TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk Premier League

Why do brilliant players rarely ever make brilliant managers? 🤔

johnverrall114w ago

Zidane, Cryuff & Pep all did alright!

pranav.shahaney4w ago

I think it’s a lot to do with their expectations of their teammates. Brilliant players had something different about them and their peers didn’t. That’s why they struggle to understand that the things which came naturally to them as players, do not usually happen with those they’re coaching. They may have issues dumbing things down

lancecpljones3284w ago

@pranav.shahaney I agree. Their skill set is way above those of lower league players and not feasible to teach prem tricks and tactics to them. Can't think of any top pro who was successful in managing a league one or two club successfully. Alan Ball, Bobby Charlton, Emlyn Hughes, to name just a few.

caleb.sage4w ago

Some get fast tracked to top jobs too quickly. They’re just not qualified for the role they’ve been given.

aryansurajc4w ago

I think it’s just that they’ve already invested so much in playing. Management is a whole different experience, and some of them aren’t able to give their best because their best in the sport is already behind them, so perhaps that’s why.

james.brooke4w ago

Sometimes they do. Carrick was about as good as a player as he is as a coach mind you. Nothing special

lee.connor4w ago

Potentially a lack of serious interest as they’re already so financially secure. Also, management is a completely different skill/mind set to being a player. Some have done it mind, Guardiola, Alonso, Fabregas, Conte, Ancelotti, to name a few.

lrandall12104w ago

I think some of them think that it’ll be the same as playing the game. It’s totally different and comes with bigger responsibility

kyle.dimond4w ago

I just think it’s largely a case by case basis. Being a great player doesn’t mean you are a great man manager or tactician. It also doesn’t mean you can’t be those things. Sure, you’re still working in football, but it’s two different skill sets

antonymmartin844w ago

It’s because the game was so different when they were brilliant players. They try to copy the tactics and systems that works well when they were in their primes. Theee are exceptions of course, like Zidane and Ancelotti, but they are both managers who didn’t rely on tactics anyway, just motivational skills

jameslloyd14.jl4w ago

Think often the star players can land a big job through their name alone, skipping the years of experience and lower-level coaching where a lot of managers learn the trade

dantowen819514w ago

Good point. That’s why I’m disappointed it didn’t work out for Rooney. I admired him going to Derby and Plymouth

jonathan.gorrie4w ago

Bobby Charlton used to ask Preston players to do things that just came naturally to him and he got frustrated at their level. Sometimes when a player is just naturally and instinctively so good, it’s hard for them to put what they would do into words.

chillout4w ago

Maybe it’s a myth, as there have been some great players who became great managers - Johan Cruyff and Zidane. Dalglish is in with a shout and Pep and Conte. Simeone too. Ancelotti and now Arteta ? Then there’s Shearer, Gerrard and Lampard. Tony Adams, Paul Ince, Neville, Rooney - all high profile failures. Great English players struggle to transition though.

jonathan.gorrie4w ago

There’s a great story of Hoddle showing England players FKs in training and Beckham gets it wrong so he steps right away and smashes it top corner 😂 can’t be great for morale!

charlesjones4w ago

Also you can get former top players who can’t cope with coaching footballers who just can’t do what they can. Remember reading about Mark Hughes somewhere basically wanting all of his players to play to his level, they just couldn’t do it because they weren’t that level and never would be.

jameslloyd14.jl4w ago

Henry was like this when he started out in management too

markmarston4w ago

charlesjones4w ago

It’s a completely different skillset in many ways. Top players often play on instinct and use their physical advantages, while it’s completely a mental game management.

dale.odonnell4w ago

Being a top manager just isn’t easy.

dale.odonnell4w ago

A lot of former MUFC players have gone good jobs at clubs. Some of the clubs too were at fault. I’ll back Solskjaer any day, even if he did terrible at Cardiff.

dancoombs4w ago

I still think Roy Keane could succeed if he would back himself. Gave up and settled on punditry a bit too easily

kilham.max4w ago

I'm not sure it's so rare - we've had pep, ancelotti, cryuff, rijkaard, Zidane, deschamps. There is a long list of excellent players who have achieved a lot in managerial roles.

brook0104w ago

Coming here to say this, we had this discussion last night and these names were quickly pulled out as contradictions!

leeclarke05084w ago

Different skill sets. If you're a brilliant footballer you won't know how you want a team to setup as a manager until much later on. It's like asking why a good electrician doesn't make a good plumber really. A much different job

harveyleonard994w ago

Wonder if there’s a tendency to throw them into the deep end far too quickly due to club connections. No way Carrick was ready to lead United

kyle.archer4w ago

Being a talented player does not mean you are also a brilliant leader or tactician - and there are plenty of strong coaches who were not elite players.

markmarston4w ago

Lesser players also understand their limitations so when they become managers they are acutely aware of how to get the best out of a group of players and play to their strengths

dakir.thanveer4w ago

Also, was Carrick that much of a brilliant footballer? He's not in the same league as Gerrard/Scholes/Lampard etc...makes me wonder why he is the featured pic here haha

james.brooke4w ago

He has become unbelievably overrated. Nobody at the time thought he was anything other than a cog at United. Can’t believe some of the things I’ve seen said about him in the last few years. Was never nailed on to start at United under Fergie

markmarston4w ago

I mean he was part of dynasty at United… won multiple titles and the UCL. Carrick would be worth £80m these days

dakir.thanveer4w ago

Think there are various factors and many of them have been pointed above. The most brilliant players tend to 'Athletes', they rely on talent and work on the pitch. The players who make brilliant managers are usually known to have a better understanding of the game (Defenders and midfielders)

tom.procter4w ago

Football management is such a hard discipline. Maybe some give so much to their playing career and are so locked in that there’s simply no time to lay the proper groundwork required to become a top manager

markmarston4w ago

Yeah this is exactly right and precisely what happened to Gary Neville

george.patten4w ago

Maybe it has something to do with the brilliant players being so good they don’t know how to coach ‘worse players’ If you’re Ronaldo or Messi, it’s second nature to make this run or go for that shot, to take a step back and teach must be a challenge

markmarston4w ago

Yeah this is defo a factor…

jordan.harris4w ago

I don’t think the best players start thinking about management until they are well past their peak. Many average players will switch some of their focus to what is next a lot earlier in their careers

markmarston4w ago

Brilliant point this

dakir.thanveer4w ago

This, too! Yes. Was thinking exactly the same

peter.lynch4w ago

They had the talent and the skills on the pitch rather than on the sidelines, simple as that. Players who end their careers earlier have time to learn about coaching and what it takes to be a top manager, whereas many who retire and quickly jump into coaching make that move far too soon

jamesshearman234w ago

My theory is most world-class players relied on their talent more than their understanding of the game. That’s why defenders/central midfielders generally make better managers than forwards. It also means they can’t relate to players with less talent than they had

david.comerford4w ago

Yeah, the best players ultimately get there on talent. They may have the IQ to go with it, but natural ability matters more and that doesn't translate to the dugout

ahambly234w ago

Completely agree with this

markmarston4w ago

It’s an interesting topic & I think it comes down to 2 things… managers who didn’t have much of a playing career have to work their way up & have a more thorough schooling. Secondly, they may have more hunger to succeed & earn new contracts. A lot of the best players are already multi millionaires so it’s more of a hobby for them than a job they NEED…

matthew.johns4w ago

Completely agree with this. It’s understandable that top players get bigger managerial jobs, but it doesn’t do them any favours.