
What would have happened if Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner played at the same time as Roger Federer and Rafael Nadal?
honariki212mo ago
I think these 2 would not have that many slams if they were in the Era of the Big 3. Watching the big 3 on YouTube when they were all at their peak it's pretty hard to argue against it. The raging bull vs the terminator vs the most beautiful player. Wouldn't that be a sight against the 2 young guns!!!
dougseward4mo ago
Fun tough question & it depends on the surface. With hard courts, they're peers. It wouldn't be domination. All would win a few. That said, Johnny Mac is just talkin' smack to say Sincaraz can beat the GOAT of clay in Rafa & the classy grassy GOAT that is Fed Express.
vs.iyer.vs8mo ago
I don't think both Jannik and Carlos would have been the favourite against peek Rafa at RG and at Australian open peek Novak would have been the favourite. Novak beat Carlos at Australian open 2025 and best Jannik in 2026 semi. As age is creeping 39, Novak is no more a force as he was earlier. Novak is unable to reenergize after a Marathon match.
geemymd8mo ago
I think they would totally be competitive and beat them. if you took them today and sent them with a time machine but it's also rhetorical, because first it will never happen and second Carlos and Jannik would not be what they are today if they didn't grow up in Big 3 era and if the rest of the atp tour didn't have to adapt to that level.
larryaldridge649mo ago
Well i do not think the number of grand slams necessarly make you the greatest nobody in the history of tennis will ever beat Nadal's 14 French open titles. NO ONE! THE MOST OF ANY ONE SLAM IN HISTORY!
debramackillop9mo ago
When comparing Carlos & Yannick, remember sinner almost 2.5 years older & on the tour that much longer. So Carlos accomplishments even more impressive.
devbha57649mo ago
I am of the view that both Nadal and Federer had the ability to unnerve their opponets....They would not let you play or dictate the game....Just see the Wimbledon 2008 Final Federer vs Nadal and Australian open Final between Nadal and Medvedev....Federer was relentless on grass and Nadal adapted to Federer's aggression and neutralized Medvedev too.
asodipo9mo ago
It would have been the Fantastic 4
fnouneh11mo ago
Great is NOT in numbers! It's in Style Shotmaking Making it look easy Not dropping a sweat Respectful Never broke a racket Never left a match Managing anger The Great Solomon said: He who controls himself is GREATER than he who controls a city! Wasn't he talking about Federer?
peterwyusaf2mo ago
I couldn't have put it better myself. ππ
rockyoda9mo ago
Many players have broken rackets. Look at Kyrigos.
daviescallum4211mo ago
I think the Slams would've been split more evenly. Alcaraz & Sinner deserve their place at the table for what they've done already
debramackillop9mo ago
Remember Carlos only 22 - his accomplishments already are incredible. He won his first final in all 4 grand slams.
peter.lynch11mo ago
Still think Rafa and Roger would have been able to dominate to be honest!
george.patten11mo ago
I doubt anyone would've reached 20 Slams
matthew.johns11mo ago
There is a chance that no male player would have 20+ Grand Slams if their careers completely aligned - an Alcaraz/Federer match would have been incredible!
john.verrall11mo ago
It's so hard to compare. But I think the biggest loser would have been Murray, who may not have ever won a Slam!