TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← 2025/26 season

Do Manchester United need to replace Luke Shaw this summer?

Or do you trust Harry Amass and Patrick Dorgu going forward👀

taylorjoe415mo ago

Definitely keep Shaw. I know he had a decent season just gone. He’s had a lot of injury issues but got loads of experience & still a top player but 31 we need a good back up to bed in before Luke ends his career

aunguramos5mo ago

Ya for the next 2-3 seasons basing on his age now

stephenjholmes15mo ago

Don't see why people are calling for Shaw to be replaced. He is one of the best English left backs. Yes he won't be playing every game next season, but for him to play every Premier league match shows he is getting back to reliability. One of the best when fit.

robdunning415mo ago

I agree Shaw has had good season, but his contract was and is up for renewal, also there was the world cup coming up. He was hoping for a seat on the plane, prior to these two issues he was on a constant sick note, let's see next season if hes suddenly injured again, but he wouldn't get a massive contract this time round.

robdunning415mo ago

Was he really injured or was it because UTD weren't achieving anything, and miraculously hes OK contract negotiations coming up and world cup!!!!!!

mwood31mw6mo ago

Shaw keep him

stephenjholmes16mo ago

It will be interesting to see Diego Leon next season

malcolmcragg6mo ago

WE NEED TO KEEP DORGU, HE IS NOW A FLYER WHO COMES INSIDE WITH POWER WHO CAN ALSO SCORE...VERY MUCH LIKE CITYS DOKU IS

dantowen819516mo ago

That Newcastle performance when he was on the right ☄️

dantowen819516mo ago

100%. Amass is recovering from a bad injury and I think Dorgu is a winger. I’d actually like two flying full backs on either flank, though Dalot still has a big role to play

theoldcrocks6mo ago

Dalot to me is a ditherer, I fall asleep waiting for him to take a Throw In (shy). Unfortunate Luke Shaw is slowing down and needs to be replaced.

reecefindlater6mo ago

We had alvaro Fernandes and let him go, that was a huge mistake. I havent seen Harry play but if he has the same potential as alvaro then we need to bring him into the first team next season. Dorgu is versatile which could aid that decision

dantowen819516mo ago

Where do you reckon Dorgu ends up? Personally, I want him as a flying winger next season, on either flank really

davecarey287mo ago

I think he's got great experience but has lost some of his speed. Always a worry about getting injured

dantowen819516mo ago

That’s my concern, too. We need a flyer to overlap Cunha and make space for him to cut in

christopheropio19937mo ago

Yes

united_soksek357mo ago

Shaw is poor, (unreliable and way past his supposed exit really,similar to Phil Jones), but dalot is piss poor. Both should never be near first xi, and should be sold to make room for better upgrades. Instead of LB, ill play Maz at RB.. try to incorporate academy players at LB if possible ❤️‍🔥

vatsal15919967mo ago

Harry Amass can be the guy, and if Diego Leon pans out our LB position is sorted for the next decade

vatsal15919967mo ago

Nobody is matching his wages. Thank the Glazers for that. I'd just let him leave for free next summer by not extending him

stephenjholmes15mo ago

If he is still playing at the current standard, there is no need to let him go on a free.

cr77mo ago

Now he’s missed out on the England squad, he’ll not care about playing!

barrymorris4168mo ago

YES as soon as bloody possible

cr78mo ago

I like Amass as an option to step up, but feel we’re always going to be a Shaw injury away from crisis

dale.odonnell6mo ago

That is the biggest concern at left-back. Now that we’ve Champions League secured there’s more money to play with.

dale.odonnell8mo ago

Shaw doesn’t need to be replaced, but stiff competition with the idea of that player being the long-term left back to eventually replace. He will struggle next season with extra games. It must be among the priorities this summer.

barrymorris4168mo ago

Yes shaw needs replacing as soon as possible your mad if you think differently

dancoombs8mo ago

I want to see Dorgu in an attacking role - so we will need alternative to Shaw. Amass, maybe...