TalkingPoints
TalkingPoints Join over 80,000 readers

Your News, Your Views.

← Talk Cricket

Joe Root is set to become England's Test captain again! Give us your first reaction 👇

pranav.shahaney2mo ago

Having the captaincy gives him the added pressure he just does not need. The ECB need to think long term and give it to someone they see in the side for the next 7-10 years.

amirmir2mo ago

This current regime loves killing off our legends, i.e Anderson and Stokes. If this goes wrong for Root, like it did last time, it will finish his career. Very bad call!

jamesshearman232mo ago

He’ll retire after we lose a home Ashes. What a mess we’re in 🤦‍♂️

vatsal2mo ago

Should have gone all-in on Brook. This is a step back, and if his batting suffers (again), England have shot themselves in the foot twice

lee.connor2mo ago

There’s no alternative, that’s the issue. Brook is not test captain material, he’s too erratic and hot headed, despite being a great player. Root will be fine for now.

leeclarke05082mo ago

Not really sure about this. Shows a complete lack of faith in Brook and for such an England great his record as captain was feeble when he packed it up last time.

lrandall12102mo ago

Seems a bit desperate. What happens when he retires?

jameslloyd14.jl2mo ago

Does he even want it? Doesn’t strike me as the type of character to turn it down if they asked him to do it

freddie2mo ago

I don’t hate it tbh, literally who else??

shamanth.jayaram2mo ago

Probably deserves a second chance because of how good a player he is, but don’t think it’s the wisest choice. Captaincy could also affect his batting and that’s definitely something England can’t afford in tests

rebecca.braybrook2mo ago

I completely agree! I think the ECB are stuck between a bit of a rock and a hard place with this decision! I think it’s wise to go with experience after our performance at the last Ashes!

charlesjones2mo ago

I guess the question is what’s the alternative? Nobody else in the set up seems ready for it.

jordan.harris2mo ago

Correct decision. Brook isn’t ready imo, so seemed the only other option. We desperately need some leaders to emerge though

jamesshearman232mo ago

Would rather have taken a punt on someone else. Root will struggle as captain, probably score less runs and want to retire next year

chillout2mo ago

I don’t think he has learned much since his first stint. And do the results under him first time around justify his return ? You have to think he has only been appointed there is no one else.

jamesshearman232mo ago

That’s the only reason he’s been appointed. He doesn’t enjoy captaincy and he’s not good at it either

harveyleonard992mo ago

Not a fan. He’s one of the greatest of all time but we have enough evidence to say he is not a good captain

jonathan.gorrie2mo ago

Pretty alarming he’s the only viable option