
Tbf, he does need a move, but Villa don't need him yet. I see him coming to the PL in Jan, it's just a case of where?
peter.lynch46d ago
Would absolutely love to see him in the prem, regardless of the club, get it done lads!
Another impressive performance from Johan Manzambi on national duty. Still getting back to full fitness, what is his ceiling this season, Villa fans?
dantowen8195147d ago
The sky is the limit. The interesting thing for me is where does Manzambi play? He and Jackson could be an elite partnership too - Jackson loves dragging defenders out of position, allowing Manzambi to drift into the spaces
amirmir49d ago
Such a silky player, so good on the eye and it looks like he will be our main creator this season. Just about staying fit and working out where he plays. Wide left, number ten or much deeper from midfield đ
Positive injury news for Aston Villa, including the return of Brian Madjo. What do you think the 17-year-old can achieve this season?
dantowen8195152d ago
He looks physically ready. An absolute chance magnet as well. Should be plenty of opportunities for him with Europe and the domestic cups Make him 2nd choice to Jackson
amirmir52d ago
Not selected in UCL squad đ Hope it changes for KO rounds. I can see Tammy leaving in Jan, tbh.
eoin52d ago
Looked really good in preseason I thought!
amirmir52d ago
Dethrone Tammy Abraham as the back-up striker. Don't hype him up too much, but he can play a supporting role to Jackson this season.
markmarston52d ago
Could notch seven or eight goals in all comps
Months after winning the Europa League with Aston Villa, Jadon Sancho is STILL a free agent. Are you surprised?
Tell us why, below...đ

jordan.harris53d ago
Very sad when players with this talent donât have the drive to make the most of it. Should get himself a move to a lesser club and look to prove himself again
jonny53d ago
Nope. He has a horrid attitude and hasnât played like the player he once was since 2022. He might be waiting a long time
leeclarke050854d ago
Not really. Attitude stinks.
Some light for Alejandro Garnacho!!! But which Aston Villa players need to up their game after the break?
amirmir56d ago
I didn't think I would be saying this, but defo Kamara. Pau Torres also, given that he is a starter too.
freddie56d ago
Kamara used to be so so good! Needs to find that form again
Emi Buendia could have left Villa last summer, but now he could extend his stay. What have you made of his rise?
jordan.harris58d ago
Such a classy player! Proving a steal really despite the previous setbacks
freddie59d ago
Such an underrated player!
dantowen8195159d ago
I didnât see this coming at all! He looked done at Villa as recently as 24/25. What a player heâs become for Emery. Not many have a better collection of goals either
What have you made of Aston Villa's season so far, and how would you grade it?
Tell us why below...đ

eoin61d ago
Im not betting against Emery. Remember how poorly they started last year, and they were in striking distance of arsenal by january
dantowen8195161d ago
You know what. Iâll give them a C - now that the new signings are being bed in, weâve seen a big improvement Jackson, Manzambi, Suzuki and Ruggeri are all excellent players. I think by Christmas Villa will be in a very different position
peter.lynch61d ago
C! Harsh to judge them this early on with the European commitments also, going to be a very tricky season balancing those two! But I back Emery to pull it off, top manager đ
Alejandro Garnacho now seems to be getting the Harvey Elliott treatment. Is his Villa career over before it has even started? đŹđŹđŹ
peter.lynch66d ago
Classic Garnacho⊠but I really did think there was potential for plenty of minutes for Villa given their busy campaign, clearly not. Rough look for him
dale.odonnell66d ago
They signed a player with a questionable reputation and heâs got off to a horrible start. This wonât end well and puts his career at a real crossroads.
amirmir66d ago
He can play on both flanks. His issue is George Hemmings has marched in front of him. Then you have McGinn, Manzambi, Mbaye, Alysson....all ahead of him! The int'l break is massive. We will know the answer to this by the end of November.
Villa are through to the next round of the Carabao Cup after a 3-1 victory against Coventry! Thoughts? đ€©

amirmir67d ago
Much better. Great win and still in the hat. Move forward. A long way to go. Cov are very small.
Is it time Emery hands starts to Mbaye, Manzambi and Harwood-Bellis for Villa's trip to Coventry?! đŠ
Tell us what changes you would make...đ

dantowen8195167d ago
Has to, presuming they are all fit to start. Barely anyone should be considered un-droppable at the moment, so this is a big opportunity for the new guys
dantowen8195167d ago
Iâm most excited to see Ruggeri - a top left back who I canât believe Atletico let go!
eoin67d ago
Very excited to see Mbaye in action , saying that as a Liverpool fan Who wanted to sign him. Hope he does well for villa
amirmir67d ago
All three defo have to start. Keep in Suszki just to see how he pings balls up top with a lot of pace there.
Taylor Harwood-Bellis since signing for Aston Villa: â Not in the UCL squad â Not made a matchday squad. Is it now time this changes, given Pau Torres' injury?
markmarston69d ago
Absolutely⊠THB is a top top player. Surprised heâs not feature yet?
amirmir69d ago
Emery likes to bed players in, that's why he hasn't fearured. THB coming in late didn't help either. Plus with so many leaving, he has gone with what was there last season, and it hasn't worked thus far!
jordan.harris69d ago
I wasnât convinced by this deal tbh but Villa are not the same force so itâs probably a good time to give him a chance to grow into the position
amirmir69d ago
Yes all day long. He needs to come in ASAP, starting with Cov. Hopefully he boosts a battered defence.
Aston Villa fail to win again as we are beaten by Nottingham Forest. What is going wrong at Villa Park?
will.butcher70d ago
Gonna need a season to gel, fans canât expect that much after so much change surely
kilham.max70d ago
A result of the exceptionally poor transfer window! Far too many outgoings and not enough quality coming in!
tom.procter70d ago
With so many top players leaving there was always gonna be a reasonable chance Villa would struggle. I back Emery to sort it out before too long though
Unai Emery has NEVER beaten Oliver Glasner during his career. Can he finally end that when Villa host Forest?
jordan.harris73d ago
Would love to see Villa get the win! Make a statement lads!
amirmir73d ago
Glasner has Emery's number, no doubt. But it's all about scoring the first goal, get that and we won't lose. MGW will score for them though!
Lift off for Villa! First win of the season and a massive three points to open our Champions League campaign. Who stood out?!
kilham.max75d ago
Such a fantastic result for the Villains. Jackson looked a menace. Some hope after a disappointing window!
jonathan.gorrie75d ago
McGinn class, Jackson good. AWB, not so muchâŠ
amirmir75d ago
Agree. AWB was poor. A lot of things wrong. Emery needs to work with him!
markmarston75d ago
That John McGinn finish was outrageous đ„đ„
Positive injury news for Villa! Johan Manzambi could be available for Forest. How excited are you to watch him play?
amirmir75d ago
Very! That final third needs some life and spark. Him and Mbaye are going to add serious attacking quality.
dantowen8195175d ago
Considering Villa havenât scored a goal yet, this canât come soon enough! Youâd back Manzambi to take the chances Buendia and McGinn missed vs Hull
Yet to make his debut, Leon Goretzka is out until after the international break. What do we think?
jordan.harris76d ago
It is difficult to see a downside to this signing. Obviously heâs not quite the player he once was, but even with a current injury, heâs still going to bring plenty to Villa
james.brooke76d ago
The UCL group runs until almost Feb now, so it shouldnât be a problem really. Frustrating but I do think heâll end up being a pretty good signing. Generally has been quite robust fitness wise so hopefully just a short term issue and thatâll be it
amirmir76d ago
The fact that he is part of the UCL squad and is out until after the break that annoys me. Not the fact that he is injured. Others could and should have been selected.
JoĂŁo Gomes to return! Tell us your Aston Villa predicted XI for Brugge, and what do you think of ours? đđȘđ„
amirmir76d ago
Hemmings deserves to keep his place. Mbaye isn't ready. The fullbacks, esp Maatsen are doing fine. The only other option I would consider is Garnacho.
What do we make of Unai Emery's current stance on George Hemmings and Alejandro Garnacho?
kilham.max76d ago
Agree with Emery here. Hemmings is a gem and certainly premier league level.
peter.lynch77d ago
Couldnât agree more with Emery, Hemmings is the man at the minute, looks good
amirmir77d ago
Hemmings looks so much better than last season. The power in his game has gone up a level. He deserves his starts. Garnacho needs time. This is normal for Emery not to start a new player straight away.
Leon Bailey's goodbye message to Villa fans after his permanent exit to Olympiacos. What did you make of his time at the club?
amirmir80d ago
That 23/24 season, he was unreal. A key reason why we got back into Europe and then the UCL. He weren't at it when he first joined, lift off under Emery, and then faded away towards the end. Still a success in my book.
A new contract is incoming for Lamare Bogarde. Do you think Aston Villa are making the right call?
dantowen8195181d ago
Might as well! Heâs shown some great flashes, should get more chances now in a rebuild. Nice, neat passer, needs to add more dynamism to his game
eoin81d ago
Need to see him perform now, been flashes but villa desperately Will need attacking output
amirmir81d ago
Yes, fantastic player, showing great signs of improvement, long way to go, but worth keeping!
Taylor Harwood-Bellis is a Villa player - what are your expectations for the new centre-back?
dantowen8195181d ago
Not sure. Hard to tell given how dreadful that Southampton side was
eoin82d ago
Think Hes quality. Will be a starter in no time with Konsa gone. Has all the qualities on and off the ball
Aston Villa have changed their mind on Tammy Abraham; he is set to stay! Is this the right call?
amirmir82d ago
Well, it's pretty clear, if he doesn't perform from now until Jan, then he will be gone in the winter.
DONE DEAL! Aston Villa sign Ibrahim Mbaye đš Thoughts?
amirmir82d ago
Emery is going to turn him into a machine.
eoin82d ago
The spot as main man is there for him now
jonathan.gorrie82d ago
Great signing! Weird window from Villa but squad does look decent
Aston Villa start the season with back-to-back defeats after losing against Arsenal. What has been the main reason for this slow start?
kyle.dimond82d ago
Expect Emery to turn things around but the concern is always whether this is giving him a reason to look for another job. Heâs basically having to build a whole new team again
david.comerford82d ago
I looked at the side yesterday and it was the kind of team Villa would have put out in the Carabao Cup last year, quality-wise. Very uninspiring
jamesshearman2383d ago
I wouldnât be worried yet. In Emery we trust. Jackson will score goals and they have more players to come into the XI
Finally, it looks like an Aston Villa player will be staying!!! What do we think of Villa's stance on Ian Maatsen?
amirmir83d ago
At that start of the summer, happy to sell. But now that everyone has left, he needs to stay.
Taylor Harwood-Bellis is reportedly closing in on a ÂŁ30m move from Southampton to Aston Villa đ Give us your initial reaction
callum_boyle84d ago
Solid signing but not any better than Konsa. But then again, itâs hard to find a replacement of that quality
Emi Martinez's message to Villa fans after leaving for Chelsea. Where does he rank among Villa's keepers of the past?
amirmir84d ago
Defo the best of the Prem era. Then it's between Emi, Jimmy Rimmer and Nigel Spink, European Cup-winning keepers, as to who is the best of all.
amirmir5h ago
Patience is needed. One minute we have a lack of control, then we have control but don't score. When we score four, we end up concecding the same amount. We are missing Tielemans more than anyone else. But it's because the spine has been ripped out. I have seen enough signs that things will be good. It just will be up and down for a while yet.
markmarston5h ago
Time to start Mbaye now? One of the lowest scorers in the division this seasonâŠ